SUBJECT COMPANY INFORMATION |
IDENTITY AND BACKGROUND OF FILING PERSON |
PAST CONTACTS, TRANSACTIONS, NEGOTIATIONS AND AGREEMENTS |
• | the vesting and cash settlement of outstanding Company Options with exercise prices per Share below the Merger Consideration in connection with the Merger; |
• | vesting and cash settlement of outstanding Company RSUs in connection with the Merger; |
• | the potential receipt of severance benefits by executive officers pursuant to their Severance Agreements (as defined below), which provides for certain severance payments or benefits in the event of a qualifying termination during the period beginning three months prior to and ending twelve months following the completion of the Merger; |
• | the potential receipt of a special cash bonus by executive officers to offset the excise taxes that may become payable by them under Section 4999 of the Code as a result of the payments and benefits that become due or payable to them in connection with the Transactions; and |
• | the entitlement to indemnification benefits in favor of directors and officers of the Company. |
Name | Number of Shares Beneficially Owned (#)(1) | Implied Cash Consideration for Shares ($) | ||||
Executive Officers | ||||||
Paul A. Wagner, Ph.D. | 85,482 | 6,582,114 | ||||
Antony A. Riley | 45,795 | 3,526,215 | ||||
Directors | ||||||
Scott Brun, M.D. | — | — | ||||
Stephen Doberstein, Ph.D. | — | — | ||||
Barbara Finck, M.D. | — | — | ||||
David Gryska | 5,940 | 457,380 | ||||
Shiv Kapoor | — | — | ||||
Steven Kornfeld | 3,960 | 304,920 | ||||
Rich Vincent | — | — | ||||
(1) | In calculating the number of Shares beneficially owned for this purpose, Shares underlying outstanding Company Options (whether or not currently exercisable) and Company RSUs held by each individual are excluded. |
Name | Number of Unvested In-the- Money Options (#) | Value of Unvested In-the- Money Options ($)(1) | Number of Vested In-the- Money Options (#) | Value of Vested In- the-Money Options ($)(1) | Number of Unvested Company RSUs (#) | Value of Unvested Company RSUs ($)(2) | Number of Underwater Options (#)(3) | ||||||||||||||
Executive Officers | |||||||||||||||||||||
Paul A. Wagner, Ph.D. | 1,189,854 | 72,427,459 | 573,011 | 38,155,570 | 186,011 | 14,322,847 | 5,400 | ||||||||||||||
Antony A. Riley | 256,779 | 15,871,728 | 195,641 | 13,098,984 | 63,726 | 4,906,902 | 4,699 | ||||||||||||||
Directors | |||||||||||||||||||||
Scott Brun, M.D. | 17,223 | 1,196,310 | 18,777 | 1,254,750 | 18,353 | 1,413,181 | — | ||||||||||||||
Stephen Doberstein, Ph.D. | 17,223 | 1,196,310 | 19,777 | 1,291,000 | 18,353 | 1,413,181 | — | ||||||||||||||
Barbara Finck, M.D. | 17,556 | 1,198,728 | 24,610 | 1,580,500 | 18,353 | 1,413,181 | — | ||||||||||||||
David Gryska | 17,223 | 1,196,310 | 18,777 | 1,253,750 | 18,353 | 1,413,181 | — | ||||||||||||||
Shiv Kapoor | 18,001 | 1,250,715 | 14,999 | 1,042,405 | 18,353 | 1,413,181 | — | ||||||||||||||
Steven Kornfeld | 17,223 | 1,196,310 | 18,777 | 1,241,250 | 18,353 | 1,413,181 | 2,000 | ||||||||||||||
Rich Vincent | 18,001 | 1,250,715 | 14,999 | 1,042,405 | 18,353 | 1,413,181 | — | ||||||||||||||
(1) | The estimated value of the in-the-money options equals the aggregate number of Shares underlying such in-the-money options multiplied by the amount by which the Merger Consideration exceeds the per Share exercise price of such in-the-money options. |
(2) | The estimated value of Company RSUs equals the aggregate number of Shares underlying such Company RSUs multiplied by the Merger Consideration. |
(3) | Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the Merger Agreement, at the Effective Time, each underwater option that is then outstanding and unexercised, whether or not vested, will be cancelled at the Effective Time without consideration and will have no further force or effect. |
• | A single, lump sum payment equal to 18 months (or 24 months with respect to Mr. Wagner) of the executive officer’s then-current annual base salary, less applicable withholdings; |
• | A single, lump sum payment equal to 150% (or 200% with respect to Mr. Wagner) of the executive officer’s then-effective annual target bonus, less applicable withholdings; |
• | Payment of premiums for coverage under the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1985, as amended, for the executive officer and the executive officer’s eligible dependents for up to 18 months (or 24 months with respect to Mr. Wagner); and |
• | Vesting acceleration as to 100% of the then-unvested Shares subject to each of the executive officer’s then-outstanding compensatory equity awards issued by the Company that are subject to time-based vesting conditions (and in the case of an equity award subject to performance-based vesting conditions, such equity award will be treated as set forth in the applicable agreement evidencing such equity award). |
• | 50% of each employee’s annual bonus will be paid by the Company on or as soon as practicable following the Closing, but in no event more than 2.5 months following the end of the calendar year in which the Closing occurs, subject to the applicable employee’s continued employment through the Closing; and |
• | 50% of each employee’s annual bonus will be paid by the Company on or as soon as practicable after December 31, 2026, but in no event later than March 15, 2027, subject to the applicable employee’s continued employment with the Company or, if the employee agrees to provide consulting or transition services, provision of consulting or transition services to the Company, through December 31, 2026. |
THE SOLICITATION OR RECOMMENDATION |
• | Financial Terms of the Offer and Certainty of Value. The Company Board considered the aggregate potential value and form of consideration to be received in the Transactions by the Company’s stockholders, and considered: |
○ | that Parent’s offer of $77.00 per Share represents a compelling premium to recent market prices for the Shares, including: |
• | an approximately 41% premium over the closing price per Share on July 24, 2026, the last full trading day prior to the execution of the Merger Agreement; |
• | an approximately 84% to premium over the volume-weighted average price during the 16-calendar day period between July 9, 2026, the first full trading day after the Company announced positive results from the FB102 Phase 1b Vitiligo Study, and July 24, 2026; |
• | an approximately 117% premium over the volume-weighted average price of the Shares during the 30-calendar day period ending on July 24, 2026; and |
• | an approximately 29% premium to highest closing price per Share over the 52 week period ending on July 24, 2026. |
○ | the current and historical market prices of the Shares, including the market performance and volatility of the Shares relative to general market indices and the risks, challenges and uncertainties associated with continued development and commercialization efforts for FB102, and funding needs and the availability of financing on attractive terms; |
○ | the Final Parent Proposal of $77.00 per Share was an increase of $12.00 per Share from the Initial Parent Proposal; |
○ | the Company Board’s belief that Parent’s offer of $77.00 per Share represented Parent’s “best and final” offer; and |
○ | that the Final Parent Proposal of $77.00 per Share is payable solely in cash, which allows the Company’s stockholders to realize immediate and certain value in respect of their Shares, especially when viewed against the internal and external risks and uncertainties around results of the Company’s clinical trials and the execution of the Company’s standalone business plan, including the long-term risks associated with funding and executing the development and commercialization of FB102, and the potential impact of such risks and uncertainties on the trading price of the Shares. |
• | The Company’s Business, Financial Condition, Prospects and Execution Risks. The Company Board’s assessment encompassed the Company’s then-current financial condition, business, drug candidates, prospects, and competitive positioning. As part of this analysis, the Company Board considered the continuation of the Company’s current business plan and the potential opportunities that those plans and strategies presented against, among other things, various execution and other risks to executing those plans. Among the potential risks identified by the Company Board were: |
○ | The Company’s prospects and competitive position as an independent public company. In this regard, the Company Board considered: |
• | (1) Risks relating to the macroeconomic, political, regulatory, industry and market conditions negatively impacting the valuations of, and the outlook for, biopharmaceutical companies such as the Company, (2) the risks and costs associated with clinical trials and preclinical studies, advancing drug candidates into clinical trials and successfully completing clinical trials, including uncertainty around the results of clinical trials, (3) other risks and costs associated with successfully developing, launching and commercializing FB102, (4) the risks and costs associated with building and maintaining the Company’s commercial organization, and (5) the uncertainties associated with pricing and reimbursement of FB102 and any other product candidates for which the Company may receive marketing approval; |
• | The Company’s competitive position in the biopharmaceutical industry and competitive risks, including potential future competition from larger and better-funded companies that have competitive advantages from their broader commercial scope and economies of scale in pricing; |
• | Other risk factors described in the Company’s other filings with the SEC, as listed in the section of this Schedule 14D-9 titled “Item 8. Additional Information—Forward-Looking Statements.” |
○ | The funding needs to execute the Company’s business plan and the availability, timing and cost of financing alternatives. |
○ | The fact that achieving management’s financial projections entails significant execution risk, as more fully described in the section titled “Item 4. The Solicitation or Recommendation—Certain Financial Projections.” |
• | Best Value Reasonably Obtainable and Implied Premium. The belief of the Company Board that the Offer Price represents the best value reasonably obtainable for the Shares, taking into account the familiarity of the Company Board with the Company’s business, operations, prospects, business strategy, assets, liabilities and general financial condition on a historical and prospective basis. In this regard, the Company Board noted the significant premium reflected in the Offer Price, as described above under “Financial Terms of the Offer and Certainty of Value,” and that the Offer Price of $77.00 per Share reflected multiple increases obtained by the Company Board over the course of its negotiations with Parent, from the Initial Parent Proposal of $65.00 per Share to the Final Parent Proposal of $77.00 per Share. The Company |
• | Best Strategic Alternative for Maximizing Stockholder Value. The assessment of the Company Board that none of the possible alternatives to the Transactions (including the possibility of continuing to operate the Company as an independent public company, and the desirability and perceived risks of those alternatives, as well as the potential benefits and risks to the Company’s stockholders of those alternatives and the timing and likelihood of effecting such alternatives) was reasonably likely to present superior opportunities for the Company to create greater value for its stockholders, taking into account execution risks as well as business, competitive, financial, industry, legal, market and regulatory risks. In particular, the Company Board considered whether other potential counterparties might have an interest in, and the financial capacity to execute, an acquisition of the Company or another strategic transaction involving the Company, and determined that soliciting the interest of additional potential acquirers (1) was not likely to yield a more attractive acquisition proposal and (2) would jeopardize the successful execution of a transaction with Parent in the near term, as more fully described in the section titled “Item 4. The Solicitation or Recommendation—Background of the Offer and the Merger.” |
• | Financial Presentation and Opinion of Guggenheim Securities. The financial presentation and the opinion, each dated as of July 26, 2026, of Guggenheim Securities to the Company Board as to the fairness, from a financial point of view and as of the date of the opinion, of the Offer Price to be received by the holders of Shares (other than Excluded Shares (as defined in the section under the caption “—Financial Analyses and Opinion”)), which opinion was based on and subject to the matters considered, the procedures followed, the assumptions made and various limitations of and qualifications to the review undertaken, as more fully described below under the caption “—Financial Analyses and Opinion.” |
• | Negotiations with Parent and Terms of the Merger Agreement. The terms and conditions of the Merger Agreement, which was the product of robust, arm’s-length negotiations and during which the Company Board was advised by Wilson Sonsini. In this regard, the factors considered by the Company Board included: |
○ | The Company’s rights under the Merger Agreement to respond to unsolicited acquisition proposals from third parties; |
○ | The belief of the Company Board that the terms of the Merger Agreement would not preclude third parties from making a superior proposal; |
○ | The Company Board’s ability, under certain circumstances, to withdraw or modify its recommendation that holders of Shares tender their Shares in the Offer; |
○ | The Company’s ability, under certain circumstances and subject to compliance with the terms of the Merger Agreement, to terminate the Merger Agreement to accept a superior proposal from a third party, which, the Company Board believed that the size of the termination fee was reasonable, generally consistent with similar fees payable in comparable transactions, and not preclusive of other offers; |
○ | The provision in the Merger Agreement requiring Parent to, under certain circumstances, extend the Offer beyond the initial expiration date of the Offer or, if applicable, subsequent expiration dates, if the conditions to the consummation of the Offer are not satisfied or waived as of such date; and |
○ | The Company’s ability, under the circumstances specified in the Merger Agreement, to specifically enforce the terms and provisions of the Merger Agreement, in addition to any other remedy to which the Company is entitled to consummate the Merger. |
• | Reasonable Likelihood of Consummation. The belief of the Company Board that the Offer and the Merger were reasonably likely to be consummated, including the belief that the regulatory approvals required to consummate the Offer and the Merger were reasonably likely to be obtained. |
• | No Financing Condition. The fact that the Transactions are not subject to a financing condition. |
• | Timing of Completion. The anticipated timing of the consummation of the Offer and the Merger and the Company Board’s conclusion that the Offer and the Merger were capable of being completed in a reasonable timeframe and in an orderly manner, reducing the period during which the Company’s business would be subject to the potential uncertainty of the Transactions being consummated and the closing risks. |
• | Business Reputation of Parent. The assessment of the Company Board that the business reputation and financial resources of Parent supported the conclusion that the Offer and the Merger were reasonably likely to be consummated successfully and in an appropriately expedited manner. |
• | Appraisal Rights. The fact that appraisal rights under Section 262 of the DGCL are available to the Company’s stockholders who do not believe that the Offer Price represents fair consideration for their Shares. |
• | Risks Associated with Failure to Consummate the Offer and the Merger. The possibility that a majority of the Company’s outstanding Shares might not be validly tendered in the Offer and the Merger might not be consummated in a timely manner or at all, and if the Transactions are not consummated, that: (1) the Company’s directors, senior management and other employees will have expended extensive time and effort and will have experienced significant distractions from their work on behalf of the Company during the pendency of the Transactions; (2) the Company will have incurred significant transaction and other costs (many of which are payable whether or not the Offer and the Merger are consummated); (3) the Company’s relationships with current or prospective strategic or commercial partners, employees and investors may be adversely affected, which could cause an adverse impact on the Company’s operating results; (4) the trading price of the Shares could be adversely affected; (5) the contractual and legal remedies available to the Company if Parent were to seek to terminate the Merger Agreement may be insufficient from a variety of perspectives, costly to pursue, or both; and (6) the potential for an adverse perception among the Company’s current and prospective patients for clinical trials, business partners, suppliers, vendors, employees and investors, which could cause an adverse impact on the Company’s operating results. |
• | No Stockholder Participation in Future Growth or Earnings. The nature of the cash consideration in the Transactions means that the Company’s stockholders will not participate in the Company’s future earnings or growth. |
• | Other Strategic Options. The other potential alternative strategies available to the Company as an independent company, which, despite significant uncertainty, could potentially have resulted in a more successful and valuable company. |
• | No Ability to Solicit an Alternative Transaction. The restrictions in the Merger Agreement on the Company’s ability to solicit competing proposals from the date of the Merger Agreement, until the consummation of the Merger or termination of the Merger Agreement. |
• | Regulatory Clearances. The Merger cannot be completed until the waiting period applicable to the Merger under the HSR Act has expired or otherwise been terminated, which subjects the Merger to potential delay and risk. |
• | Termination Fee Payable to Parent. The requirement that the Company pay the termination fee of $65,000,000 to Parent under certain circumstances following termination of the Merger Agreement, including if the Company Board terminates the Merger Agreement to accept a superior proposal, pursuant to the terms of the Merger Agreement. The Company Board considered the potentially dampening effect that the Company termination fee could have on a third party’s interest in making a proposal to acquire the Company. |
• | Impact of Interim Restrictions on Company’s Business Pending the Completion of the Merger. The restrictions in the Merger Agreement on the conduct of the Company’s business prior to the consummation of the Transactions, which have the potential to delay or prevent the Company from undertaking strategic initiatives before the completion of the Transactions that, absent the Merger Agreement, the Company might have pursued. |
• | Potential Effects of the Announcement of the Merger. The potential effects of the public announcement of the Offer and the Merger, including the: (1) effects on the Company’s employees, clinical trial patients, partners, suppliers, vendors and operating results; (2) impact on the Company’s ability to attract and retain management, research, medical and technical personnel; and (3) potential for litigation in connection with the Merger, and the risk of incurring substantial costs and expenses in connection therewith. |
• | Taxable Consideration. The fact that stockholders’ receipt of cash in exchange for Shares in the Offer and the Merger will generally be a taxable transaction for U.S. federal income tax purposes for the Company’s stockholders that are U.S. persons. |
• | Interests of the Company’s Directors and Executive Officers. The fact that the Company’s directors and executive officers may have interests in the Transactions which may be different from, or in addition to, those of the Company’s other stockholders, as more fully described in the section of this Schedule 14D-9 titled “Item 3. Past Contacts, Transactions, Negotiations and Agreements—Arrangements with Current Executive Officers and Directors of the Company” above. |
Fiscal Year Ending December 31 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
($ millions) | 2026E | 2027E | 2028E | 2029E | 2030E | 2031E | 2032E | 2033E | 2034E | 2035E | ||||||||||||||||||||
Total Net Revenue | $— | $— | $— | $— | $48 | $226 | $539 | $964 | $1,457 | $1,795 | ||||||||||||||||||||
EBIT(1) | $(85) | $(77) | $(118) | $(195) | $(125) | $(66) | $142 | $438 | $667 | $824 | ||||||||||||||||||||
Less: Tax Expense(2) | $— | $— | $— | $— | $— | $— | $(35) | $(109) | $(167) | $(206) | ||||||||||||||||||||
Less: Change in Net Working Capital | $— | $— | $— | $— | $(5) | $(18) | $(31) | $(42) | $(49) | $(34) | ||||||||||||||||||||
Unlevered Free Cash Flow(3) | $(85) | $(77) | $(118) | $(195) | $(130) | $(84) | $75 | $286 | $451 | $584 | ||||||||||||||||||||
2036E | 2037E | 2038E | 2039E | 2040E | 2041E | 2042E | 2043E | 2044E | 2045E | |||||||||||||||||||||
Total Net Revenue | $2,091 | $2,319 | $2,547 | $2,771 | $3,015 | $3,281 | $3,573 | $3,891 | $2,119 | $1,155 | ||||||||||||||||||||
EBIT(1) | $964 | $1,069 | $1,175 | $1,282 | $1,395 | $1,522 | $1,657 | $1,808 | $985 | $537 | ||||||||||||||||||||
Less: Tax Expense(2) | $(241) | $(267) | $(294) | $(320) | $(349) | $(380) | $(414) | $(452) | $(246) | $(134) | ||||||||||||||||||||
Less: Change in Net Working Capital | $(30) | $(23) | $(23) | $(22) | $(24) | $(27) | $(29) | $(32) | $177 | $96 | ||||||||||||||||||||
Unlevered Free Cash Flow(3) | $693 | $779 | $859 | $939 | $1,022 | $1,115 | $1,214 | $1,324 | $916 | $499 | ||||||||||||||||||||
(1) | “EBIT” is defined as gross profit, less total research and development expense, less total sales and marketing expense, less total general and administrative expense. |
(2) | The calculation of tax expense assumes a tax rate of 25% and aggregate estimated cash savings from tax assets of approximately $153 million in fiscal years 2032 through 2034. |
(3) | “Unlevered Free Cash Flow” is defined as EBIT, less tax expense, less change in net working capital. Unlevered Free Cash Flow assumes no depreciation and amortization and no capital expenditures. |
• | was provided to the Company Board (in its capacity as such) for its information and assistance in connection with its evaluation of the Offer Price; |
• | did not constitute a recommendation to the Company Board with respect to the Transactions; |
• | does not constitute advice or a recommendation to any holder of Shares as to whether to tender any such Shares pursuant to the Offer or how to act in connection with the Transactions or otherwise; |
• | did not address the Company’s underlying business or financial decision to pursue or effect the Transactions, the relative merits of the Transactions as compared to any alternative business or financial strategies that might exist for the Company, the financing or funding of the Transactions by Parent or the effects of any other Transactions in which the Company might engage; |
• | addressed only the fairness, from a financial point of view and as of the date of such opinion, of the Offer Price to be received by the holders of Shares (other than Excluded Shares) to the extent expressly specified in such opinion; |
• | expressed no view or opinion as to (i) any other term, aspect or implication of (y) the Transactions (including, without limitation, the form or structure of the Transactions) or the Merger Agreement or (z) any tender and support agreement or any other agreement, transaction document or instrument contemplated by the Merger Agreement or to be entered into or amended in connection with the Transactions or (ii) the fairness, financial or otherwise, of the Transactions to, or of any consideration to be paid to or received by, the holders of any class of securities (other than as expressly specified herein), creditors or other constituencies of the Company; and |
• | expressed no view or opinion as to the fairness, financial or otherwise, of the amount or nature of any compensation payable to or to be received by any of the Company’s directors, officers or employees, or any class of such persons, in connection with the Transactions relative to the Offer Price or otherwise. |
• | reviewed a draft of the Merger Agreement dated as of July 26, 2026; |
• | reviewed certain publicly available business and financial information regarding the Company; |
• | reviewed certain non-public business and financial information regarding the Company and its business, products, product candidates, intellectual property and future prospects (including certain probability-adjusted financial projections for the Company on a stand-alone basis for the years ending December 31, 2026 through December 31, 2045 (being referred to solely for purposes of this section of this Schedule 14D-9 as the “Company-Provided Financial Projections”), certain estimates as to potentially realizable existing net operating loss carryforwards expected to be utilized by the Company and certain other estimates and other forward-looking information), all as prepared by, discussed with and approved for Guggenheim Securities’ use by the Company’s senior management (collectively being referred to solely for purposes of this section of this Schedule 14D-9 as the “Company-Provided Information”); for more information on the Company-Provided Financial Projections and the Company-Provided Information, see the section of this Schedule 14D-9 captioned “Certain Unaudited Prospective Financial Information.” |
• | discussed with the Company’s senior management their views of the Company’s business, operations, historical and projected financial results, liquidity, funding needs, access to capital and future prospects (including, without limitation, their assumptions as to the expected amounts, timing and pricing of future issuances of equity in the Company) and the commercial, competitive and regulatory dynamics in the biopharmaceutical sector; |
• | performed a financing-adjusted discounted cash flow analysis based on the Company-Provided Financial Projections; |
• | reviewed acquisition premia associated with certain precedent mergers and acquisitions that Guggenheim Securities deemed relevant in evaluating the Transactions; |
• | reviewed the historical prices and the trading activity of the Shares; and |
• | conducted such other studies, analyses, inquiries and investigations as Guggenheim Securities deemed appropriate. |
• | Guggenheim Securities relied upon and assumed the accuracy, completeness and reasonableness of all industry, business, financial, legal, regulatory, tax, accounting, actuarial and other information provided by or discussed with the Company (including, without limitation, the Company-Provided Information) or obtained from public sources, data suppliers and other third parties. |
• | Guggenheim Securities (i) did not assume any responsibility, obligation or liability for the accuracy, completeness, reasonableness, achievability or independent verification of, and Guggenheim Securities did not independently verify, any such information (including, without limitation, the Company-Provided Information), (ii) expressed no view or opinion regarding (y) the reasonableness or achievability of the Company-Provided Financial Projections, any other estimates or any other forward-looking information provided by the Company or the assumptions upon which any of the foregoing were based or (z) the reasonableness of the probability adjustments reflected in the Company-Provided Financial Projections and (iii) relied upon the assurances of the Company’s senior management that they were unaware of any facts or circumstances that would have made the Company-Provided Information incomplete, inaccurate or misleading. |
• | Guggenheim Securities was (i) advised by the Company’s senior management, and assumed, that the Company-Provided Financial Projections (including the probability adjustments reflected therein and the expected development and commercialization of the Company’s products and product candidates) had been (y) reasonably prepared on bases reflecting the best then-currently available estimates and judgments of the Company’s senior management as to the expected future performance of the Company on a stand-alone basis and (z) reviewed by the Company Board with the understanding that such information would be used and relied upon by Guggenheim Securities in connection with rendering its opinion and (ii) assumed that any financial projections/forecasts, any other estimates and/or any other forward-looking information obtained from public sources, data suppliers and other third parties were reasonable and reliable. |
• | Guggenheim Securities did not perform or obtain any independent appraisal of the assets or liabilities (including any contingent, derivative or off-balance sheet assets and liabilities) of the Company or any other entity or the solvency or fair value of the Company or any other entity, nor was Guggenheim Securities furnished with any such appraisals. |
• | Guggenheim Securities’ professionals are not legal, regulatory, tax, consulting, accounting, appraisal or actuarial experts and Guggenheim Securities’ opinion should not be construed as constituting advice with respect to such matters; accordingly, Guggenheim Securities relied on the assessments of the Company’s senior management and the Company’s other professional advisors with respect to such matters. Guggenheim Securities did not express any view or render any opinion regarding the tax consequences of the Transactions to the Company or its securityholders. |
• | Guggenheim Securities further assumed that: |
• | in all respects meaningful to its analyses, (i) the final executed form of the Merger Agreement would not differ from the draft that Guggenheim Securities reviewed, (ii) the Company, Parent and Purchaser will comply with all terms and provisions of the Merger Agreement and (iii) the representations and warranties of the Company, Parent and Purchaser contained in the Merger Agreement were true and correct and all conditions to the obligations of each party to the Merger Agreement to consummate the Transactions would be satisfied without any waiver, amendment or modification thereof; and |
• | the Transactions will be consummated in a timely manner in accordance with the terms of the Merger Agreement and in compliance with all applicable legal and other requirements, without any delays, limitations, restrictions, conditions, waivers, amendments or modifications (regulatory, tax-related or otherwise) that would have an effect on the Company or the Transactions in any way meaningful to Guggenheim Securities’ analyses or opinion. |
• | based its financial analyses on various assumptions, including assumptions concerning general economic, business and capital markets conditions and industry-specific and company-specific factors, all of which are beyond the control of the Company and Guggenheim Securities; |
• | did not form a view or opinion as to whether any individual financial analysis or factor, whether positive or negative, considered in isolation, supported or failed to support its opinion; |
• | considered the results of all its financial analyses and did not attribute any particular weight to any one financial analysis or factor; and |
• | ultimately arrived at its opinion based on the results of all its financial analyses assessed as a whole and believes that the totality of the factors considered and the various financial analyses performed by Guggenheim Securities in connection with its opinion operated collectively to support its determination as to the fairness, from a financial point of view and as of the date of such opinion, of the Offer Price to be received by the holders of Shares (other than Excluded Shares) to the extent expressly specified in such opinion. |
• | Such financial analyses, particularly those based on estimates and projections, are not necessarily indicative of actual values or actual future results, which may be significantly more or less favorable than suggested by these analyses. |
• | Such financial analyses do not purport to be appraisals or to reflect the prices at which any securities may trade at the present time or at any time in the future. |
• | Unless otherwise noted below, all stock price data is as of July 24, 2026, the last full trading day prior to the delivery of Guggenheim Securities’ opinion (the “Unaffected Date”). |
Premia Implied by Transactions | |||
Offer Price per Share | $77.00 | ||
Company Stock Price | ||||||
Acquisition Premium/(Discount) Relative to the Company’s: | ||||||
Unaffected Price (Closing Stock Price @ 7/24/26) | $54.78 | 41% | ||||
Closing Stock Price Prior to the Initial Parent Proposal @ 7/10/26 | $43.92 | 75% | ||||
Vitiligo Data Date VWAP @ 7/24/26 | $41.96 | 84% | ||||
30-Day VWAP @ 7/24/26 | $35.41 | 117% | ||||
52-Week High @ 7/24/26 | $59.70 | 29% | ||||
Recap of Change-of-Control Financial Analyses | |||
Offer Price per Share | $77.00 | ||
Reference Range for the Company’s Shares | ||||||
Financial Analyses | Low | High | ||||
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis | $56.57 | $78.85 | ||||
For Informational Reference Purposes | ||||||
Premia Paid in Selected Merger and Acquisition Transactions | ||||||
Unaffected 1-Day Premium Applied to Unaffected Price (Company’s Closing Stock Price @ 7/24/26) | $77.79 | $98.06 | ||||
Unaffected 52-Week High Premium Applied to Company’s 52-Week High Price @ 7/24/26 | $67.46 | $88.36 | ||||
Historical Trading Range | $9.61 | $59.70 | ||||
Wall Street Equity Research Stock Price Targets | $54.00 | $75.00 | ||||
• | Guggenheim Securities based its financing-adjusted discounted cash flow analysis on forecasted, risk-adjusted after-tax unlevered free cash flows over the period beginning on July 1, 2026 and ending on |
• | Guggenheim Securities used a discount rate range of 11.75% – 14.50% based on its estimate of the Company’s weighted average cost of capital. |
• | In estimating the Company’s terminal/continuing value, Guggenheim Securities used an illustrative perpetual growth rate of negative 50.0% applied to the Company’s terminal year normalized after-tax unlevered free cash flow as provided by, discussed with and approved for Guggenheim Securities’ use by the Company’s senior management. |
• | Guggenheim Securities’ analysis deducted from the result the estimated present value of the estimated net cost of equity financings from 2027 through 2030 and added the Company’s estimated net cash of $198 million as of June 30, 2026, each as provided by, discussed with and approved for Guggenheim Securities’ use by the Company’s senior management. |
• | Guggenheim Securities then converted the result of the foregoing calculations to per Share equity value using diluted shares outstanding (based on the treasury stock method) as of July 24, 2026, as provided by, discussed with and approved for Guggenheim Securities’ use by the Company’s senior management. |
PERSONS/ASSETS RETAINED, EMPLOYED, COMPENSATED OR USED |
INTEREST IN SECURITIES OF THE SUBJECT COMPANY |
Name | Date of Transaction | Nature of Transaction | Number of Shares | Price per Share | ||||||||
Paul A. Wagner | 7/1/2026 | A broker-assisted/withholding transaction to satisfy such person’s tax withholding obligations in connection with the vesting of Company RSUs. | 98 | $21.32 | ||||||||
Paul A. Wagner | 6/16/2026 | Grant of stock options under the 2021 Equity Incentive Plan. | 500,000 | $17.15 | ||||||||
Antony A. Riley | 7/1/2026 | A broker-assisted/withholding transaction to satisfy such person’s tax withholding obligations in connection with the vesting of Company RSUs. | 134 | $21.32 | ||||||||
Antony A. Riley | 7/1/2026 | A purchase by Mr. Riley under the Company’s 2017 Employee Stock Purchase Plan. | 377 | $18.12 | ||||||||
Antony A. Riley | 6/16/2026 | Grant of stock options under the 2021 Equity Incentive Plan. | 22,000 | $17.15 | ||||||||
Barbara K. Finck | 6/16/2026 | Grant of Company RSUs under the 2021 Equity Incentive Plan. | 18,353 | $17.15 | ||||||||
PURPOSES OF THE TRANSACTION AND PLANS OR PROPOSALS |
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION |
Named Executive Officer | Cash ($)(1) | Equity ($)(2) | Benefits ($)(3) | Tax Reimbursement ($)(4) | Other ($)(5) ($) | Total ($) | ||||||||||||
Paul A. Wagner, Ph.D. | 2,170,000 | 86,750,306 | 60,000 | — | 385,000 | 89,365,306 | ||||||||||||
Antony A. Riley | 1,029,000 | 20,778,630 | 45,000 | — | 196,000 | 22,048,630 | ||||||||||||
(1) | Cash. Amounts represent the aggregate dollar value of cash severance payments that each named executive officer would be entitled to receive upon a Change in Control Qualified Termination as described in the subsection entitled “- Executive Officer Change in Control and Severance Agreements” above: (i) 18 months of base salary (24 months for Mr. Wagner) and (ii) 150% of the target annual bonus award for calendar year 2026 (200% for Mr. Wagner). These amounts would constitute “double trigger” benefits and are subject to the named executive officer’s execution and nonrevocation of a release of claims. |
(2) | Equity. Amounts represent the potential value of unvested equity awards held by each named executive officer that would be canceled and converted into cash amounts as described in the section entitled “- Effect of the Offer and the Merger on Equity Awards” above and, include the 2021 Performance RSU Award that constitutes a “single trigger” benefit. |
(3) | Benefits. The amounts in this column represent the estimated value of 18 months (24 months for Mr. Wagner) of insurance premiums for continuation coverage under the Company’s insurance and group health plans if the named executive officer incurs a Change in Control Qualified Termination and elects such coverage for the maximum amount of time permitted, at the same cost as would have applied if the |
(4) | Special Bonus Payment. The amounts in this column represent the estimated amount of the special cash transaction bonuses that may be paid to the named executive officers. As described above under “-Section 280G and 4999 Matters”, the parties have agreed that the Company may pay up to an aggregate of $25,000,000, to certain employees of the Company to offset the payment of taxes imposed under Section 4999 of the Code (as a result of a payment being classified as a parachute payment under Section 280G of the Code) plus any taxes resulting from such payment, including the named executive officers. An employee affected by such taxes may execute a letter agreement with the Company which contains reasonable and customary terms negotiated in good faith and approved by Parent in good faith, and further enter into a non-compete with Parent, in the employee’s capacity as a selling shareholder, with reasonable and customary terms negotiated and proposed in good faith by Parent, as contemplated by the Merger Agreement. As of the date of this filing, the Company has not entered into any letter agreements providing for any such payments. To the extent any special cash transaction bonus amounts are paid, such amounts would constitute “single trigger” benefits. |
(5) | Annual Incentive Bonus. Amounts represent the aggregate dollar value of the annual cash incentive bonus payments for 2026, at target performance level (55% of annual base salary for Mr. Wagner and 40% of annual base salary for Mr. Riley). 50% of the annual bonus payment is a “single trigger” benefit that would be paid shortly following the closing of the merger and 50% of the annual bonus payment is a “double trigger” benefit that would be paid upon the named executive officer’s termination without cause or resignation for good reason following closing and prior to December 31, 2026, as described in the subsection entitled “-Annual Incentive Bonuses”. The portion of the annual cash incentive bonus payment payable as “double trigger” benefit is subject to the named executive officer’s execution and nonrevocation of a release of claims. |
Named Executive Officer | Number of Unvested Company Options (#) | Value of Unvested Company Options ($)(A) | Number of Unvested Company RSUs (#) | Value of Unvested Company RSUs ($)(B) | Total Value of Unvested Equity Awards ($) | ||||||||||
Paul A. Wagner, Ph.D. | 1,189,854 | 72,427,459 | 186,011 | 14,322,847 | 86,750,306 | ||||||||||
Antony A. Riley | 256,779 | 15,871,728 | 63,726 | 4,906,902 | 20,778,630 | ||||||||||
(A) | The estimated value of the unvested Company Options equals the aggregate number of Shares underlying the unvested Company Options multiplied by the amount, if any, by which the Merger Consideration exceeds the per Share exercise price of the unvested Company Options. |
(B) | The estimated value of the unvested Company RSUs equals the aggregate number of Shares underlying the unvested Company RSUs multiplied by the Merger Consideration. |
Forte Biosciences, Inc. | |||
3060 Pegasus Park Drive, Building 6 | |||
Dallas, Texas 75247 | |||
Attention: Paul Wagner, Chief Executive Officer | |||
The Company requests that a copy (which shall not constitute notice) also be sent to: | |||
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati, P.C. | |||
12235 El Camino Real | |||
San Diego, California 92130-3002 | |||
Attention: Remi Korenblit; Dan Koeppen; Robert L. Wernli Jr.; and Ben Capps | |||
EXHIBITS |
Exhibit No. | Description | ||
Offer to Purchase, dated as of August 6, 2026 (incorporated by reference to Exhibit (a)(1)(i) to the Schedule TO of Parent and Purchaser filed August 6, 2026 (the “Schedule TO”)). | |||
Form of Letter of Transmittal (incorporated by reference to Exhibit (a)(1)(ii) to the Schedule TO). | |||
Form of Letter to Brokers, Dealers, Commercial Banks, Trust Companies and Other Nominees (incorporated by reference to Exhibit (a)(1)(iii) to the Schedule TO). | |||
Form of Letter to Clients for Use by Brokers, Dealers, Commercial Banks, Trust Companies and Other Nominees (incorporated by reference to Exhibit (a)(1)(iv) to the Schedule TO). | |||
Form of Summary Advertisement, published August 6, 2026 in The New York Times (incorporated by reference to Exhibit (a)(1)(v) to the Schedule TO). | |||
Joint Press Release of Forte Biosciences, Inc. and Parent dated July 27, 2026 (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 99.1 to the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by the Company on July 27, 2026). | |||
Email message to Forte Biosciences, Inc.’s employees from Paul A. Wagner, Chief Executive Officer of Forte Biosciences, Inc., dated July 27, 2026 (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 99.1 to the Schedule 14D-9C filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on July 27, 2026). | |||
Guggenheim Securities, LLC Opinion Letter to the Company Board of Directors of Forte Biosciences, Inc., dated July 26, 2026 (included as Annex A to this Schedule 14D-9). | |||
Agreement and Plan of Merger, dated as of July 26, 2026, by and among Forte Biosciences, Inc., Parent and Purchaser (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 2.1 to the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on July 27, 2026). | |||
Confidentiality and Nondisclosure Agreement, dated as of April 8, 2026, by and between Forte Biosciences, Inc. and Parent. | |||
Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation of Forte Biosciences, Inc. (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 3.1 to the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on April 19, 2017). | |||
Certificate of Amendment to Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation of the Registrant, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 3.1 of the Current Report on Form 8-K filed by Forte Biosciences, Inc. with the SEC on June 15, 2020. | |||
Certificate of Amendment to Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation of Forte Biosciences, Inc. incorporated by reference to Exhibit 3.1 of the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc., on August 30, 2024. | |||
Amended and Restated Bylaws of Forte Biosciences, Inc., incorporated by reference to Exhibit 3.1 of the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc., on February 9, 2023. | |||
Form of Indemnity Agreement by and between Forte Biosciences, Inc. and its directors and officers, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.1 of the Registration Statement on Form S-1, as amended, originally filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on March 9, 2017. | |||
Tocagen, Inc. 2017 Equity Incentive Plan, as amended, and Forms of Stock Option Grant Notice, Option Agreement and Notice of Exercise thereunder, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.3 of Annual Report on Form 10-K filed by Forte Biosciences, Inc. with the SEC on February 27, 2019. | |||
Tocagen, Inc. 2017 Employee Stock Purchase Plan, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.4 of Forte Biosciences, Inc.’s Registration Statement on Form S-1, as amended, originally filed with the SEC on March 9, 2017. | |||
Tocagen, Inc. Annual Incentive Plan, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.1 of Forte Biosciences, Inc.’s Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q filed with the SEC on August 9, 2017. | |||
Form of Restricted Stock Unit Grant Notice and Agreement, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.18 of the Annual Report of Forte Biosciences, Inc. on Form 10-K filed with the SEC on February 27, 2020. | |||
2020 Inducement Equity Incentive Plan, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.1 of the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on August 11, 2020. | |||
Exhibit No. | Description | ||
Form of stock option agreements under the 2020 Inducement Equity Incentive Plan, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.2 of the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on August 11, 2020. | |||
Amended and Restated 2021 Equity Incentive Plan incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.1 of the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on June 2, 2026. | |||
Amended and Restated Non-Employee Director Compensation Policy, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.2 of the Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on May 15, 2025. | |||
Forte Subsidiary, Inc. 2018 Equity Incentive Plan, as amended, and Forms of Stock Option Agreement, Exercise Notice and Investment Representation Statement thereunder, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.19 of the Registration Statement on Form S-4, as amended, originally filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on March 25, 2020. | |||
Offer Letter, dated December 14, 2018, by and between Forte Subsidiary, Inc. and Paul A. Wagner, Ph.D., incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.20 of Registration Statement on Form S-4, as amended, originally filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on March 25, 2020. | |||
Offer Letter, dated March 16, 2020, by and between Forte Subsidiary, Inc. and Antony Riley, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.21 of the Registration Statement of Forte Biosciences, Inc. on Form S-4, as amended, originally filed with the SEC on March 25, 2020. | |||
Form of Change in Control and Severance Agreement, incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.1 of the Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on November 14, 2022. | |||
Form of Tender and Support Agreement (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 10.1 to the Current Report on Form 8-K filed with the SEC by Forte Biosciences, Inc. on July 27, 2026). | |||
Forte Biosciences, Inc. | ||||||
By: | /s/ Paul A. Wagner, Ph.D. | |||||
Name: | Paul A. Wagner, Ph.D. | |||||
Title: | President and Chief Executive Officer | |||||
Dated: August 6, 2026 | ||||||
![]() | Guggenheim Securities, LLC 330 Madison Avenue New York, New York 10017 GuggenheimPartners.com | ||
• | Reviewed a draft of the Agreement dated as of July 26, 2026; |
• | Reviewed certain publicly available business and financial information regarding Forte; |
• | Reviewed certain non-public business and financial information regarding Forte and its business, products, product candidates, intellectual property and future prospects (including certain probability-adjusted financial projections for Forte on a stand-alone basis for the years ending December 31, 2026 through December 31, 2045 (the “Forte-Provided Financial Projections”), certain estimates as to potentially realizable existing net operating loss carryforwards expected to be utilized by Forte and certain other estimates and other forward-looking information), all as prepared by, discussed with and approved for our use by Forte’s senior management (collectively, the “Forte-Provided Information”); |
• | Discussed with Forte’s senior management their views of Forte’s business, operations, historical and projected financial results, liquidity, funding needs, access to capital and future prospects (including, without limitation, their assumptions as to the expected amounts, timing and pricing of future issuances of equity in Forte) and the commercial, competitive and regulatory dynamics in the biopharmaceutical sector; |
• | Performed financing-adjusted discounted cash flow analyses based on the Forte-Provided Financial Projections; |
• | Reviewed acquisition premia associated with certain precedent mergers and acquisitions that we deemed relevant in evaluating the Transaction; |
• | Reviewed the historical prices and the trading activity of the Shares; and |
• | Conducted such other studies, analyses, inquiries and investigations as we deemed appropriate. |
• | We have relied upon and assumed the accuracy, completeness and reasonableness of all industry, business, financial, legal, regulatory, tax, accounting, actuarial and other information provided by or discussed with Forte (including, without limitation, the Forte-Provided Information) or obtained from public sources, data suppliers and other third parties. |
• | We (i) do not assume any responsibility, obligation or liability for the accuracy, completeness, reasonableness, achievability or independent verification of, and we have not independently verified, any such information (including, without limitation, the Forte-Provided Information), (ii) express no view or opinion regarding (y) the reasonableness or achievability of the Forte-Provided Financial Projections, any other estimates or any other forward-looking information provided by Forte or the assumptions upon which any of the foregoing are based or (z) the reasonableness of the probability adjustments reflected in the Forte-Provided Financial Projections and (iii) have relied upon the assurances of Forte’s senior management that they are unaware of any facts or circumstances that would make the Forte-Provided Information incomplete, inaccurate or misleading. |
• | We (i) have been advised by Forte’s senior management, and have assumed, that the Forte-Provided Financial Projections (including the probability adjustments reflected therein and the expected development and commercialization of Forte’s products and product candidates) have been (y) reasonably prepared on bases reflecting the best currently available estimates and judgments of Forte’s senior management as to the expected future performance of Forte on a stand-alone basis and (z) reviewed by Forte’s Board of Directors with the understanding that such information will be used and relied upon by us in connection with rendering our opinion and (ii) have assumed that any financial projections/forecasts, any other estimates and/or any other forward-looking information obtained from public sources, data suppliers and other third parties are reasonable and reliable. |