Exhibit 99.2

 

LOGO

Columbia Financial, Inc. Fair Lawn, New Jersey PROPOSED HOLDING COMPANY FOR: Columbia Bank Fair Lawn, New Jersey


LOGO

June 18, 2026

Boards of Directors

Columbia Bank MHC

Columbia Financial, Inc.

Columbia Bank

19-01 Route 208 North

Fair Lawn, New Jersey 07410

Members of the Boards of Directors:

We have completed and hereby provide an updated appraisal of the estimated pro forma market value of the common stock which is to be issued in connection with the two-part transaction described below.

This Appraisal is furnished pursuant to the requirements stipulated in the Code of Federal Regulations and has been prepared in accordance with the 1994 “Guidelines for Appraisal Reports for the Valuation of Savings and Loan Associations Converting from Mutual to Stock Form of Organization” (“Valuation Guidelines”) and applicable regulatory interpretations thereof. These Valuation Guidelines were issued by the Office of Thrift Supervision (“OTS”) and are accepted by the Federal Reserve Board (“FRB”), the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”), and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (“FDIC”). Our original appraisal report, dated February 2, 2026 (the “Original Appraisal”), is incorporated herein by reference. As in the preparation of our Original Appraisal, we believe the data and information used herein is reliable; however, we cannot guarantee the accuracy and completeness of such information.

On January 31, 2026, the respective Boards of Directors of Columbia Bank MHC (the ”MHC”) and Columbia Financial, Inc. (“CLBK”) adopted the Plan of Conversion whereby the MHC will convert to stock form. As a result of the conversion, CLBK, which currently owns all of the issued and outstanding common stock of Columbia Bank, Fair Lawn, New Jersey (the “Bank”), will be succeeded by a new Maryland corporation with the name of Columbia Financial, Inc. (“Columbia Financial” or the “Company”). Following the conversion, the MHC will no longer exist. For purposes of this document, the existing consolidated entity will hereinafter also be referred to as Columbia Financial or the Company, unless otherwise identified as CLBK. As of December 31, 2025, the MHC had a majority ownership interest in, and its principal asset consisted of, approximately 73.10% of the common stock (the “MHC Shares”) of CLBK. The remaining 26.90% of CLBK’s common stock was owned by public shareholders.

Pursuant to the Plan of Conversion, Columbia Financial has offered its stock representing the majority ownership interest held by the MHC in a subscription offering to Eligible Account Holders, Tax-Qualified Employee Plans including the Bank’s employee stock ownership plan (the “ESOP”), Supplemental Eligible Account Holders and Other Members, as such terms are defined for purposes of applicable federal regulatory requirements governing mutual-to-stock conversions. To the extent that shares remain available for purchase after satisfaction of all subscriptions received in the subscription offering, the shares may be offered for sale to the general public in a community offering and a firm commitment offering. Upon

 

 
Washington Headquarters   
1311-A Dolley Madison Blvd., Suite 2A    Main: (703) 528-1700
McLean, VA 22101    Fax: (703) 528-1788
www.pfinancial.com    E-Mail: mail@rpfinancial.com


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 2

 

completing the mutual-to-stock conversion and stock offering (the “second-step conversion”), the Company will be 100% owned by public shareholders, the publicly-held shares of CLBK will be exchanged for shares in the Company at a ratio that retains their ownership interest at the time the conversion is completed.

In connection with the second-step conversion, the Boards of Directors of CLBK, Columbia Financial and the MHC entered into an Agreement and Plan of Merger (the “Agreement”) with Northfield Bancorp, Inc., Woodbridge, New Jersey (“Northfield Bancorp”). Pursuant to the Agreement, Northfield Bancorp will merge with and into Columbia Financial, with Columbia Financial as the surviving entity (the “Merger”). Immediately following the Merger, Northfield Bank, a federal savings bank and a wholly owned subsidiary of Northfield Bancorp, will merge with and into Columbia Bank with Columbia Bank as the surviving entity.

As set forth in Agreement, if the Final Independent Valuation (full conversion value) is less than $2.3 billion, Northfield Bancorp shareholders may elect to receive 1.425 shares of Columbia Financial common stock, based on a $10.00 per share offering price, or $14.25 in cash for each share of Northfield Bancorp common stock. If the Final Independent Valuation is equal to or greater than $2.3 billion and less than $2.6 billion, Northfield Bancorp shareholders may elect to receive 1.450 shares of Columbia Financial common stock, based on a $10.00 per share offering price, or $14.50 in cash for each share of Northfield Bancorp common stock. If the Final Independent Valuation is equal to or greater than $2.6 billion, Northfield Bancorp shareholders may elect to receive 1.465 shares of Columbia Financial common stock, based on a $10.00 per share offering price, or $14.65 in cash for each share of Northfield Bancorp common stock. The proration procedures set forth in the Agreement require that the cash consideration shall not be greater than 30% of the total merger consideration.

This updated appraisal reflects the following noteworthy items: (1) a review of recent developments in Columbia Financial’s and Northfield Bancorp’s financial condition, including financial data through March 31, 2026; (2) an updated comparison of Columbia Financial’s financial condition and operating results versus the Peer Group companies identified in the Original Appraisal; (3) a review of stock market conditions since the date of the Original Appraisal; and (4) the results of Columbia Financial’s subscription offering, which concluded on June 16, 2026.

The estimated pro forma market value is defined as the price at which Columbia Financial’s common stock, immediately upon completion of the second-step offering and merger, would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or sell and both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts.

Our valuation is not intended, and must not be construed, as a recommendation of any kind as to the advisability of purchasing shares of the common stock. Moreover, because such valuation is necessarily based upon estimates and projections of a number of matters, all of which are subject to change from time to time, no assurance can be given that persons who purchase shares of common stock in the conversion will thereafter be able to buy or sell such shares at prices related to the foregoing valuation of the pro forma market value thereof. RP Financial is not a seller of securities within the meaning of any federal and state securities laws and any report prepared by RP Financial shall not be used as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any securities. RP Financial maintains a policy which prohibits the company, its principals or employees from purchasing stock of its client institutions.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 3

 

Discussion of Relevant Considerations

1. Financial Results

Table 1 presents Columbia Financial’s summary balance sheet and income statement details for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 and updated financial information through March 31, 2026. Columbia Financial’s total assets decreased by $8.3 million or 0.08% from December 31, 2025 to March 31, 2026. The decrease in total assets was primarily attributable to decreases in cash and cash equivalents and net loans receivable, which was largely offset by asset growth consisting primarily of investment securities and FHLB/FRB stock. Overall, cash and investments (inclusive of FHLB/FRB stock) increased from $1.930 billion, or 17.52% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $1.942 billion, or 17.64% of assets, at March 31, 2026. Loans receivable decreased from $8.225 billion, or 74.64% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $8.191 billion, or 74.39% of assets, at March 31, 2026. The balances for bank-owned life insurance (“BOLI”) and goodwill/intangible assets were respectively slightly higher and lower at March 31, 2026 compared to December 31, 2025.

Updated credit quality measures showed an increase in non-performing assets during the quarter ended March 31, 2026, which was the result of a $3.4 million increase in non-accruing loans and a $5.9 million increase in other real estate owned. The increase in non-accruing loans was primarily due to a $10.6 million commercial real estate loan that was designated as non-performing during the three month period ended March 31, 2026, which was partially offset by decreases in non-performing commercial business loans and non-performing construction loans amounting to $1.6 million and $5.9 million, respectively. The decrease in non-performing construction loans was due to one loan that was transferred to other real estate owned. Overall, Columbia Financial’s non-performing assets increased from $38.0 million, or 0.34% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $47.3 million, or 0.43% of assets, at March 31, 2026. As of March 31, 2026, non-performing assets consisted of $41.4 million of non-accruing loans and $5.9 million of other real estate owned.

Asset shrinkage and increases in borrowings and equity funded a decrease in deposits during the quarter ended March 31, 2026. Deposits decreased from $8.444 billion, or 76.63% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $8.372 billion, or 76.04% of assets, at March 31, 2026, which was primarily due a decrease in interest-bearing demand deposits. Borrowings increased from $1.183 billion, or 10.74% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $1.243 billion, or 11.29% of assets, at March 31, 2026, as the Company added short-term and long-term borrowings that were partially offset by repayments of maturing long-term borrowings. Columbia Financial’s equity increased from $1.161 billion, or 10.53% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $1.174 billion, or 10.66% of assets, at March 31, 2026. Similarly, tangible equity increased from $1.043 billion, or 9.47% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $1.057 billion, or 9.60% of assets, at March 31, 2026. The increase in capital was primarily due to the retention of earnings during the first quarter of 2026.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 4

 

Table 1

Columbia Financial, Inc.

Recent Financial Data

 

     At December, 31, 2025     At March 31, 2026  
     Amount      Assets     Amount      Assets  
     ($000)      (%)     ($000)      (%)  

Balance Sheet Data

          

Total assets

   $ 11,018,793        100.00   $ 11,010,507        100.00

Cash, cash equivalents

     340,806        3.09       276,947        2.52  

Investment securities

     1,525,052        13.84       1,582,355        14.37  

Loans receivable, net

     8,224,809        74.64       8,190,917        74.39  

Bank-owned life insurance

     283,094        2.57       285,267        2.59  

FHLB/FRB stock

     64,604        0.59       82,865        0.75  

Goodwill and intangible assets

     117,661        1.07       117,186        1.06  

Deposits

     8,444,079        76.63       8,372,014        76.04  

Borrowings

     1,183,472        10.74       1,243,462        11.29  

Total equity

     1,160,728        10.53       1,173,722        10.66  

Tangible equity

     1,043,067        9.47       1,056,536        9.60  

 

     12 Months Ended     12 Months Ended  
     December 31, 2025     March, 31, 2026  
     Amount      Avg. Assets     Amount      Avg. Assets  
     ($000)      (%)     ($000)      (%)  

Summary Income Statement

          

Interest income

   $ 470,951        4.37   $ 477,659        4.39

Interest expense

     (249,317      (2.32     (245,959      (2.26
  

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net interest income

     221,634        2.06       231,700        2.13  

Provision for credit losses

     (9,822      (0.09     (7,845      (0.07
  

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net interest income after prov.

     211,812        1.97       223,855        2.06  

Non-interest operating income

     35,906        0.33       35,654        0.33  

Gain (loss) on securities

     290        0.00       290        0.00  

Change in fair value of equity securities

     873        0.01       (599      (0.01

Merger related expenses

     (214      0.00       (2,037      (0.02

Non-interest operating expense

     (180,678      (1.68     (182,497      (1.68
  

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

 

Income before income tax expense

     67,989        0.63       74,666        0.68  

Income taxes

     (16,223      (0.15     (18,701      (0.17
  

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net income

   $ 51,766        0.48   $ 55,965        0.51

 

Sources:

Columbia Financial’s prospectus, audited and unaudited financial statements, and RP Financial calculations.

Columbia Financial’s operating results for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 and March 31, 2026 are also set forth in Table 1. The Company’s reported earnings increased from $51.8 million, or 0.48% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $56.0 million, or 0.51% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. The increase in net income was primarily due to an increase in net interest income and, to a lesser extent, a decrease in the provision for credit losses. Partially offsetting the increase in net income were increases in operating and merger related expenses, as well as a decrease in the change in fair value of equity securities.

 


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 5

 

Columbia Financial’s net interest income increased from $221.6 million, or 2.06% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $231.7 million, or 2.13% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. The increase in net interest income was realized through an increase in interest income and a decrease in interest expense, which was facilitated by an increase in the average yield earned on interest-earning assets and a decrease in the average cost of interest-bearing liabilities, as well as a more significant increase in the average balance of interest-earning assets relative to the increase in the average balance of interest-bearing liabilities. Overall, the Company’s interest rate spread increased from 1.48% during the quarter ended March 31, 2025 to 1.84% during the quarter ended March 31, 2026 and net interest-earning assets increased from $1.873 billion during the quarter ended March 31, 2025 to $2.000 billion during the quarter ended March 31, 2026.

Operating expenses increased from $180.7 million, or 1.68% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 20125 to $182.5 million, or 1.68% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. Most of the increase in operating expenses was due to an increase in compensation and employee benefits expense. Overall, Columbia Financial’s updated ratios for net interest income and operating expenses provided for a slight increase in the expense coverage ratio (net interest income divided by operating expenses) from 1.23x for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to 1.27x for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026.

Non-interest operating income was slightly lower during the most recent twelve month period, decreasing from $35.9 million, or 0.33% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $35.7 million, or 0.33% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. The decrease in non-interest operating income was primarily due to a decrease in gain on sale loans. Overall, when factoring non-interest operating income into core earnings, the Company’s updated efficiency ratio of 68.29% (operating expenses as a percent of net interest income and non-interest operating income) was slightly more favorable compared to an efficiency ratio of 70.29% for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025.

The provision for credit losses was lower during the most recent twelve period, decreasing from $9.8 million, or 0.09% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $7.8 million, or 0.07% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. As of March 31, 2026, the Company maintained an allowance for credit losses of $68.8 million equal to 166.19% of non-performing loans.

Updated non-operating income and losses showed an increase in merger related expenses from $214,000, or 0.00% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $2.0 million, or 0.02% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026, and a decrease in the change in fair value of equity securities from $873,000, or 0.01% of average assets, to a loss of $599,000, or 0.01% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. There was no change in the gain on securities, equal to $290,000 or 0.00% of average assets for both twelve month periods shown in Table 1.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 6

 

The income tax expense increased from $16.2 million, or 0.15% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $18.7 million, or 0.17% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. The increase in income tax expense was primarily due to an increase in pre-tax income.

Pro Forma Impact of Northfield Bancorp Acquisition

Table 2 presents the pro forma balance sheet and income statement impact of the Northfield Bancorp acquisition, as of and for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 and updated financial data through March 31, 2026. The updated pro forma financial data through March 31, 2026 reflects estimated fair value merger adjustments applied to Northfield Bancorp’s March 31, 2026 financial data.

Columbia Financial’s pro forma assets decreased by $34.1 million or 0.21% from December 31, 2025 to March 31, 2026. Net loans receivable accounted for the decline in pro forma assets, which was largely offset by increases in cash and cash equivalents, investment securities, BOLI and FHLB/FRB stock. Overall, cash and investments (inclusive of FHLB/FRB stock) increased from $3.374 billion, or 20.46% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $3.422 billion, or 20.80% of assets, at March 31, 2026. Net loans receivable decreased from $11.863 billion, or 71.95% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $11.770 billion, or 71.53% of assets, at March 31, 2026. The updated balance of BOLI increased slightly to equal $470.0 million, or 2.86% of assets, at March 31, 2026, and the updated balance of goodwill/intangibles was slightly higher to equal $193.6 million, or 1.18% of assets, at March 31, 2026.

Updated pro forma credit quality measures remained favorable, although the balance of non-performing assets increased during the three months ended March 31, 2026. Pro forma non-performing assets increased from $54.1 million, or 0.33% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $68.7 million, or 0.42% of assets, at March 31, 2026. The increase in the updated balance of non-performing assets was the result of increases in non-performing loans for both Columbia Financial and Northfield Bancorp, as well as an increase in other real estate owned for Columbia Financial.

Columbia Financial’s pro forma funding composition showed a slight increase in deposits and a slight decrease in borrowings during the three months ended March 31, 2026. The increase in deposits was due to increases in Northfield Bancorp’s deposits and the estimated fair value merger adjustment applied for deposits, which was largely offset by a decrease in Columbia Financial’s deposits. Overall, pro forma deposits increased by $3.2 million to equal $12.462 billion, or 75.74% of assets, at March 31, 2026. The pro forma balance of borrowings declined from $2.146 billion, or 13.01% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $2.102 billion, or 12.77% of assets, at March 31, 2026. Columbia Financial’s pro forma tangible equity increased from $1.376 billion, or 8.35% of assets, at December 31, 2025 to $1.388 billion, or 8.43% of assets, at March 31, 2026. The increase in tangible equity was mostly due to the retention of earnings by both Columbia Financial and Northfield Bancorp during the three month period ended March 31, 2026, which was partially offset by an increase in the reduction in equity resulting from the estimated fair value merger adjustments as of March 31, 2026.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 7

 

Table 2

Columbia Financial, Inc.

Pro Forma Combined Recent Financial Data

 

     At December, 31, 2025     At March 31, 2026  
     Amount      Assets     Amount      Assets  
     ($000)      (%)     ($000)      (%)  

Balance Sheet Data

          

Total assets

   $ 16,488,131        100.00   $ 16,453,984        100.00

Cash, cash equivalents

     297,219        1.80       309,016        1.88  

Investment securities

     2,965,497        17.99       2,987,691        18.16  

Loans receivable, net

     11,863,328        71.95       11,770,124        71.53  

Bank-owned life insurance

     465,922        2.83       469,985        2.86  

FHLB/FRB stock

     111,172        0.67       125,060        0.76  

Goodwill and intangible assets

     190,926        1.16       193,586        1.18  

Deposits

     12,458,526        75.56       12,461,761        75.74  

Borrowings

     2,145,504        13.01       2,101,611        12.77  

Total equity

     1,567,325        9.51       1,581,313        9.61  

Tangible equity

     1,376,399        8.35       1,387,727        8.43  

 

     12 Months Ended     12 Months Ended  
     December 31, 2025     March, 31, 2026 (1)  
     Amount      Avg. Assets     Amount      Avg. Assets  
     ($000)      (%)     ($000)      (%)  

Summary Income Statement

          

Interest income

   $ 755,580        4.69   $ 768,451        4.73

Interest expense

     (361,464      (2.24     (358,553      (2.21
  

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net interest income

     394,116        2.45       409,898        2.52  

Provision for credit losses

     (17,224      (0.11     (12,912      (0.08
  

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net interest income after prov.

     376,892        2.34       396,986        2.44  

Non-interest operating income

     50,220        0.31       50,313        0.31  

Gain (loss) on securities

     290        0.00       288        0.00  

Change in fair value of equity securities

     2,567        0.02       1,140        0.01  

Merger expenses/Goodwill impairment

     (41,226      (0.26     (44,758      (0.28

Non-interest operating expense

     (281,676      (1.75     (284,179      (1.75
  

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

 

Income before income tax expense

     107,067        0.66       119,790        0.74  

Income taxes

     (38,530      (0.24     (43,002      (0.26
  

 

 

    

 

 

   

 

 

    

 

 

 

Net income

   $ 68,537        0.43   $ 76,788        0.47

 

(1)

Merger adjustments for the three months ended March 31, 2026 have been annualized.

 

Sources:

Columbia Financial’s prospectus, Columbian Financial’s and Northfield Bancorp’s audited and unaudited financial statements, and RP Financial calculations.

Pro forma operating results for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 and March 31, 2026 are also set forth in Table 2. The Company’s reported pro forma earnings increased from $68.5 million, or 0.43% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $76.8 million, or 0.47% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. The increase in pro forma net income was primarily realized through an increase in net interest income and a decrease in credit loss provisions, which was partially offset by increases in operating expenses, non-operating expenses and income taxes, and a decrease in non-operating income.

 


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 8

 

The increase in Columbia Financial’s pro forma net interest income during the most recent twelve month period was realized through increases in net interest income recorded by both Columbia Financial and Northfield Bancorp, as well as an increase in the estimated fair value merger adjustment for net interest income. Overall, pro forma net interest income increased from $394.1 million, or 2.45% of average assets, during the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $409.9 million, or 2.52% of average assets, during the twelve months ended March 31, 2026.

Pro forma operating expenses increased from $281.7 million or 1.75% of average assets during the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $284.2 million or 1.75% of average assets during the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. Overall, Columbia Financial’s updated pro forma ratios for net interest income and operating expenses provided for a slightly higher expense coverage ratio (net interest income divided by operating expenses). Columbia Financial’s pro forma expense coverage ratio increased from 1.40x for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to 1.44x for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026.

The Company’s updated pro forma earnings showed little change in non-interest operating income, which amounted to $50.3 million, or 0.31% of average assets, during the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. Overall, when factoring non-interest operating income into pro forma core earnings, the Company’s updated pro forma efficiency ratio of 61.84% (operating expenses as a percent of net interest income and non-interest operating income) was slightly more favorable than the 63.41% pro forma efficiency ratio recorded for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025.

The pro forma provision for credit losses decreased from $17.2 million, or 0.11% of average assets, during the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $12.9 million, or 0.08% of average assets, during the twelve months ended March 31, 2026, as both Columbia Financial and Northfield Bancorp reported lower credit loss provisions during the most recent twelve month period.

Pro forma non-operating income and losses, consisting of goodwill impairment, merger related expenses and securities gains, reflected an increase in the net non-operating loss recorded during the most recent twelve month period. The increase in the net non-operating loss was due to an increase in merger related expenses and a decrease in securities gains. Overall, the pro forma net non-operating loss increased from $38.4 million, or 0.24% of average assets, during the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $43.3 million, or 0.27% of average assets, during the twelve months ended Mach 31, 2026.

The pro forma income tax expense increased from $38.5 million, or 0.24% of average assets, for the twelve months ended December 31, 2025 to $43.0 million, or 0.26% of average assets, for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. Higher pro forma pre-tax earnings largely accounted for the increase in the pro forma income tax expense.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 9

 

2. Peer Group Financial Comparisons

Tables 3 and 4 present updated financial characteristics and operating results for Columbia Financial, the Peer Group and all publicly-traded thrifts. The financial data presented for Columbia Financial includes the estimated pro forma impact of the acquisition of Northfield Bancorp before the impact of the second-step offering, except that the regulatory capital ratios in Table 3 and the yield-cost spread in Table 4 are for Columbia Financial on a stand-alone basis. The Company’s and the Peer Group’s ratios are based on financial results through March 31, 2026.

In general, the comparative balance sheet ratios for the Company and the Peer Group did not vary significantly from the ratios exhibited in the Original Appraisal. Consistent with the Original Appraisal, the Company’s updated interest-earning asset composition reflected a lower concentration of loans and a higher concentration of cash and investments. Overall, the Company’s and the Peer Group’s updated interest-earning assets-to-assets ratios equaled 92.33% and 93.30%, respectively.

Consistent with the Original Appraisal, Columbia Financial’s funding composition showed a lower concentration of deposits and a higher concentration of borrowings relative to the comparable Peer Group measures. Updated interest-bearing liabilities-to-assets ratios equaled 88.51% and 87.43% for the Company and the Peer Group, respectively. Columbia Financial’s updated tangible equity-to-assets ratio equaled 8.43%, which remained slightly below the comparable Peer Group ratio of 8.97%. Overall, Columbia Financial’s updated interest-earning assets-to-interest-bearing liabilities (“IEA/IBL”) ratio equaled 104.32%, which remained below the comparable Peer Group ratio of 106.71%. As discussed in the Original Appraisal, the additional capital realized from stock proceeds should serve to increase Columbia Financial’s IEA/IBL ratio, as the level of interest-bearing liabilities funding assets will be lower due to the increase in capital realized from the offering and on the asset side of the balance sheet the net proceeds, net of the cash consideration to fund the acquisition of Northfield Bancorp, will be primarily deployed into interest-earning assets.

Updated growth rates for Columbia Financial and the Peer Group are based on growth for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. The Company’s growth rates reflect Columbia Financial’s growth and the pro forma growth resulting from the acquisition of Northfield Bancorp. Columbia Financial recorded a 55.11% increase in assets, versus an 11.24% increase in assets for the Peer Group. Asset growth by the Company reflected a 47.77% increase in loans and an 89.78% increase in cash and investments. Comparatively, the Peer Group’s asset growth was realized through a 10.44% increase in loans and was supplemented with a 16.58% increase in cash and investments.

Acquisition-related growth continued to be the primary source for the Company’s higher deposit growth rate, with the Company and the Peer Group posting updated deposit growth rates of 52.07% and 11.72%, respectively. With the acquisition of Northfield Bancorp, the Company’s borrowings increased 89.75% compared to a 2.93% increase in borrowings for the Peer Group. Updated pre-conversion tangible equity growth rates for the Company and the Peer Group equaled 41.43% and 12.91%, respectively. The Company’s post-conversion capital growth rate will initially be constrained by maintenance of a higher pro forma capital position. Additionally, implementation of any stock repurchases and dividend payments,


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 10

 

Table 3  
Balance Sheet Composition and Growth Rates  
Comparable Institution Analysis  
As of March 31, 2026 or the Most Recent Date Available  
                 Balance Sheet as a Percent of Assets     Balance Sheet Annual Growth Rates     Regulatory Capital  
                 Cash &
Equival.
    MBS &
Invest
    BOLI     Net
Loans (1)
    Deposits     Borrowed
Funds
    Sub.
Debt
    Total
Equity
    Goodwill
& Intang
    Tangible
Equity
    Assets     MBS, Cash
Invests
    Loans     Deposits     Borrows.
&Subdebt
    Total
Equity
    Tangible
Equity
    Tier 1
Leverage
     Tier 1
Risk-Based
     Risk-Based
Capital
 

Columbia Financial, Inc.

     NJ                                             

March 31, 2026

        1.88     18.92     2.86     71.53     75.74     12.40     0.37     9.61     1.18     8.43     55.11     89.78     47.77     52.07     89.75     43.71     41.43     10.40      14.23      15.14

All Public Banks and Non-MHC Thrifts

                                             

Averages

        6.37     16.55     1.48     70.44     81.61     4.65     0.80     11.49     1.68     9.83     8.94     7.48     9.64     9.10     5.85     13.87     14.25     10.50      13.43      15.30

Medians

        5.17     15.27     1.52     73.18     82.60     3.17     0.70     11.03     1.24     9.14     4.42     3.04     5.71     4.38     -2.69     9.64     11.71     10.14      12.89      14.63

Comparable Group

                                             

Averages

        4.34     13.45     1.77     75.51     81.97     4.57     0.89     11.33     2.36     8.97     11.24     16.58     10.44     11.72     2.93     12.36     12.91     9.91      12.59      13.69

Medians

        2.80     13.47     1.87     75.98     83.54     2.81     1.05     11.36     2.18     8.92     6.40     9.66     3.89     8.46     -7.90     7.30     8.41     9.95      12.26      13.33

Comparable Group

                                             

CCNE

   CNB Financial Corporation      PA        7.08     11.83     1.88     74.78     83.86     2.64     1.24     10.44     1.42     9.02     35.25     17.41     39.53     30.77     106.13     42.37     32.30     10.53      13.67      14.50

CNOB

   ConnectOne Bancorp, Inc.      NJ        2.42     8.92     2.63     81.58     81.02     6.04     1.42     11.20     1.95     9.25     45.60     63.58     42.79     48.23     49.64     27.03     26.34     10.81      12.35      13.33

DCOM

   Dime Commercial Bancshares, Inc.      NY        13.73     10.33     2.70     70.34     84.00     3.18     1.54     9.98     1.06     8.92     6.40     47.95     -2.14     8.46     -14.52     6.02     6.86     10.42      14.62      15.60

FCF

   First Commonwealth Financial Corporation      PA        2.80     13.47     1.92     76.14     84.89     0.55     1.05     12.66     3.25     9.41     4.04     7.82     3.57     5.56     -48.93     7.30     8.41     9.95      12.01      13.76

KRNY

   Kearny Financial Corp.      NJ        1.63     15.11     4.10     75.54     75.31     13.93     0.00     10.03     1.51     8.52     -1.62     -3.28     -1.05     0.38     -12.68     1.99     2.43     8.92      13.70      14.64

NBTB

   NBT Bancorp Inc.      NY        4.42     17.03     1.97     70.41     84.81     0.99     0.84     11.81     3.13     8.68     16.88     21.11     15.51     17.38     -4.97     22.27     20.36     9.47      12.06      13.17

OCFC

   OceanFirst Financial Corp.      NJ        0.94     15.42     1.87     75.98     76.64     8.70     1.75     11.47     3.61     7.86     9.37     12.99     9.85     9.62     29.80     -2.33     -2.59     8.80      11.73      12.60

PGC

   Peapack-Gladstone Financial Corporation      NJ        3.29     10.61     0.62     82.81     88.67     1.38     0.00     9.08     0.58     8.50     8.12     -10.03     12.22     8.59     -25.64     12.44     13.66     9.02      10.77      11.83

PFS

   Provident Financial Services, Inc.      NJ        0.88     14.52     1.64     77.29     75.79     10.09     1.62     11.36     3.07     8.29     4.03     8.65     3.89     3.53     5.35     7.68     12.98     10.49      12.26      13.16

STBA

   S&T Bancorp, Inc.      PA        3.41     10.36     0.86     79.11     82.31     1.01     0.50     14.39     3.78     10.61     2.32     9.66     1.67     3.70     -23.05     0.89     1.29     11.31      13.87      15.44

TMP

   Tompkins Financial Corporation      NY        1.97     19.89     0.90     73.83     81.12     6.53     0.00     10.89     0.84     10.05     6.05     5.91     6.90     4.45     -7.90     27.70     34.92     8.98      11.74      12.66

UVSP

   Univest Financial Corporation      PA        2.73     6.59     1.75     84.33     83.69     2.81     1.21     11.69     2.18     9.51     2.09     8.17     1.59     2.33     -8.57     5.37     6.70     9.51      10.83      12.08

WSFS

   WSFS Financial Corporation      DE        11.18     20.71     0.17     59.50     83.54     1.58     0.41     12.28     4.35     7.93     7.58     25.64     1.38     9.42     -6.53     1.99     4.16     10.58      14.01      15.21

 

(1)

Includes loans held for sale.

Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.

Copyright (c) 2026 by RP® Financial, LC.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 11

 

Table 4  
Income as Percent of Average Assets and Yields, Costs, Spreads  
Comparable Institution Analysis  
For the 12 Months Ended March 31, 2026 or the Most Recent 12 Months Available  
                       Net Interest Income           Non-Interest Income           NonOp Items           Yields, Costs, and Spreads               
                 Net
Income
    Income     Expense     NII     Loss
Provis.
on IEA
    NII
After
Provis.
    Gain
on Sale of
Loans
    Other
Non-Int
Income
    Total
Non-Int
Expense
    Net Gains/
Losses (1)
    Extrao.
Items
    Provision
for
Taxes
    Yield
On IEA
    Cost
Of IBL
    Yld-Cost
Spread
    MEMO:
Assets/
FTE Emp.
     MEMO:
Effective
Tax Rate
 
                 (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     ($000)      (%)  

Columbia Financial, Inc.

     NJ                                      

March 31, 2026

        0.47     4.73     2.21     2.52     0.08     2.44     0.00     0.31     1.75     -0.27     0.00     0.26     4.77     3.06     1.71   $ 14,258        35.90

All Public Banks and Non-MHC Thrifts

                                      

Averages

        1.07     5.26     1.91     3.35     0.23     3.13     0.11     0.74     2.56     -0.08     0.00     0.29     5.64     2.71     2.93   $ 10,767        19.94

Medians

        1.11     5.14     1.84     3.31     0.11     3.15     0.03     0.55     2.43     -0.01     0.00     0.29     5.54     2.67     2.92   $ 9,567        21.06

Comparable Group

                                      

Averages

        1.07     4.98     1.89     3.10     0.15     2.93     0.02     0.68     2.28     0.06     0.00     0.35     5.35     2.71     2.63   $ 11,645        24.17

Medians

        1.16     5.05     2.02     3.13     0.11     3.08     0.01     0.56     2.42     -0.01     0.00     0.33     5.33     2.70     2.59   $ 10,452        23.25

Comparable Group

                                      

CCNE

   CNB Financial Corporation      PA        1.07     5.50     2.02     3.48     0.12     3.27     0.00     0.50     2.44     -0.09     0.00     0.26     5.95     2.66     3.29   $ 9,166        19.33

CNOB

   ConnectOne Bancorp, Inc.      NJ        0.74     5.30     2.32     2.98     0.37     2.62     0.02     0.18     1.58     -0.20     0.00     0.30     5.68     3.27     2.41   $ 19,228        28.90

DCOM

   Dime Commercial Bancshares, Inc.      NY        0.85     4.76     1.85     2.91     0.30     2.61     0.01     0.32     1.72     -0.01     0.00     0.36     5.04     2.90     2.14   $ 16,796        29.90

FCF

   First Commonwealth Financial Corporation      PA        1.29     5.27     1.67     3.61     0.03     3.50     0.06     0.68     2.42     0.06     0.00     0.33     5.72     2.47     3.25   $ 7,703        20.45

KRNY

   Kearny Financial Corp.      NJ        0.47     4.25     2.27     1.99     0.04     1.95     0.01     0.26     1.65     0.02     0.00     0.11     4.52     2.78     1.74   $ 14,167        19.49

NBTB

   NBT Bancorp Inc.      NY        1.16     4.67     1.33     3.34     0.19     3.15     0.00     1.28     2.77     -0.11     0.00     0.35     5.11     2.12     2.99   $ 6,949        23.13

OCFC

   OceanFirst Financial Corp.      NJ        0.50     4.72     2.06     2.66     0.09     2.57     0.02     0.26     2.04     -0.14     0.00     0.15     5.13     2.70     2.43   $ 16,099        23.25

PGC

   Peapack-Gladstone Financial Corporation      NJ        0.60     5.05     2.12     2.93     0.36     2.57     0.02     1.10     2.90     0.02     0.00     0.24     5.13     2.94     2.19   $ 11,406        28.74

PFS

   Provident Financial Services, Inc.      NJ        1.24     5.20     2.07     3.13     0.00     3.14     0.00     0.44     1.86     0.00     0.00     0.49     5.61     2.86     2.75   $ 13,549        28.12

STBA

   S&T Bancorp, Inc.      PA        1.39     5.29     1.66     3.62     0.11     3.52     0.00     0.56     2.33     -0.02     0.00     0.35     5.72     2.68     3.04   $ 8,191        20.19

TMP

   Tompkins Financial Corporation      NY        2.00     4.73     1.56     3.17     0.09     3.08     0.00     0.66     2.43     1.26     0.00     0.79     4.94     2.35     2.59   $ 10,452        28.29

UVSP

   Univest Financial Corporation      PA        1.16     5.26     2.27     3.00     0.14     2.85     0.04     1.03     2.50     0.00     0.00     0.29     5.60     3.21     2.39   $ 8,525        19.97

WSFS

   WSFS Financial Corporation      DE        1.44     4.76     1.32     3.44     0.11     3.33     0.04     1.61     3.01     -0.04     0.00     0.47     5.33     2.30     3.03   $ 9,158        24.48

 

(1)

Net gains/losses includes gain/loss on sale of securities and nonrecurring income and expense.

Source:

S&P Global Market Intelligence and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.

Copyright (c) 2026 by RP® Financial, LC.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 12

 

pursuant to regulatory limitations and guidelines, could also slow the Company’s capital growth rate in the longer term following the stock offering.

Table 4 displays comparative operating results for Columbia Financial and the Peer Group, based on earnings for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. The Company’s earnings have been adjusted to reflect the pro forma impact of the Northfield Bancorp acquisition, with the exception of the Company’s yield-cost interest rate spread. Columbia Financial and the Peer Group reported net income to average assets ratios of 0.47% and 1.07%, respectively. The Peer Group’s higher return was realized through higher ratios for net interest income, non-interest operating income and non-operating income and lower effective tax rate, while the Company maintained earnings advantages with respect to lower ratios for credit loss provisions and operating expenses.

Updated expense coverage ratios posted by Columbia Financial and the Peer Group equaled 1.44x and 1.36x, respectively, as the Peer Group’s higher net interest income ratio was more than offset by the Company’s lower operating expense ratio. The Peer Group’s higher net interest income ratio was realized through a higher interest income ratio and a lower interest expense ratio.

Non-interest operating income remained a more significant contributor to the Peer Group’s earnings, as such income amounted to 0.31% and 0.70% of the Company’s and the Peer Group’s average assets, respectively. Accordingly, taking non-interest operating income into account in assessing Columbia Financial’s core earnings strength relative to the Peer Group’s, the Company’s updated efficiency ratio of 61.84% remained slightly less favorable than the Peer Group’s efficiency ratio of 60.00%.

Credit loss provisions remained a slightly larger factor in the Peer Group’s earnings, equaling 0.08% and 0.15% of average assets for the Company and the Peer Group, respectively.

Non-operating gains and losses remain as an earning advantage for the Peer Group. The Company recorded a net non-operating loss equal to 0.27% of average assets, versus net non-operating income equal to 0.06% of average assets for the Peer Group. As set forth in the Original Appraisal, typically, such gains and losses are discounted in valuation analyses as they tend to have a relatively high degree of volatility, and, thus, are not considered part of core operations. Extraordinary items remained a non-factor in the Company’s and the Peer Group’s updated earnings.

The Company’s effective tax rate of 35.90% remained above the Peer Group’s effective tax rate of 24.17%.

The Company’s updated credit quality measures continued to imply a slightly lower degree of credit risk exposure relative to the comparable Peer Group measures. Columbia Financial’s ratios include the pro forma impact of the Northfield Bancorp acquisition. As shown in Table 5, the Company’s non-performing assets/assets and non-performing loans/loans ratios of 0.42% and 0.53%, respectively, were lower than the comparable Peer Group ratios of 0.87% and 1.07%. The Company’s updated reserve coverage ratios indicated a lower level of reserves as a percent of non-performing loans (109.51% versus 125.68% for the


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 13

 

Table 5

Credit Risk Measures and Related Information

Comparable Institution Analysis

As of March 31, 2026 or the Most Recent Date Available

 

                 REO/
Assets
    NPAs &
90+Del/
Assets (1)
    NPLs/
Loans (2)
    Rsrves/
Loans HFI
    Rsrves/
NPLs (2)
    Rsrves/
NPAs &
90+Del (1)
    Net Loan
Chargeoffs (3)
     NLCs/
Loans
 
                 (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     ($000)      (%)  

Columbia Financial, Inc.

     NJ                    

March 31, 2026

        0.04     0.42     0.53     0.58     109.51     100.07   $ 7,274        0.06

All Public Banks and Non-MHC Thrifts

                    

Averages

        0.05     0.63     0.76     1.26     242.20     212.49   $ 198,661        0.29

Medians

        0.01     0.51     0.62     1.17     183.90     169.00   $ 6,885        0.14

Comparable Group

                    

Averages

        0.03     0.87     1.07     1.10     125.68     111.51   $ 19,458        0.21

Medians

        0.00     0.76     0.92     1.11     109.82     105.09   $ 16,308        0.19

Comparable Group

                    

CCNE

   CNB Financial Corporation      PA        0.03     0.59     0.74     1.01     137.11     128.85   $ 6,638        0.09

CNOB

   ConnectOne Bancorp, Inc.      NJ        0.00     0.75     0.83     1.30     156.36     144.60   $ 21,490        0.20

DCOM

   Dime Commercial Bancshares, Inc.      NY        0.00     1.06     1.49     0.95     63.38     63.38   $ 33,836        0.31

FCF

   First Commonwealth Financial Corporation      PA        0.00     1.00     1.26     1.37     108.52     105.73   $ 34,438        0.36

KRNY

   Kearny Financial Corp.      NJ        0.00     1.06     1.38     0.77     55.77     55.77   $ 2,393        0.04

NBTB

   NBT Bancorp Inc.      NY        0.00     0.39     0.51     1.20     235.41     222.65   $ 16,403        0.14

PGC

   Peapack-Gladstone Financial Corporation      NJ        0.00     1.88     2.25     1.04     46.31     46.31   $ 34,553        0.57

PFS

   Provident Financial Services, Inc.      NJ        0.01     0.72     0.91     0.90     99.31     98.20   $ 13,923        0.07

STBA

   S&T Bancorp, Inc.      PA        0.00     0.73     0.92     1.17     127.90     127.90   $ 16,212        0.20

TMP

   Tompkins Financial Corporation      NY        0.00     0.64     0.85     0.90     105.20     104.45   $ 10,431        0.17

UVSP

   Univest Financial Corporation      PA        0.30     0.76     0.49     1.28     261.72     143.87   $ 10,695        0.16

WSFS

   WSFS Financial Corporation      DE        0.06     0.85     1.21     1.36     111.12     96.40   $ 32,481        0.24

 

(1)

NPAs are defined as nonaccrual loans, accruing loans 90 days or more past due, performing TDRs, and OREO.

(2)

NPLs are defined as nonaccrual loans, accruing loans 90 days or more past due and performing TDRs.

(3)

Net loan chargeoffs are shown on a last twelve month basis.

 

Source:

S&P Global Market Intelligence and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obrained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.

Copyright (c) 2026 by RP® Financial, LC.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 14

 

Peer Group) and a lower level of reserves as a percent of loans (0.58% versus 1.10% for the Peer Group). The Company’s lower reserve ratios reflect fair value accounting for the acquisition of Northfield Bancorp, which eliminates Northfield Bancorp’s allowance for credit losses. Net loan charge-offs remained a more significant factor for the Peer Group, with net loan charge-offs as a percent of loans equal to 0.21% for the Peer Group compared to 0.06% for the Company.

3. Stock Market Conditions

Since the date of the Original Appraisal, the performance of the broader stock market has generally been positive. Signs that the U.S. economy was gaining momentum propelled the Dow Jones Industrial Average (“DJIA”) to a close above 50000 for the first time on February 6, 2026. Worries that the rapidly growing artificial intelligence (“AI”) industry would hurt the long-term outlook for technology and financial companies, along with U.S. military build-up in the Middle East, pressured stocks lower through mid-February. Technology stocks led a stock market rebound in late-February, which was followed by stocks generally trading lower through the first half of March. Factors contributing to the stock market selloff included concerns about AI disruption, market stress for private-credit lenders, a spike in oil prices caused by the broadening Middle East conflict and a disappointing employment report for February. Concerns over how long the war with Iran would last and the prospect of Federal Reserve interest cuts being dimmed by higher oil prices sustained the broader stock market downturn through late-March, as the DJIA and NASDAQ moved into correction territory. Stocks ended a weak first quarter with a strong rally, which was driven by investors seeing a potential off ramp to the war with Iran.

After trading in a mixed range at the beginning of the second quarter of 2026, a two-week cease-fire between the U.S. and Iran and the potential for a peace deal that would reopen the Strait of Hormuz propelled stock market gains through mid-April. Uncertainty surrounding the ongoing negotiations between the U.S. and Iran provided for an up and down market in the second half April, with the major U.S. stock indexes rallying higher at end of April in reaction to the strong earnings reported by Alphabet and Caterpillar. Overall, April was the best month for stocks since 2020. The first couple of trading days of May saw the NASDAQ and the S&P 500 close at fresh highs, which was followed by stocks trading lower as fighting in the Iran war escalated and oil prices spiked higher. A better-than-expected jobs report for April and a strong rally in technology stocks tied to the buildout of AI related industries powered the S&P 500 and NASDAQ to record highs heading into mid-May. Stocks turned lower going into the second half of May, as higher oil prices raised inflation concerns that also sparked a selloff in Treasury bonds. Growing optimism over a peace deal between the U.S. and Iran, along with some strong earnings reports drove major U.S. stock indexes to record highs in the last week of May. Renewed skepticism over the U.S. and Iran negotiating a peace deal caused stocks to retreat at the beginning of June, with the S&P 500 trading lower on June 3rd after nine consecutive days of gains. Healthcare and financial stocks led the DJIA to a record high close ahead of the release of May’s unemployment report, which was followed by a steep selloff in tech shares with the NASDAQ posting its worst day in more than a year on June 5th. The selloff was prompted by fears of rising interest rates based on May’s employment report showing stronger-than-expected job, as well as new concerns that the significant investment in AI technology would not produce adequate returns. Renewed fighting in the Middle East followed by hopes that the U.S. and Iran were nearing a peace deal translated into a volatile market for


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 15

 

the major U.S. stock indexes heading into mid-June. Oil prices fell, bonds rallied and the DJIA closed at a record high on June 15th after President announced a deal to end the war with Iran. Market volatility continued going in the second half of June as stocks fell after the Federal Reserve left its target rate unchanged while signaling their next move might be to raise interest rates, which was followed stock rebounding on expectations that the reopening the Strait of Hormuz would provide for lower oil prices and ease inflationary pressures. On June 18, 2026, the DJIA closed at 51564.70 or 4.37% higher since the date of the Original Appraisal and the NASDAQ closed at 26517.93 or 12.40% higher since the date of the Original Appraisal. The S&P 500 closed at 7500.58 on June 18, 2026, an increase of 7.51% since the date of the Original Appraisal.

The market for financial shares has been mixed since the date of the Original Appraisal. After trading higher at the beginning of February on indications that U.S. economy was gaining momentum, bank stocks were among the sectors that experienced a mid-February selloff on concerns that AI would hurt the long-term outlook for financial companies. Concerns about the direction of interest rates, fading hopes of a quick resolution to the war with Iran and a challenging market for private lenders factored into bank shares continuing to trade lower in the second half of March. Bank stocks rallied along with the broader stock market at the conclusion of the first quarter and into early-April and then stabilized through mid-April at the start of the second quarter earnings season. As bank earnings were generally in-line with expectations, bank stocks traded in a narrow range through the second half of April and the beginning of May. A spike in oil prices and higher interest rates translated into bank shares trading lower at the start of the first full week of May. Inflation concerns contributed to bank shares experiencing additional selling pressure in mid-May, while the prospect of a Middle East peace deal contributed to bank shares trading higher for the balance of May and the start of June. Bank shares surged higher ahead of the release of the jobs report for May, as financial stocks were viewed as a safe haven investment alternative for investors concerned about a potential bubble in tech stocks. Favorable economic data regarding the May employment report showing strong job growth and a pick-up in existing home sales for May helped to sustain the positive trend in bank stocks going into mid-June. Bank shares retreated slightly at the conclusion of the Federal Reserve’s mid-June policy meeting and then edged up going into the second half of June on expectations that lower oil prices would ease inflationary pressures. On June 18, 2026, the S&P BMI Banks Index closed at 264.5, an increase of 3.40% since February 2, 2026.

Since the date of the Original Appraisal, the updated pricing measures for the Peer Group indicate that the Peer Group outperformed the market for all publicly-traded banks and thrifts. Since the date of the Original Appraisal, the stock prices of all twelve Peer Group companies were higher as of June 18, 2026. A comparative pricing analysis of the Peer Group and all publicly-traded banks and thrifts is shown in the following table, based on closing stock market prices as of February 2, 2026 and June 18, 2026.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 16

 

Average Pricing Characteristics

 

     At Feb. 2,
2026
    At June 18,
2026
    %
Change
 

Peer Group

      

Price/Earnings (x)

     12.85     13.34     3.81

Price/Core Earnings (x)

     12.81       13.17       2.81  

Price/Book (%)

     107.09     118.03     10.22  

Price/Tangible Book(%)

     136.39       148.82       9.11  

Price/Assets (%)

     12.04       13.21       9.72  

Avg. Mkt. Capitalization ($Mil)

   $ 1,619.18     $ 1,746.85       7.88  

All Publicly-Traded Banks and Thrifts

      

Price/Earnings (x)

     13.46     13.32     (1.04 )% 

Price/Core Earnings (x)

     12.90       12.49       (3.18

Price/Book (%)

     124.42     127.33     2.34  

Price/Tangible Book(%)

     149.05       152.90       2.58  

Price/Assets (%)

     13.88       14.13       1.80  

Avg. Mkt. Capitalization ($Mil)

   $ 10,076.84     $ 10,437.81       3.58  

As set forth in the Original Appraisal, the “new issue” market is separate and distinct from the market for seasoned issues like the Peer Group companies in that the pricing ratios for converting issues are computed on a pro forma basis, specifically: (1) the numerator and denominator are both impacted by the conversion offering amount, unlike existing stock issues in which price change affects only the numerator; and (2) the pro forma pricing ratio incorporates assumptions regarding source and use of proceeds, effective tax rates, stock plan purchases, etc. which impact pro forma financials, whereas pricing for existing issues are based on reported financials. The distinction between the pricing of converting and existing issues is perhaps most evident in the case of the price/book (“P/B”), and the price/tangible book (“P/TB”) ratio, in that the book value based ratios of a converting thrift will typically result in a discount to book value, whereas in the current market for existing thrifts the P/B ratio, and P/TB ratiom, may reflect a premium to book value. Therefore, it is appropriate to also consider the market for new issues, both at the time of the conversion and in the aftermarket.

As shown in Table 6, five standard conversions and two second-step conversions have been completed during the past twelve months. The second-step conversion offerings are considered to be more relevant for Columbia Financial’s pro forma pricing. The average closing pro forma price/tangible book ratio of the two recent second-step conversion offerings equaled 58.9%. On average, the two recent second-step conversion offerings had price appreciation of 11.1% after their first week of trading. As of June 18, 2026, the two recent second-step conversion offerings showed an average price increase of 48.2% from their respective second-step offering prices.

The comparability of the recent second-step conversion offerings to Columbia Financial’s second-step offering is somewhat limited by the significantly larger size of the


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 17

 

Table 6

Pricing Characteristics and After-Market Trends

Conversions Completed Twelve Months Ended June 18, 2026

 

Institutional Information

   Pre-Conversion Data     Offering Information     Contribution to     Insider Purchases           Pro Forma Data             Post-IPO Pricing Trends  
                 Financial Info.     Asset Quality                              Char. Found.     % Off Incl. Fdn.+Merger Shares           Pricing Ratios(2)(5)      Financial Charac.             Closing Price:  
                                          Excluding Foundation            % of     Benefit Plans           Initial                                                     First             After             After                       

Institution

   Conversion
Date
    

Ticker

   Assets      Equity/
Assets
    NPAs/
Assets
    Res.
Cov.
    Gross
Proc.
     %
Offer
    % of
Mid.
    Exp./
Proc.
    Form      Public Off.
Inc. Fdn.
    ESOP     Recog.
Plans
    Stk
Option
    Mgmt.&
Dirs.
    Div.
Yield
    P/TB     Core
P/E
     P/A      Core
ROA
     TE/A      Core
ROE
     IPO
Price
     Trading
Day
     %
Chg
     First
Week(3)
     %
Chg
     First
Month(4)
     %
Chg
     Thru
6/18/2026
     %
Chg
 
                 ($Mil)      (%)     (%)     (%)     ($Mil.)      (%)     (%)     (%)            (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)(1)     (%)     (%)     (x)      (%)      (%)      (%)      (%)      ($)      ($)      (%)      ($)      (%)      ($)      (%)      ($)      (%)  

Standard Conversions

                                                                                  

PSB Financial, Inc. -MT

     5/22/26      PNSB-OTCQB    $ 120        15.39     0.71     134   $ 17.2        100     132     9.3     N.A.        N.A.       8.0     4.0     10.0     6.1     0.00     53.7     55.6x        12.9      0.1      24.0      0.4    $ 10.00      $ 10.50        5.0    $ 11.55        15.5    $ 11.15        11.5    $ 11.15        11.5

URSB Bancorp, Inc. - NJ*

     3/27/26      URSB-OTCQB    $ 353        5.42     0.28     200   $ 23.1        100     132     7.4     C/S      $ 250/0.86     8.0     4.0     10.0     3.0     0.00     62.0     36.8x        6.3      0.2      10.1      1.7    $ 10.00      $ 10.70        7.0    $ 11.48        14.8    $ 11.35        13.5    $ 11.45        14.5

Hoyne Bancorp, Inc. -IL*

     12/4/25      HYNE-NASDAQ    $ 453        19.60     0.20     269   $ 79.4        100     132     3.4     C/S      $ 250/2.00     8.0     4.0     10.0     3.0     0.00     52.0     NM        15.6      0.0      30.0      -0.1    $ 10.00      $ 14.00        40.0    $ 13.75        37.5    $ 14.19        41.9    $ 16.59        65.9

Security Midwest Bancorp, Inc., IL

     8/1/25      SBMW-OTCQB    $ 218        6.41     0.40     129   $ 8.9        100     89     15.2     N.A.        N.A.       7.0     3.0     10.0     13.5     0.00     45.4     9.0x        4.0      0.4      8.8      5.1    $ 10.00      $ 11.40        14.0    $ 11.12        11.2    $ 12.30        23.0    $ 17.00        70.0

Avidia Bancorp, Inc., MA*

     8/1/25      AVBC-NYSE    $ 2,707        6.87     0.44     184   $ 191.8        100     132     3.0     C/S      $ 1,000/4.48     8.0     4.0     10.0     3.4     0.00     59.5     14.2x        7.0      0.5      11.8      4.1    $ 10.00      $ 14.64        46.4    $ 14.58        45.8    $ 15.47        54.7    $ 20.14        101.4
     Averages - Standard Conversions:    $ 770        10.74     0.41     183   $ 64.1        100     123     7.7     N.A.        N.A.       7.8     3.8     10.0     5.8     0.00     54.5     28.9x        9.2      0.2      16.9      2.2    $ 10.00      $ 12.25        22.5    $ 12.50        25.0    $ 12.89        28.9    $ 15.27        52.7
     Medians - Standard Conversions:    $ 353        6.87     0.40     184   $ 23.1        100     132     7.4     N.A.        N.A.       8.0     4.0     10.0     3.4     0.00     53.7     25.5x        7.0      0.2      11.8      1.7    $ 10.00      $ 11.40        14.0    $ 11.55        15.5    $ 12.30        23.0    $ 16.59        65.9

Second Step Conversions

                                                                                  

Seneca Bancorp, Inc., NY*

     10/16/25      SNNF-OTCQX    $ 299        7.94     0.31     186   $ 10.4        58     100     15.1     N.A.        N.A.       8.0     4.0     10.0     9.6     0.00     58.6     20.8x        5.8      0.3      16.9      2.8    $ 10.00      $ 10.22        2.2    $ 10.10        1.0    $ 9.75        -2.5    $ 12.23        22.3

Lake Shore Bancorp, Inc., NY*

     7/21/25      LSBK-NASDAQ    $ 689        13.16     0.66     114   $ 49.5        63     99     4.4     N.A.        N.A.       8.0     4.0     10.0     5.3     0.00     59.2     14.4x        10.7      0.7      18.1      4.1    $ 10.00      $ 11.95        19.5    $ 12.11        21.1    $ 12.33        23.3    $ 17.40        74.0
     Averages - Second Step Conversions:    $ 494        10.55     0.49     150   $ 30.0        61     100     9.8     N.A.        N.A.       8.0     4.0     10.0     7.5     0.00     58.9     17.6x        8.3      0.5      17.5      3.5    $ 10.00      $ 11.09        10.9    $ 11.11        11.1    $ 11.04        10.4    $ 14.82        48.2
     Medians - Second Step Conversions:    $ 494        10.55     0.49     150   $ 30.0        61     100     9.8     N.A.        N.A.       8.0     4.0     10.0     7.5     0.00     58.9     17.6x        8.3      0.5      17.5      3.5    $ 10.00      $ 11.09        10.9    $ 11.11        11.1    $ 11.04        10.4    $ 14.82        48.2

Mutual Holding Companies

                                                                                  
     Averages - MHC Conversions:                                                                             
     Medians - MHC Conversions:                                                                             
     Averages - All Conversions:    $ 691        10.68     0.43     174   $ 54.3        89     117     8.3     N.A.        N.A.       7.9     3.9     10.0     6.3     0.00     55.8     25.1x        8.9      0.3      17.1      2.6    $ 10.00      $ 11.92        19.2    $ 12.10        21.0    $ 12.36        23.6    $ 15.14        51.4
     Medians - All Conversions:    $ 353        7.94     0.40     184   $ 23.1        100     132     7.4     N.A.        N.A.       8.0     4.0     10.0     5.3     0.00     58.6     17.6x        7.0      0.3      16.9      2.8    $ 10.00      $ 11.40        14.0    $ 11.55        15.5    $ 12.30        23.0    $ 16.59        65.9

Note: *—Appraisal performed by RP Financial; BOLD = RP Financial assisted in the business plan preparation, “NT” - Not Traded; “NA” - Not Applicable, Not Available; C/S-Cash/Stock.

 

(1)   As a percent of MHC offering for MHC transactions.

  

(5)   Mutual holding company pro forma data on full conversion basis.

(2)   Does not take into account the adoption of SOP 93-6.

  

(6)   Simultaneously completed acquisition of another financial  institution.

(3)   Latest price if offering is less than one week old.

  

(7)   Simultaneously converted to a commercial bank charter.

(4)   Latest price if offering is more than one week but less than one month old.

  

(8)   Former credit union.6/18/2026


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 18

 

Company’s offering, which is expected to attract large and institutional investor interest relative to the two smaller second-step offerings referenced.

As set forth in the Original Appraisal, RP Financial’s analysis of stock market conditions also considered recent trading activity in CLBK’s stock. Since the date of the Original Appraisal, the trading price of CLBK’s stock ranged from a low closing price of $17.18 on March 18, 2026 to a high closing price of $20.94 on June 9, 2026. As of June 18, 2026, the Company’s closing stock price was $20.03 per share, indicating a 13.10% increase from CLBK’s closing stock price of $17.71 per share as of the February 2, 2026 date of the Original Appraisal.

4. Results of the Offering

Columbia Financial’s subscription offering concluded on June 16, 2026. The total takedown of the offering amounted to $934,930,290, based on orders received for 93,493,029 shares at $10.00 per share. There were 5,226 orders received for the Company’s stock. The total orders received in the subscription offering were below the $1.0 billion adjusted minimum of the offering range. Based on information provided by Keefe, Bruyette & Woods, Inc. (“KBW”) there were 100 orders for the individual maximum order amount of $3.0 million and one order for the group maximum purchase amount of $10.0 million, which totaled $310.0 million or 33.16% of the total takedown. Out-of-state orders (excluding 401(k) purchases) accounted for 62.58% of the total takedown and 70.29% of the maximum orders received (including the one group maximum purchase order). The prospectus indicated that intended purchases by the Board, executive officers and their associates totaled $4.2 million. A distribution summary of the orders received, as provided by KBW, is shown in the table below.

 

Category

   Shares
Ordered
     Number of
Orders
     Average
Shares
Ordered
     Percent of
Total
Orders
 

Eligible Account Holders

     88,044,804        4,991        17,641        94.17

ESOP(1)

     —         —         —         —   

401(k)

     736,994        1        736,994        0.79  

Supplemental Elg. Acct. Holders

     4,433,958        186        23,838        4.74  

Other Members

     277,273        48        5,777        0.30  
  

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

    

 

 

 

Total(2)

     93,493,029        5,226        17,890        100.00

(1) ESOP will purchase 3.0% of the second-step offering shares at the proposed closing value.

Summary of Adjustments

In the Original Appraisal, we made the following adjustments to Columbia Financial’s pro forma value based upon our comparative analysis to the Peer Group:


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 19

 

Key Valuation Parameters:

   Previous Valuation
Adjustment
Financial Condition    Slight Upward
Profitability, Growth and Viability of Earnings    Slight Downward
Asset Growth    Slight Upward
Primary Market Area    No Adjustment
Dividends    No Adjustment
Liquidity of the Shares    No Adjustment
Marketing of the Issue    No Adjustment
Management    No Adjustment
Effect of Govt. Regulations and Regulatory Reform    No Adjustment

The factors concerning the valuation parameters of primary market area, dividends, liquidity of the shares, management and effect of government regulations and regulatory reform did not change since the Original Appraisal. Accordingly, those parameters were not discussed further in this update.

In terms of balance sheet strength, on a pro forma basis the Company’s updated financial condition continued to warrant a slight upward adjustment, with the Company’s higher pro forma capital position as a percent of assets continuing to provide the primary basis for the adjustment. A slight downward adjustment remained appropriate for earnings, based on the Company’s lower pro forma core earnings measures for ROAA and ROAE. The slight upward adjustment for asset growth continued to give consideration to the Company’s higher pro forma tangible equity-to-assets ratio and resulting greater leverage capacity, as well stronger historical growth provided by the acquisition of Northfield Bancorp.

The broader market for bank and thrift stocks was up slightly since the date of the Original Appraisal, with the market-cap weighted S&P U.S. BMI Banks Index increasing 3.40% since the date of the Original Appraisal. Comparatively, the overall stock market outperformed bank stocks since the date of the Original Appraisal, as indicated by increases of 4.37%, 12.40% and 7.51% in the DJIA, NASDAQ and S&P 500, respectively. Comparatively, the Peer Group’s updated pricing measures, as well as CLBK’s stock price, showed more significant increases relative to the S&P U.S. BMI Banks Index and the updated pricing measures for all publicly-traded banks and thrifts. Two second-step conversion offerings have been completed during the past twelve and are currently trading above their IPO prices. Both of the second-step offerings were significantly smaller offerings compared to the size of Columbia Financial’s offering. Total orders received in the subscription offering were less than the adjusted minimum of the offering range.

Valuation Approaches

In applying the accepted valuation methodology promulgated by the regulatory agencies, i.e., the pro forma market value approach, we considered the three key pricing ratios in valuing Columbia Financial’s to-be-issued stock — price/earnings (“P/E”), price/book (“P/B”), and price/assets (“P/A”) approaches — all performed on a pro forma basis including the effects of the conversion proceeds and the merger with Northfield Bancorp.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 20

 

In computing the pro forma impact of the offering and the related pricing ratios, the valuation parameters utilized in the Original Appraisal were updated with Columbia Financial’s and Northfield Bancorp’s financial data as of March 31, 2026.

Consistent with the Original Appraisal, this updated appraisal continues to be based primarily on fundamental analysis techniques applied to the Peer Group, including the P/E approach, the P/B approach and the P/A approach. Also consistent with the Original Appraisal, this updated appraisal incorporates a “technical” analysis of recently completed offerings, including principally the P/B approach which (as discussed in the Original Appraisal) is the most meaningful pricing ratio as the pro forma P/E ratios reflect an assumed reinvestment rate and do not yet reflect the actual use of proceeds.

RP Financial also considered the trading price of CLBK’s stock, which had a closing price of $20.03 as of June 18, 2026, an increase of 13.10% from its closing price as of February 2, 2026. The $20.03 closing trading price implied a pro forma market capitalization of approximately $2.083 billion, which is between the minimum and midpoint of the full conversion valuation range as set forth in the Original Appraisal.

The Company has adopted “Employers’ Accounting for Employee Stock Ownership Plans” (“ASC 718-40”), which causes earnings per share computations to be based on shares issued and outstanding excluding unreleased ESOP shares. For purposes of preparing the pro forma pricing analyses, we have reflected all shares issued in the offering, including all ESOP shares, to capture the full dilutive impact, particularly since the ESOP shares are economically dilutive, receive dividends and can be voted. However, we did consider the impact of ASC 718-40 in the valuation.

In preparing the pro forma pricing analysis, we took into account the FRB’s policy potentially leading to minority shareholder dilution with the consolidation of the MHC’s net assets with the issuer’s equity at closing. In the Company’s case, however, the MHC has net liabilities of $48,000, leading to a nominal reduction of equity. Accordingly, no adjustment to the minority shareholder exchange ratio per the FRB policy is applicable in the Company’s second-step conversion.

Overall, taking into account the foregoing factors, RP Financial concluded that as of June 18, 2026, the aggregate pro forma value of Columbia Financial’s conversion stock equaled $2,291,268,770, equal to 229,126,877 shares at $10.00 per share. The midpoint, which was unchanged from the midpoint value set forth in the Original Appraisal, is based on the sale of a 73.10% ownership interest to the public. The public offering at the midpoint value is $1,675,000,000, equal to 167,500,000 shares at $10.00 per share. The aggregate pro forma market value of Columbia Financial’s conversion stock, including the 41,800,140 shares of stock to-be-issued for the acquisition of Northfield Bancorp, was $2,709,270,170 at the midpoint, equal to 270,927,017 shares at $10.00 per share. The 73.10% ownership interest was based on the Company’s shares outstanding as of December 31, 2025, which is consistent with the date of the pro forma data in the Company’s prospectus. As of March 31, 2026, the MHC’s ownership interest equaled 72.99%.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 21

 

1. Price-to-Earnings (“P/E”). The application of the P/E valuation method requires calculating the Company’s pro forma market value by applying a valuation P/E multiple to the pro forma earnings base. In applying this technique, we considered both reported earnings and a recurring earnings base, that is, earnings adjusted to exclude any one-time non-operating items, plus the estimated after-tax earnings benefit of the reinvestment of the net proceeds. The Company’s reported earnings, including the estimated pro forma impact of the Northfield Bancorp acquisition, equaled $76.788 million for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026. In deriving Columbia Financial’s core earnings, the adjustments made to reported earnings were to eliminate gain on securities of $288,000, change in fair value of equity securities of $1.140 million, goodwill impairment of $41.012 million and merger related expense of $3.746 million. As shown below, assuming an effective marginal tax rate of 27.0% for the earnings adjustments, the Company’s core earnings were estimated at $108.420 million for the twelve months ended March 31, 2026.

 

     Amount  
     ($000)  

Net income (loss)

   $ 76,788  

Deduct; Gain on equity securities (1)

     (210

Deduct: Change in fair value of equity securities (1)

     (832

Add: Goodwill impairment (1)

     29,939  

Add: Merger related expenses (1)

     2,735  
  

 

 

 

Core earnings estimate

   $ 108,420  

 

(1)

Tax effected at 27.0%.

Based on Columbia Financial’s reported and estimated core earnings and incorporating the impact of the pro forma assumptions discussed previously, the Company’s reported and core P/E multiples at the $2.709 billion midpoint value equaled 25.84 times and 19.85 times, respectively. The Company’s updated reported and core P/E multiples indicate premiums of 93.70% and 50.72% relative to the Peer Group’s average reported and core P/E multiples of 13.34 times and 13.17 times, respectively (versus premiums of 122.41% and 72.21% relative to the Peer Group’s average reported and core P/E multiples as indicated in the Original Appraisal). The Company’s updated reported and core P/E multiples at the updated midpoint value indicated premiums of 96.35% and 54.84% relative to the Peer Group’s median reported and core P/E multiples, which equaled 13.16 times and 12.82 times, respectively (versus premiums of 124.51% and 79.64% relative to the Peer Group’s median reported and core P/E multiples as indicated in the Original Appraisal). The Company’s pro forma P/E ratios based on reported earnings at the adjusted minimum and the maximum equaled 22.23x and 27.90x, respectively, and based on core earnings at the adjusted minimum and the maximum equaled 16.33x and 21.66x, respectively. The Company’s implied conversion pricing ratios relative to the Peer Group’s pricing ratios are indicated in Table 7, and the pro forma calculations are detailed in Exhibits 2 and 3.

2. P/B Approach. In applying the P/B approach, we considered both reported book value and tangible book value, taking into account the pro forma impact of the Northfield Bancorp acquisition. Based on the $2.709 billion midpoint value, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios equaled 86.66% and 92.34%, respectively. In comparison to the average P/B and P/TB ratios indicated for the Peer Group of 118.03% and 148.82%, respectively, Columbia Financial’s updated ratios reflected a discount of 26.58% on a P/B basis and a discount of 37.95% on a P/TB basis (versus discounts of 18.73% and 31.99% from the Peer Group’s average P/B and


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 22

 

Table 7

Fully-Converted Market Pricing Versus Peer Group

Columbia Financial, Inc.

As of June 18, 2026

 

                 Market
Capitalization
     Per Share Data                                                                                                                       
                 Core
12 Month
EPS(1)
     Book
Value/
Share
                                     Dividends(3)     Financial Characteristics(5)                
                 Price/
Share
     Market
Value
     Pricing Ratios(2)      Amount/
Share
     Yield     Payout
Ratio(4)
    Total
Assets
     Equity/
Assets
    Tang. Eq./
T. Assets
    NPAs/
Assets
    Reported      Core      Offering
Range
     Exchange
Ratio
 
                 P/E      P/B     P/A     P/TB     P/Core     ROAA     ROAE      ROAA      ROAE  
                 ($)      ($Mil)      ($)      ($)      (x)      (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)      ($)      (%)     (%)     ($Mil)      (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)      (%)      (%)      ($Mil)      (xl)  

Columbia Financial, Inc.

     NJ                                                           

Maximum

      $ 10.00      $ 3,064.69      $ 0.46      $ 10.95        27.90x        91.32     16.80     96.99     21.66x      $ 0.20        2.00     55.79   $ 18,241        18.39     17.52     0.38     0.60     3.28      0.78      4.22    $ 1,926.25        2.5340x  

Midpoint

      $ 10.00      $ 2,709.27      $ 0.50      $ 11.54        25.84x        86.66     15.05     92.34     19.85x      $ 0.20        2.00     51.67   $ 17,999        17.37     16.47     0.38     0.58     3.35      0.76      4.37    $ 1,675.00        2.2035x  

Minimum

      $ 10.00      $ 2,365.58      $ 0.56      $ 12.22        23.74x        81.83     13.32     87.72     18.02x      $ 0.20        2.00     47.47   $ 17,764        16.28     15.35     0.39     0.56     3.45      0.74      4.54    $ 1,423.75        1.8729x  

Adjusted Minimum

      $ 10.00      $ 1,947.58      $ 0.61      $ 12.68        22.23x        78.86     11.23     85.54     16.33x      $ 0.20        2.00     44.47   $ 17,342        14.24     13.27     0.40     0.51     3.55      0.69      4.83    $ 1,005.75        1.8729x  

All Public Banks and Non-MHC Thrifts(6)

 

                                    

Averages

      $ 54.82      $ 10,437.81      $ 4.41      $ 41.77        13.32x        127.33     14.13     152.90     12.49x      $ 1.19        2.62     37.48   $ 76,367        11.49     9.98     0.60     1.06     9.54      1.16      10.43      

Median

      $ 35.04      $ 859.51      $ 3.09      $ 28.72        12.49x        119.55     13.37     146.73     11.80x      $ 1.00        2.57     31.46   $ 6,528        11.00     9.36     0.48     1.11     10.34      1.19      11.03      

All Public Banks and Non-MHC Thrifts State of NJ(6)

 

                                    

Averages

      $ 25.45      $ 1,347.76      $ 2.05      $ 24.92        14.45x        97.82     11.38     112.01     13.76x      $ 0.60        2.76     36.47   $ 11,591        11.76     10.49     0.64     0.94     7.86      0.96      8.11      

Medians

      $ 18.83      $ 533.04      $ 1.78      $ 22.63        13.05x        95.26     11.56     104.84     12.36x      $ 0.44        2.51     40.25   $ 3,971        11.47     9.43     0.66     0.86     7.29      0.96      8.45      

Comparable Group

 

                                    

Averages

      $ 41.47      $ 1,746.85      $ 3.17      $ 33.67        13.34x        118.03     13.21     148.82     13.17x      $ 1.01        2.74     34.38   $ 12,966        11.32     9.27     0.53     1.12     9.94      1.09      9.63      

Medians

      $ 40.32      $ 1,656.63      $ 2.88      $ 32.70        13.16x        120.48     13.02     144.35     12.82x      $ 0.86        2.73     36.84   $ 11,103        11.28     9.08     0.56     1.16     10.15      1.16      10.16      

Comparable Group

 

                                    

CCNE

   CNB Financial
Corporation
     PA      $ 32.16      $ 942.89      $ 3.08      $ 28.06        11.44x        114.63     11.27     134.19     10.44x      $ 0.76        2.38     26.33   $ 8,515        10.44     9.15     0.58     1.07     10.36      1.17      11.35      

CNOB

   ConnectOne
Bancorp, Inc.
     NJ      $ 32.45      $ 1,628.10      $ 2.41      $ 29.44        18.76x        110.21     11.57     135.61     13.49x      $ 0.78        2.42     42.49   $ 14,210        11.20     9.43     0.29     0.74     6.52      0.96      8.45      

DCOM

   Dime
Commercial
Bancshares,
Inc.
     NY      $ 39.00      $ 1,720.43      $ 2.68      $ 31.33        14.66x        124.47     11.54     140.62     14.55x      $ 1.00        2.58     37.59   $ 15,000        9.98     9.02     0.64     0.85     8.43      0.85      8.50      

FCF

   First
Commonwealth
Financial
Corporation
     PA      $ 19.53      $ 1,978.24      $ 1.58      $ 15.27        12.93x        127.89     16.19     172.06     12.38x      $ 0.56        2.89     36.09   $ 12,263        12.66     9.73     0.54     1.29     10.25      1.35      10.70      

KRNY

   Kearny
Financial Corp.
     NJ      $ 8.47      $ 533.04      $ 0.56      $ 11.79        14.86x        71.86     7.21     84.57     15.18x      $ 0.44        5.24     77.19   $ 7,608        10.03     8.65     0.69     0.47     4.78      0.46      4.67      

NBTB

   NBT Bancorp
Inc.
     NY      $ 46.68      $ 2,427.84      $ 3.98      $ 36.81        13.30x        126.82     14.98     172.58     11.73x      $ 1.48        3.19     42.17   $ 16,204        11.81     8.96     0.36     1.16     10.06      1.31      11.39      

PGC

   Peapack-
Gladstone
Financial
Corporation
     NJ      $ 44.75      $ 783.34      $ 2.47      $ 37.79        18.04x        118.42     10.33     126.92     18.11x      $ 0.20        0.45     8.06   $ 7,699        9.08     8.55     0.77     0.60     6.85      0.59      6.82      

PFS

   Provident
Financial
Services, Inc.
     NJ      $ 22.72      $ 2,960.73      $ 2.56      $ 21.97        9.67x        103.42     11.75     141.64     8.86x      $ 0.96        4.25     40.85   $ 25,202        11.36     8.56     0.58     1.24     11.04      1.36      12.04      

STBA

   S&T Bancorp,
Inc.
     PA      $ 46.84      $ 1,685.16      $ 3.58      $ 39.46        13.12x        118.71     17.08     160.96     13.08x      $ 1.48        3.16     40.06   $ 9,944        14.39     11.03     0.50     1.39     9.32      1.39      9.35      

TMP

   Tompkins
Financial
Corporation
     NY      $ 89.30      $ 1,284.40      $ 5.89      $ 65.78        7.65x        135.75     14.78     147.06     15.15x      $ 2.68        3.05     22.37   $ 8,696        10.89     10.14     0.59     2.00     20.00      1.01      10.09      

UVSP

   Univest
Financial
Corporation
     PA      $ 41.64      $ 1,159.50      $ 3.31      $ 34.06        12.50x        122.25     14.29     150.27     12.56x      $ 0.92        2.21     26.73   $ 8,142        11.69     9.72     0.46     1.16     10.27      1.15      10.22      

WSFS

   WSFS
Financial
Corporation
     DE      $ 74.14      $ 3,858.55      $ 5.95      $ 52.24        13.19x        141.91     17.48     219.34     12.46x      $ 0.80        1.08     12.63   $ 22,107        12.28     8.29     0.40     1.44     11.40      1.53      12.02      

 

(1)

Core income, on a diluted per-share basis. Core income is net income after taxes and before extraordinary items, less net income attributable to noncontrolling interest, gain on the sale of securities, amortization of intangibles, goodwill and nonrecurring items. Assumed tax rate is 35%.

(2)

P/E = Price to earnings; P/B = Price to book; P/A = Price to assets; P/TB = Price to tangible book value; and P/Core = Price to core earnings. P/E and P/Core =NM if the ratio is negative or above 35x.

(3)

Indicated 12 month dividend, based on last quarterly dividend declared

(4)

Indicated 12 month dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month earnings.

(5)

Equity and tangible equity equal common equity and tangible common equity, respectively. ROAA (return on average assets) and ROAE (return on average equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month earnings and average equity and assets balances.

(6)

Excludes from averages and medians those companies the subject of actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics.

Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence and RP Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this report has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.

Copyright (c) 2026 by RP® Financial, LC.

 


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 23

 

P/TB ratios as indicated in the Original Appraisal). In comparison to the median P/B and P/TB ratios indicated for the Peer Group of 120.48% and 144.35%, respectively, Columbia Financial’s updated ratios at the $2.709 billion midpoint value reflected discounts of 28.07% and 36.03% (versus discounts of 19.06% and 29.82% from the Peer Group’s median P/B and P/TB ratios as indicated in the Original Appraisal). At the maximum of the range, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios equaled 91.32% and 96.99%, respectively. In comparison to the Peer Group’s average P/B and P/TB ratios, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios at the maximum of the range reflected discounts of 22.63% and 34.83%, respectively. In comparison to the Peer Group’s median P/B and P/TB ratios, the Company’s P/B and P/TB ratios at the maximum of the range reflected discounts of 24.20% and 32.81%, respectively.

3. P/A Approach. P/A ratios are generally not as a reliable indicator of market value, as investors do not place significant weight on total assets as a determinant of market value. Investors place significantly greater weight on book value and earnings – and which have received greater weight in our valuation analysis. At the $2.709 billion midpoint value Columbia Financial’s pro forma P/A ratio equaled 15.05%. In comparison to the Peer Group’s average P/A ratio of 13.21%, Columbia Financial’s P/A ratio indicated a premium of 13.93% (versus a premium of 24.75% at the midpoint valuation in the Original Appraisal). In comparison to the Peer Group’s median P/A ratio of 13.02%, Columbia Financial’s P/A ratio at the $2.709 billion updated midpoint value indicated a premium of 15.59% (versus a premium of 28.71% at the midpoint valuation in the Original Appraisal).

Comparison to Recent Offerings

As discussed previously, the average closing pro forma P/TB ratio of the two second-step offerings completed during the past twelve months equaled 58.90%. In comparison, the Company’s pro forma price/tangible book ratio of 92.34% at the midpoint value reflects an implied premium of 56.77% and at the maximum P/TB ratio of 96.99% reflects an implied premium of 64.67%.

Valuation Conclusion

Our analysis indicates that the Company’s estimated pro forma market value did not change from the midpoint value as set forth in the Original Appraisal. Accordingly, based on the foregoing, it is our opinion that, as of June 18, 2026, the estimated aggregate pro forma value of the shares of common stock of the Company to be issued and outstanding upon completing the conversion offering – including (1) newly-issued shares representing the MHC’s current ownership interest in the Company and (2) exchange shares issued to existing public shareholders of Columbia Financial – was $2,291,268,770 at the midpoint, equal to 229,126,877 shares at $10.00 per share. The resulting range of value and pro forma shares, all based on $10.00 per share, are as follows: $1,947,578,450 or 194,757,845 shares at the minimum/adjusted minimum and $2,634,959,080 or 263,495,908 shares at the maximum.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 24

 

Based on this valuation and taking into account the MHC’s ownership interest, the midpoint of the offering range is $1,675,000,000 equal to 167,500,000 shares at $10.00 per share. The resulting offering range and offering shares, all based on $10.00 per share, are as follows: $1,423,750,000 or 142,375,000 shares at the minimum and $1,926,250,000 or 192,625,000 shares at the maximum. At the adjusted minimum of the offering range, the public offering is $1,005,748,600 equal to 100,574,860 shares at $10.00 per share and the merger shares applied to the offering range is $418,001,400 equal to 41,800,140 shares at $10.00 per share.

Taking into account the Company’s use of proceeds, as of June 18, 2026, the estimated aggregate pro forma market value of the shares to be issued immediately following the conversion, including the 41,800,140 merger shares issued to Northfield Bancorp’s shareholders as part of the $597.1 million cash and stock merger with Northfield Bancorp was $2,709,270,170 at the midpoint, equal to 270,927,017 shares at a per share value of $10.00. Based on the foregoing valuation, the corresponding range of shares and market values based on a $10.00 per share price are as follows:

Shares

 

Conclusion

   2nd Step
Offering
Shares
     2nd Step
Exchange
Shares
     Full
Conversion
Shares
     Merger
Shares
Issued To
Target
     Merger
Shares
Applied to
Offering
     Total Market
Capitalization
Shares
     Exchange
Ratio
     Merger Shares
Pct. Of Total
 

Maximum

     192,625,000        70,870,908        263,495,908        42,973,477        0        306,469,385        2.5340        14.02

Midpoint

     167,500,000        61,626,877        229,126,877        41,800,140        0        270,927,017        2.2035        15.43

Minimum

     142,375,000        52,382,845        194,757,845        41,800,140        0        236,557,985        1.8729        17.67

Adusted Minimum(4)

     100,574,860        52,382,845        194,757,845        0        41,800,140        194,757,845        1.8729        21.46
Market Value

 

                    

Conclusion

   2nd Step
Offering Value
     2nd Step
Exchange
Shares Value
     Full
Conversion
Value
     Merger
Shares Value
     Merger
Shares
Applied to
Offering
     Total Market
Capitalization
Value
               

Maximum

   $ 1,926,250,000      $ 708,709,080      $ 2,634,959,080      $ 429,734,770        0      $ 3,064,693,850        

Midpoint

   $ 1,675,000,000      $ 616,268,770      $ 2,291,268,770      $ 418,001,400        0      $ 2,709,270,170        

Minimum

   $ 1,423,750,000      $ 523,828,450      $ 1,947,578,450      $ 418,001,400        0      $ 2,365,579,850        

Adjusted Minimum(4)

   $ 1,005,748,600      $ 523,828,450      $ 1,947,578,450      $ 0        418,001,400      $ 1,947,578,450        

The pro forma valuation calculations relative to the Peer Group are shown in Table 7 and are detailed in Exhibit 2 and Exhibit 3.

Establishment of the Exchange Ratio

Conversion regulations provide that in a conversion of a mutual holding company, the minority shareholders are entitled to exchange the public shares for newly issued shares in the fully converted company. The Boards of Directors of the MHC and CLBK have independently determined the exchange ratio, which has been designed to preserve the current aggregate minority shareholder ownership percentage in the Company. The exchange ratio to be received by the existing minority shareholders of the Company will be determined at the end of the offering, based on the total number of shares sold in the second-step conversion offering and the final appraisal. Based on the valuation conclusion herein, the resulting offering value and the $10.00 per share offering price, the indicated exchange ratio at the midpoint is 2.2035 shares of the Company’s stock for every one public share held by public shareholders. Furthermore, based on the offering range of value, the indicated exchange ratio is 1.8729 at the minimum/adjusted minimum and 2.5340 at the maximum. RP Financial expresses no opinion on the proposed exchange of newly issued Company shares for the shares held by the public shareholders or on the proposed exchange ratio.


Boards of Directors

June 18, 2026

Page 25

 

Resolicitation of Maximum Purchasers

Following the close of the subscription offering, the Company announced an increase in the maximum purchase limitation from $3.0 million to $8.0 million for individual purchasers and from $10.0 million to $50.0 million for group purchasers. Only those persons who subscribed for the maximum number of shares in the subscription offering will be resolicited and given the opportunity to purchase additional shares up to the new purchase limits.

 

Respectfully submitted,
RP® FINANCIAL, LC.
LOGO
Ronald S. Riggins
Managing Director
LOGO
Gregory E. Dunn
Director


 

 

EXHIBITS


LIST OF EXHIBITS

 

Exhibit

Number

  

Description

1    Stock Prices: As of June 18, 2026
2    Pro Forma Analysis Sheet
3    Pro Forma Effect of Conversion Proceeds
4    Firm Qualifications Statement


 

 

EXHIBIT 1

Stock Prices

As of June 18, 2026


Exhibit 1A

Weekly Bank and Thrift Market Line - Part One

Prices As of June 18, 2026

 

            Market Capitalization     Price Change Data     Current Per Share Financials        
            Price/
Share(1)
    Shares
Outstanding
    Market
Capitalization
    52 Week (1)     Last Wk     % Change From     LTM
EPS (3)
    LTM Core
EPS (3)
    BV/
Share
    TBV/
Share (4)
    Assets/
Share
    Assets  
        High     Low     Last Wk     52 Wks (2)     MRY (2)        
            ($)     (000)     ($Mil)     ($)     ($)     ($)     (%)     (%)     (%)     ($)     ($)     ($)     ($)     ($)        

Companies

                                                                                             

SRCE

  1st Source Corporation   MW     76.91       24,069       1,851.1       86.64       56.89       77.83       -1.18       30.09       23.08       6.52       6.81       53.10       49.61       378.64       9,113,429  

ACNB

  ACNB Corporation   MA     57.22       10,212       584.3       58.54       40.50       57.01       0.37       39.19       18.35       4.89       5.67       41.16       32.85       320.20       3,269,864  

ALRS

  Alerus Financial Corporation   MW     29.68       25,129       745.8       30.49       20.26       29.87       -0.64       40.93       31.79       1.05       3.47       22.79       18.15       210.44       5,287,971  

AMAL

  Amalgamated Financial Corp.   MA     43.96       29,867       1,312.8       45.23       25.13       44.10       -0.33       47.11       37.23       3.44       3.52       27.05       26.59       307.05       9,170,892  

AMTB

  Amerant Bancorp Inc.   SE     23.60       39,802       939.3       24.38       15.62       23.79       -0.80       42.34       20.96       1.41       1.87       22.96       22.42       248.82       9,903,514  

ABCB

  Ameris Bancorp   SE     87.59       67,066       5,874.3       90.00       59.54       86.95       0.74       44.39       17.93       6.36       6.49       60.64       44.76       419.14       28,109,935  

ASRV

  AmeriServ Financial, Inc.   MA     3.89       16,964       66.0       4.04       2.64       3.81       2.10       33.22       21.94       0.33       0.33       7.12       6.31       86.81       1,472,654  

ATLO

  Ames National Corporation   MW     29.46       8,857       260.9       32.16       16.94       30.11       -2.16       70.58       28.31       2.42       2.45       23.44       21.95       241.90       2,142,539  

AROW

  Arrow Financial Corporation   MA     38.80       16,529       641.3       40.29       24.81       38.11       1.81       55.64       23.57       3.09       3.20       26.63       25.12       273.58       4,522,019  

ASB

  Associated Banc-Corp   MW     29.20       163,363       4,770.2       29.96       22.48       28.96       0.83       27.68       13.35       2.88       2.93       29.04       22.23       279.10       45,593,740  

AUB

  Atlantic Union Bankshares Corporation   SE     39.16       143,116       5,604.4       42.18       29.64       39.50       -0.86       30.40       10.93       2.36       3.50       34.39       19.93       260.73       37,315,011  

AUBN

  Auburn National Bancorporation, Inc.   SE     25.40       3,496       88.7       29.00       21.01       24.38       4.21       16.95       -5.75       2.27       2.27       26.62       26.62       293.76       1,026,946  

AVBH

  Avidbank Holdings, Inc.   WE     31.96       10,955       350.1       32.98       19.92       31.94       0.06       59.88       20.33       -1.88       3.50       26.33       26.33       235.46       2,579,554  

AVBC

  Avidia Bancorp, Inc.   NE     20.14       18,571       374.0       21.43       14.00       20.34       -0.98       37.57       19.81       NA       NA       19.10       18.51       151.18       2,807,417  

AX

  Axos Financial, Inc.   WE     88.07       56,885       5,009.8       101.92       69.25       89.28       -1.36       23.87       2.22       8.23       8.18       53.89       50.18       514.18       29,248,986  

BANC

  Banc of California, Inc.   WE     20.09       154,202       3,097.9       21.61       13.24       19.87       1.11       47.18       4.15       1.31       1.45       19.80       17.77       225.19       34,724,241  

BANF

  BancFirst Corporation   SW     111.31       33,586       3,738.5       138.77       101.48       114.15       -2.49       -6.10       4.99       7.30       7.24       56.65       50.58       450.08       15,116,541  

BFC

  Bank First Corporation   MW     142.68       11,163       1,592.8       153.00       109.11       143.99       -0.91       27.86       17.12       7.19       8.39       73.05       47.04       543.66       6,069,013  

BAC

  Bank of America Corporation   SE     56.20       7,096,591       398,828.4       57.98       44.21       55.16       1.89       24.72       2.18       4.03       4.04       38.66       28.73       492.66       3,496,186,000  

BOH

  Bank of Hawaii Corporation   WE     77.85       39,621       3,084.5       82.74       59.36       78.83       -1.24       19.37       13.87       4.95       5.07       38.33       37.53       603.47       23,909,933  

BMRC

  Bank of Marin Bancorp   WE     25.81       15,989       412.7       28.48       21.26       26.12       -1.19       20.05       -0.77       -2.02       2.40       24.37       19.77       244.80       3,914,117  

BOTJ

  Bank of the James Financial Group, Inc.   SE     24.55       4,543       111.5       29.79       13.00       24.79       -0.95       76.82       32.13       2.42       2.51       17.89       16.11       233.57       1,061,189  

OZK

  Bank OZK   SE     49.26       109,166       5,377.5       53.66       42.37       51.63       -4.59       9.69       7.04       6.14       6.14       53.19       47.15       381.66       41,663,976  

BSVN

  Bank7 Corp.   SW     45.65       9,519       434.6       50.10       37.56       45.64       0.02       19.69       11.40       4.66       4.67       27.29       26.04       204.33       1,945,080  

BKU

  BankUnited, Inc.   SE     47.54       72,682       3,455.3       52.11       33.33       48.64       -2.26       40.82       6.66       3.59       3.56       41.11       40.05       486.49       35,358,613  

BWFG

  Bankwell Financial Group, Inc.   NE     56.18       7,771       436.6       56.98       34.53       55.15       1.87       61.58       22.61       4.98       4.98       39.11       38.63       434.17       3,373,859  

BANR

  Banner Corporation   WE     64.83       33,968       2,202.1       69.83       57.05       66.85       -3.02       4.23       3.46       5.94       6.04       58.06       46.97       481.17       16,344,272  

BHB

  Bar Harbor Bankshares   NE     36.39       16,742       609.2       37.20       28.06       36.61       -0.60       26.88       17.20       2.45       3.37       32.13       22.71       279.31       4,676,228  

BCML

  BayCom Corp   WE     31.55       10,836       341.9       33.15       25.84       31.92       -1.16       18.52       7.31       2.42       2.47       31.53       27.82       244.43       2,648,536  

BAFN

  BayFirst Financial Corp.   SE     4.96       4,108       20.4       15.45       4.80       5.28       -6.06       -65.07       -36.82       -7.22       -5.83       16.10       NA       291.11       1,195,910  

BCBP

  BCB Bancorp, Inc.   MA     11.06       17,363       192.0       11.71       7.31       10.95       1.00       41.79       37.05       -0.07       -0.06       16.25       15.95       188.28       3,269,097  

BBT

  Beacon Financial Corporation   NE     29.60       84,028       2,487.2       32.83       22.81       30.10       -1.66       23.90       12.25       1.74       2.66       29.81       23.42       264.53       22,227,616  

BRBS

  Blue Ridge Bankshares, Inc.   SE     3.35       88,500       296.5       4.79       3.23       3.32       0.90       0.90       -21.55       0.12       NA       3.08       3.06       27.28       2,414,046  

BOKF

  BOK Financial Corporation   SW     130.33       60,760       7,918.8       139.73       91.35       132.20       -1.41       40.84       10.02       9.88       9.56       98.31       80.58       884.80       53,760,405  

BWB

  Bridgewater Bancshares, Inc.   MW     19.74       27,883       550.4       20.30       14.80       19.72       0.10       31.95       12.61       1.77       1.64       16.60       15.92       191.35       5,335,396  

BYFC

  Broadway Financial Corporation   WE     9.90       8,872       87.8       10.46       5.51       10.05       -1.49       65.00       33.78       -2.77       -0.55       12.10       11.95       160.73       1,426,065  

BHRB

  Burke & Herbert Financial Services Corp.   SE     65.51       20,150       1,320.0       70.90       55.40       66.34       -1.25       16.44       5.14       7.71       8.28       56.77       51.83       393.44       7,927,711  

BFST

  Business First Bancshares, Inc.   SW     28.77       32,678       940.1       30.32       22.52       29.08       -1.07       24.49       10.06       2.82       2.95       28.18       23.18       272.56       8,906,808  

BVFL

  BV Financial, Inc.   MA     20.34       8,084       164.4       20.75       14.05       19.71       3.20       42.24       12.13       1.39       1.62       20.99       19.27       112.67       910,857  

BY

  Byline Bancorp, Inc.   MW     35.15       45,409       1,596.1       35.84       24.75       35.08       0.20       40.66       20.58       3.07       3.28       28.17       23.57       218.23       9,909,680  

CFFI

  C&F Financial Corporation   SE     78.36       3,254       255.0       80.99       57.09       77.08       1.66       30.67       7.95       8.70       8.47       81.73       73.70       864.61       2,813,748  

BCAL

  California BanCorp   WE     19.74       32,165       634.9       20.47       14.07       19.82       -0.40       37.47       5.73       1.83       1.96       17.97       13.97       125.87       4,048,734  

CAC

  Camden National Corporation   NE     51.49       16,915       870.9       53.71       35.00       51.74       -0.48       34.02       18.70       4.70       5.01       41.98       30.58       411.57       6,961,581  

CBNK

  Capital Bancorp, Inc.   MA     33.27       16,288       541.9       36.40       26.40       33.67       -1.19       6.50       18.10       3.31       3.46       25.10       22.53       233.82       3,808,467  

CCBG

  Capital City Bank Group, Inc.   SE     47.48       17,101       812.0       48.78       36.43       46.36       2.42       29.51       11.53       3.53       3.43       32.75       27.54       260.43       4,453,734  

COF

  Capital One Financial Corporation   SE     201.53       616,019       124,146.4       259.64       174.24       182.04       10.71       2.21       -16.85       2.29       6.06       173.50       101.10       1108.58       682,905,000  

CFFN

  Capitol Federal Financial, Inc.   MW     8.08       124,060       1,002.4       8.32       5.71       8.15       -0.86       38.83       18.65       0.60       0.60       8.03       7.96       79.23       9,829,080  

CARE

  Carter Bankshares, Inc.   SE     30.96       22,222       688.0       31.40       16.27       29.56       4.74       86.17       57.48       4.87       2.55       22.78       22.69       215.97       4,799,270  

CLST

  Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.   SW     16.43       4,052       66.6       18.16       12.02       16.01       2.62       30.81       4.32       0.55       0.57       20.26       20.26       71.20       288,508  

CATY

  Cathay General Bancorp   WE     59.09       67,035       3,961.1       61.55       42.01       59.91       -1.37       37.55       22.11       4.85       4.68       44.60       38.95       358.74       24,048,630  

CBFV

  CB Financial Services, Inc.   MA     37.00       5,073       187.7       37.95       27.11       37.40       -1.07       34.40       6.14       1.29       2.93       31.30       29.38       312.13       1,583,292  

CBC

  Central Bancompany, Inc.   MW     28.23       239,768       6,768.7       29.26       9.80       28.71       -1.67       48.58       17.04       1.79       1.87       15.84       14.38       85.32       20,456,371  

CPF

  Central Pacific Financial Corp.   WE     35.85       26,101       935.7       37.01       25.62       36.26       -1.13       37.78       15.05       2.99       2.99       22.74       22.74       287.17       7,495,363  

CPBI

  Central Plains Bancshares, Inc.   MW     18.64       3,914       73.0       18.75       14.85       18.51       0.70       23.85       10.17       1.03       1.03       20.87       NA       136.86       535,738  

CFBK

  CF Bankshares Inc.   MW     30.00       6,498       194.9       34.34       22.10       30.25       -0.83       27.77       20.24       2.78       2.78       28.67       28.67       330.22       2,145,776  

CBNA

  Chain Bridge Bancorp, Inc.   SE     40.47       6,562       265.6       40.47       23.76       38.36       5.50       65.79       16.83       3.31       3.31       26.65       26.65       292.40       1,918,674  

CHMG

  Chemung Financial Corporation   MA     70.97       4,820       342.1       73.84       43.20       72.41       -1.99       51.03       27.19       3.79       6.59       54.56       50.03       570.30       2,748,722  

COFS

  ChoiceOne Financial Services, Inc.   MW     31.87       14,975       477.3       35.40       26.10       32.42       -1.70       14.60       7.96       3.70       4.03       31.42       20.77       293.46       4,394,565  

C

  Citigroup Inc.   MA     143.06       1,705,577       243,999.8       147.96       77.26       138.07       3.61       82.59       22.60       8.07       8.74       112.23       99.01       1628.59       2,777,687,000  

CZNC

  Citizens & Northern Corporation   MA     21.73       17,917       389.3       24.12       18.16       21.88       -0.69       17.08       7.73       1.09       1.57       18.74       14.60       176.62       3,164,340  

CZWI

  Citizens Community Bancorp, Inc.   MW     21.34       9,644       205.8       22.62       12.83       20.66       3.29       61.12       19.75       1.53       1.56       19.82       16.52       189.02       1,822,974  

CFG

  Citizens Financial Group, Inc.   NE     67.08       422,882       28,366.9       68.79       40.41       66.51       0.86       62.34       14.84       4.23       4.14       56.48       36.92       538.96       227,918,000  

CZFS

  Citizens Financial Services, Inc.   MA     67.96       4,805       326.5       71.85       49.99       67.72       0.35       18.85       19.19       8.19       8.25       71.51       53.34       629.87       3,026,478  

CHCO

  City Holding Company   SE     127.12       14,111       1,793.8       133.59       113.21       128.54       -1.10       9.50       6.64       9.08       9.22       56.29       45.14       479.07       6,760,269  

CIVB

  Civista Bancshares, Inc.   MW     26.85       20,783       558.0       28.31       18.95       26.75       0.37       22.27       20.84       2.72       2.99       26.57       19.83       206.82       4,298,322  

CCNE

  CNB Financial Corporation   MA     32.16       29,319       942.9       33.22       21.49       32.58       -1.29       47.73       22.89       2.81       3.08       28.06       23.97       290.43       8,514,896  

CCB

  Coastal Financial Corporation   WE     71.65       15,249       1,092.6       120.05       66.50       71.99       -0.47       -13.79       -37.47       3.19       3.37       33.05       32.76       371.43       5,663,829  

COSO

  CoastalSouth Bancshares, Inc.   SE     26.48       12,036       318.7       27.52       19.24       26.75       -1.01       31.06       13.89       2.20       2.21       21.94       21.52       195.13       2,348,547  

CBAN

  Colony Bankcorp, Inc.   SE     20.56       21,160       435.0       21.61       15.00       20.78       -1.06       34.55       15.38       1.60       1.91       17.98       14.46       175.84       3,720,613  

COLB

  Columbia Banking System, Inc.   WE     30.55       289,490       8,843.9       32.70       21.91       30.82       -0.88       37.06       9.30       2.51       3.39       26.47       19.03       228.08       66,027,000  

CBSH

  Commerce Bancshares, Inc.   MW     54.73       145,777       7,978.4       63.19       46.99       55.08       -0.64       -4.90       4.57       4.07       4.00       29.47       26.80       245.01       35,717,256  

CBK

  Commercial Bancgroup, Inc.   SE     31.36       13,701       429.7       31.67       23.24       30.77       1.92       30.67       27.69       2.93       3.13       21.43       20.52       169.97       2,328,789  

CMTV

  Community Bancorp   NE     41.25       5,591       230.6       42.92       19.35       40.56       1.70       113.18       65.73       3.17       2.92       20.88       18.81       220.93       1,235,285  

CBU

  Community Financial System, Inc.   MA     62.34       52,555       3,276.3       67.50       51.12       65.35       -4.61       14.91       8.53       4.12       4.43       38.52       20.57       337.64       17,744,859  

CTBI

  Community Trust Bancorp, Inc.   MW     68.35       18,164       1,241.5       71.28       49.64       70.10       -2.50       36.10       20.97       5.71       5.73       47.99       44.38       371.13       6,741,168  

CWBC

  Community West Bancshares   WE     25.19       27,134       683.5       25.99       17.99       25.45       -1.02       38.79       11.96       2.16       2.23       21.85       16.39       136.47       3,702,983  

CNOB

  ConnectOne Bancorp, Inc.   MA     32.45       50,173       1,628.1       33.12       21.79       32.27       0.56       48.17       23.76       1.73       2.41       29.44       23.93       283.21       14,209,561  

CFR

  Cullen/Frost Bankers, Inc.   SW     145.66       62,797       9,147.0       148.97       119.00       146.11       -0.31       17.89       15.03       10.27       10.32       69.83       58.80       839.60       52,724,557  

CUBI

  Customers Bancorp, Inc.   MA     75.79       33,825       2,563.6       82.56       50.69       77.22       -1.85       47.34       3.65       7.88       7.95       63.64       63.54       765.14       25,880,767  

CVBF

  CVB Financial Corp.   WE     20.81       176,455       3,672.0       21.63       17.95       20.92       -0.53       13.28       11.88       1.53       1.60       17.09       11.42       87.88       15,507,580  

DCOM

  Dime Commercial Bancshares, Inc.   MA     39.00       44,113       1,720.4       40.76       25.63       39.81       -2.03       49.37       29.61       2.66       NA       31.33       27.73       340.02       14,999,503  

EBMT

  Eagle Bancorp Montana, Inc.   WE     22.91       7,827       179.3       24.05       15.10       23.41       -2.14       47.62       15.13       1.98       2.03       24.22       19.48       267.24       2,091,851  

EGBN

  Eagle Bancorp, Inc.   MA     27.60       30,496       841.7       29.26       15.03       28.26       -2.34       62.93       28.85       -4.12       -3.38       37.56       37.56       326.42       9,954,281  

EFSI

  Eagle Financial Services, Inc.   SE     41.74       5,325       222.3       44.00       28.70       42.76       -2.39       43.44       4.89       3.52       3.45       35.16       35.16       345.25       1,838,360  
                                 

EWBC

  East West Bancorp, Inc.   WE     126.81       136,996       17,372.5       136.00       91.36       130.18       -2.59       35.47       12.83       10.01       9.94       65.70       62.30       605.02       82,886,152  

EBC

  Eastern Bankshares, Inc.   NE     20.60       219,796       4,511.6       22.58       14.10       20.73       -0.63       43.85       11.77       1.78       2.17       18.45       12.90       139.37       30,632,569  

ECBK

  ECB Bancorp, Inc.   NE     20.31       8,754       177.8       20.50       14.82       19.70       3.10       34.33       16.79       1.15       1.15       20.05       20.05       188.52       1,650,295  

EFSC

  Enterprise Financial Services Corp   MW     62.11       36,586       2,272.3       64.56       51.18       63.27       -1.83       17.74       15.02       5.30       4.77       53.31       41.38       470.89       17,227,828  

EQBK

  Equity Bancshares, Inc.   MW     46.60       20,641       961.9       50.07       36.04       47.94       -2.80       20.41       4.37       1.26       4.29       39.35       32.56       371.47       7,667,370  

ESQ

  Esquire Financial Holdings, Inc.   MA     113.53       8,192       930.1       134.82       88.47       113.25       0.25       26.89       11.23       5.95       6.08       34.88       34.88       295.54       2,421,155  

FNB

  F.N.B. Corporation   MA     18.23       355,964       6,489.2       19.14       13.56       18.29       -0.33       32.39       6.61       1.62       1.65       19.12       12.05       142.23       50,628,037  

FMAO

  Farmers & Merchants Bancorp, Inc.   MW     28.84       13,604       392.3       29.83       22.77       28.36       1.69       20.02       16.67       2.61       2.73       27.30       20.76       256.23       3,485,569  

FMNB

  Farmers National Banc Corp.   MW     14.14       59,215       837.3       15.50       12.12       14.56       -2.88       10.21       6.16       1.45       1.68       12.96       7.74       121.18       7,175,476  

FBLA

  FB Bancorp, Inc.   SW     14.49       14,717       213.3       14.68       10.73       14.35       0.98       33.92       12.76       0.15       0.17       17.50       17.50       85.95       1,265,008  

FBK

  FB Financial Corporation   SE     53.75       51,523       2,769.4       62.37       42.44       54.12       -0.68       25.50       -3.67       2.66       4.12       38.39       31.00       319.63       16,468,439  

FDBC

  Fidelity D & D Bancorp, Inc.   MA     49.67       5,805       288.3       51.26       39.00       50.21       -1.07       19.51       14.11       5.12       5.26       42.14       38.67       492.54       2,859,265  

FDSB

  Fifth District Bancorp, Inc.   SW     15.99       5,265       84.2       16.13       11.94       15.52       3.03       32.26       6.60       0.87       0.34       24.45       24.45       101.75       535,692  

FITB

  Fifth Third Bancorp   MW     52.74       906,312       47,798.9       55.44       38.10       53.42       -1.27       36.00       12.67       2.98       3.62       35.24       22.88       327.74       297,039,000  

FISI

  Financial Institutions, Inc.   MA     37.36       19,686       735.5       38.47       24.41       37.98       -1.63       52.18       19.86       3.84       3.78       31.21       28.15       319.75       6,294,783  

FNWD

  Finward Bancorp   MW     34.19       4,330       148.0       39.99       26.46       34.00       0.56       19.25       -2.84       2.29       2.58       39.81       34.39       465.40       2,015,156  

FINW

  FinWise Bancorp   SW     14.18       13,706       194.4       22.49       12.82       14.71       -3.60       0.50       -20.96       1.10       1.16       14.34       14.07       65.62       899,440  

FBNC

  First Bancorp   SE     60.76       41,375       2,514.0       62.64       40.09       61.30       -0.88       49.58       19.63       2.93       4.31       40.68       28.72       312.93       12,947,734  

FBP

  First BanCorp.   MA     25.20       153,619       3,871.2       25.86       19.16       25.00       0.80       29.10       21.56       2.25       2.24       12.72       12.45       124.24       19,086,105  

FRBA

  First Bank   MA     16.67       25,062       417.8       18.11       14.34       16.35       1.96       13.94       1.28       1.67       1.75       17.93       15.90       158.44       3,970,761  

BUSE

  First Busey Corporation   MW     28.23       84,577       2,387.6       29.10       21.63       28.47       -0.84       25.58       18.66       2.25       2.77       25.70       20.12       213.26       18,036,622  

FCAP

  First Capital, Inc.   MW     63.00       3,346       210.8       71.00       33.73       64.01       -1.58       45.03       6.42       5.23       5.17       41.26       39.33       383.84       1,284,151  

FCBM

  First Carolina Financial Services, Inc.   SE     12.60       30,246       381.1       13.25       12.60       12.50       0.80       0.80       0.80       1.09       1.29       28.71       23.05       113.02       3,418,377  

FCNC.A

  First Citizens BancShares, Inc.   SE     2071.62       11,587       23,836.3       2232.21       1623.76       2117.01       -2.14       12.26       -3.47       173.88       182.21       1735.17       1690.01       20364.16       235,959,000  


Exhibit 1A

Weekly Bank and Thrift Market Line - Part One

Prices As of June 18, 2026

 

            Market Capitalization     Price Change Data     Current Per Share Financials        
            Price/
Share(1)
    Shares
Outstanding
    Market
Capitalization
    52 Week (1)     Last Wk     % Change From     LTM
EPS (3)
    LTM Core
EPS (3)
    BV/
Share
    TBV/
Share (4)
    Assets/
Share
    Assets  
        High     Low     Last Wk     52 Wks (2)     MRY (2)        
            ($)     (000)     ($Mil)     ($)     ($)     ($)     (%)     (%)     (%)     ($)     ($)     ($)     ($)     ($)        

Companies

                                                                                             

FCF

  First Commonwealth Financial Corporation   MA     19.53       101,292       1,978.2       20.05       15.00       19.60       -0.36       27.07       15.84       1.51       1.58       15.27       11.35       121.06       12,262,572  

FCBC

  First Community Bankshares, Inc.   SE     43.42       18,867       819.2       45.10       31.21       43.89       -1.06       16.35       28.73       2.65       2.97       27.64       18.92       193.19       3,644,947  

FCCO

  First Community Corporation   SE     31.56       9,398       296.6       33.03       22.20       31.91       -1.10       41.59       6.44       2.55       2.81       23.50       20.07       254.47       2,391,531  

FFBC

  First Financial Bancorp.   MW     31.61       104,929       3,316.8       32.66       22.93       31.78       -0.53       36.19       26.34       2.83       3.17       28.02       16.37       217.10       22,779,815  

FFIN

  First Financial Bankshares, Inc.   SW     32.78       142,342       4,666.0       38.74       28.12       33.30       -1.56       -6.61       9.74       1.84       1.84       13.57       11.38       108.10       15,387,645  

THFF

  First Financial Corporation   MW     73.07       11,892       868.9       75.61       49.72       74.01       -1.27       43.81       20.94       6.80       7.49       55.10       45.13       515.36       6,128,589  

FGBI

  First Guaranty Bancshares, Inc.   SW     10.60       16,028       169.9       11.02       4.31       10.60       0.00       30.86       97.39       -3.36       -2.65       11.91       11.78       246.98       3,958,542  

FHB

  First Hawaiian, Inc.   WE     27.93       121,649       3,397.7       29.03       22.65       28.15       -0.78       20.60       10.40       2.28       2.26       22.75       14.57       199.46       24,264,548  

FHN

  First Horizon Corporation   SE     24.81       474,618       11,775.3       26.56       19.18       24.99       -0.72       27.17       3.81       2.00       2.00       17.72       14.34       177.26       84,132,000  

INBK

  First Internet Bancorp   MW     25.78       8,717       224.7       28.51       17.05       25.57       0.82       10.83       23.53       -3.85       -0.39       41.41       39.08       655.26       5,711,688  

FIBK

  First Interstate BancSystem, Inc.   WE     36.43       97,143       3,538.9       39.26       25.81       36.56       -0.36       38.99       5.29       3.07       2.76       34.47       22.37       272.04       26,426,800  

FRME

  First Merchants Corporation   MW     40.72       63,023       2,566.3       43.22       34.66       41.21       -1.19       14.00       8.64       3.40       4.10       42.35       29.16       334.36       21,072,521  

FMBH

  First Mid Bancshares, Inc.   MW     45.86       26,616       1,220.6       49.03       33.92       46.20       -0.74       29.95       17.59       3.97       4.51       40.46       30.20       348.99       9,288,617  

FXNC

  First National Corporation   SE     29.36       9,041       265.4       30.86       18.31       29.56       -0.68       57.51       16.32       2.33       2.40       20.86       19.11       229.60       2,075,823  

FNRN

  First Northern Community Bancorp   WE     18.40       16,407       301.9       18.62       9.24       17.87       2.97       97.14       44.61       1.42       1.46       13.03       12.78       117.30       1,924,548  

FNWB

  First Northwest Bancorp   WE     10.03       8,868       88.9       10.98       6.05       10.56       -5.02       29.92       6.93       0.55       0.92       16.52       16.41       240.57       2,133,443  

FUNC

  First United Corporation   MA     42.58       6,447       274.5       42.83       28.00       41.65       2.23       48.57       13.73       3.91       3.94       31.84       30.08       316.29       2,039,010  

FUSB

  First US Bancshares, Inc.   SE     16.50       5,567       91.9       16.50       10.30       16.30       1.23       24.62       18.11       1.04       NA       18.67       17.34       209.30       1,165,236  

MYFW

  First Western Financial, Inc.   SW     30.55       9,729       297.2       31.24       20.40       29.85       2.35       44.99       13.95       1.55       1.57       28.10       24.87       333.10       3,240,717  

FSBC

  Five Star Bancorp   WE     44.87       21,376       959.1       45.48       26.20       44.52       0.79       69.26       25.41       3.15       3.19       21.45       21.45       235.39       5,031,751  

FLG

  Flagstar Bank, National Association   MA     14.65       416,815       6,106.3       15.37       10.38       14.54       0.76       28.06       16.36       -0.22       0.17       18.28       17.42       209.04       87,129,000  

FRBT

  Forbright, Inc.   MA     18.00       49,688       894.4       18.57       17.48       18.10       -0.55       -0.55       -0.55       NA       NA       20.35       19.58       165.70       8,233,060  

FRAF

  Franklin Financial Services Corporation   MA     61.45       4,493       276.1       62.84       33.44       59.98       2.45       79.94       22.41       5.34       5.27       39.78       37.78       511.35       2,297,518  

FSBW

  FS Bancorp, Inc.   WE     41.69       5,312       221.4       44.22       36.66       42.40       -1.67       10.00       1.26       4.29       4.52       41.84       40.06       603.12       3,203,515  

FULT

  Fulton Financial Corporation   MA     22.90       191,134       4,377.0       23.66       16.60       23.00       -0.43       33.92       18.47       2.10       2.22       18.52       15.11       168.66       32,237,438  

FVCB

  FVCBankcorp, Inc.   SE     16.63       17,997       299.3       18.41       11.16       16.69       -0.36       43.98       19.55       1.28       1.28       14.47       14.06       129.77       2,335,434  

GBFH

  GBank Financial Holdings Inc.   WE     29.57       14,470       427.9       44.00       23.87       32.27       -8.37       -17.03       -12.75       1.23       1.29       11.58       11.58       96.32       1,393,812  

GABC

  German American Bancorp, Inc.   MW     44.99       37,564       1,690.0       46.39       36.55       45.29       -0.66       22.26       14.83       3.61       3.84       31.27       20.44       223.15       8,382,458  

GBCI

  Glacier Bancorp, Inc.   WE     48.43       130,143       6,302.8       53.99       39.90       48.81       -0.78       19.67       9.94       2.14       2.42       32.65       21.29       243.84       31,734,082  

GSBC

  Great Southern Bancorp, Inc.   MW     74.23       10,893       808.6       76.92       53.76       75.27       -1.38       32.72       20.58       6.31       6.27       58.27       57.39       522.10       5,687,322  

HWC

  Hancock Whitney Corporation   SE     70.24       81,158       5,700.5       75.43       52.93       71.53       -1.80       31.02       10.30       4.87       5.96       54.46       42.26       437.94       35,542,126  

HAFC

  Hanmi Financial Corporation   WE     31.21       29,537       921.8       31.99       22.00       31.27       -0.19       37.37       15.46       2.68       2.64       26.93       26.50       265.40       7,839,227  

HNVR

  Hanover Bancorp, Inc.   MA     23.28       7,157       166.6       24.55       19.91       23.94       -2.76       11.60       0.74       1.05       1.30       27.44       24.74       331.29       2,370,949  

HWBK

  Hawthorn Bancshares, Inc.   MW     39.14       6,897       269.9       39.37       27.07       36.86       6.19       37.04       12.21       3.49       3.48       25.46       25.46       269.10       1,855,860  

HBT

  HBT Financial, Inc.   MW     30.30       36,381       1,102.3       30.85       22.36       30.03       0.90       28.34       17.21       2.18       2.68       20.54       17.01       186.19       6,773,724  

HFWA

  Heritage Financial Corporation   WE     27.92       41,219       1,150.8       29.29       21.32       28.82       -3.12       23.81       18.05       2.04       2.38       27.05       19.07       206.18       8,498,404  

HTH

  Hilltop Holdings Inc.   SW     37.86       58,530       2,216.0       40.41       28.92       37.88       -0.05       28.78       11.55       2.64       NA       36.63       31.97       268.27       15,701,856  

HIFS

  Hingham Institution for Savings   NE     284.65       2,197       625.4       338.00       220.76       291.07       -2.21       26.26       0.24       22.81       16.50       220.06       220.06       2069.77       4,547,809  

HBCP

  Home Bancorp, Inc.   SW     66.28       7,843       519.8       68.65       48.36       67.28       -1.49       34.39       14.67       5.95       6.14       56.73       46.04       453.25       3,554,643  

HOMB

  Home BancShares, Inc.   SE     27.65       201,413       5,569.1       30.83       25.50       27.85       -0.72       0.29       -0.47       2.43       2.42       22.15       14.87       115.19       23,201,679  

HFBL

  Home Federal Bancorp, Inc. of Louisiana   SW     20.30       2,964       59.6       20.30       12.32       20.00       1.50       55.56       12.78       1.92       1.99       18.96       17.74       216.46       641,649  

HTB

  HomeTrust Bancshares, Inc.   SE     48.45       16,589       803.7       48.63       34.66       47.50       2.00       37.80       12.83       3.87       3.87       35.26       32.96       264.42       4,386,341  

HOPE

  Hope Bancorp, Inc.   WE     12.84       127,839       1,641.5       13.29       9.44       13.01       -1.31       27.38       17.15       0.52       0.90       17.86       13.71       145.94       18,656,864  

HBNC

  Horizon Bancorp, Inc.   MW     19.34       51,330       992.7       19.93       14.34       19.52       -0.92       33.75       14.03       -3.18       2.19       13.69       10.52       127.88       6,564,216  

HYNE

  Hoyne Bancorp, Inc.   MW     16.59       8,097       134.3       16.65       13.35       16.26       2.03       18.50       14.49       NA       NA       19.89       19.88       58.94       477,222  

HBAN

  Huntington Bancshares Incorporated   MW     16.86       2,027,131       34,177.4       19.46       14.89       17.21       -2.03       7.18       -2.82       1.30       1.51       14.63       9.44       140.78       285,372,000  

INDB

  Independent Bank Corp.   NE     81.05       48,327       3,916.9       87.00       57.01       81.79       -0.90       32.30       10.91       5.04       6.02       72.92       47.86       512.83       24,783,580  

IBCP

  Independent Bank Corporation   MW     34.31       20,606       707.0       39.17       29.63       35.32       -2.86       12.97       5.47       3.35       3.45       24.80       23.38       269.70       5,557,509  

IBOC

  International Bancshares Corporation   SW     73.56       62,181       4,574.1       77.11       61.45       75.67       -2.79       17.66       10.72       6.70       6.68       52.88       48.34       270.60       16,826,407  

ISTR

  Investar Holding Corporation   SW     29.84       13,794       411.6       31.77       17.89       29.78       0.20       63.42       11.68       2.28       2.44       27.97       22.72       280.94       3,875,115  

ISBA

  Isabella Bank Corporation   MW     40.31       7,333       295.6       58.83       28.49       43.24       -6.78       3.33       -19.38       2.71       2.76       31.90       25.32       307.12       2,251,956  

JMSB

  John Marshall Bancorp, Inc.   SE     21.31       14,044       299.3       22.35       17.30       21.50       -0.88       19.92       6.60       1.59       1.57       19.00       19.00       167.50       2,352,350  

JPM

  JPMorgan Chase & Co.   MA     325.22       2,679,511       871,430.7       338.09       269.72       313.49       3.74       18.71       0.93       20.88       20.84       128.38       107.78       1828.87       4,900,475,000  

KRNY

  Kearny Financial Corp.   MA     8.47       62,933       533.0       8.89       5.76       8.66       -2.19       39.77       14.30       0.57       0.56       11.79       10.02       120.89       7,607,656  

KEY

  KeyCorp   MW     22.59       1,079,369       24,382.9       23.35       15.68       22.33       1.16       41.10       9.45       1.63       1.63       16.08       13.55       174.79       188,663,000  

LSBK

  Lake Shore Bancorp, Inc.   MA     17.40       7,863       136.8       17.40       11.23       16.20       7.41       50.10       18.69       1.09       1.08       18.11       18.11       91.82       722,011  

LKFN

  Lakeland Financial Corporation   MW     59.86       24,914       1,491.3       69.40       54.36       60.83       -1.59       2.46       4.91       4.27       4.26       30.04       29.84       284.33       7,083,680  

LARK

  Landmark Bancorp, Inc.   MW     29.37       6,098       179.1       30.20       22.31       29.00       1.28       16.68       12.14       3.12       3.27       26.50       20.89       263.35       1,605,787  

LCNB

  LCNB Corp.   MW     17.19       14,246       244.9       17.89       13.90       17.09       0.59       20.72       4.88       1.61       1.68       19.36       12.55       157.09       2,237,836  

LC

  LendingClub Corporation   WE     19.21       115,351       2,215.9       21.67       10.74       18.24       5.32       71.21       1.43       1.49       1.51       13.19       11.90       103.51       11,939,839  

LOB

  Live Oak Bancshares, Inc.   SE     38.26       46,262       1,770.0       42.89       27.35       38.66       -1.03       36.79       11.38       2.61       2.24       25.55       NA       330.72       15,300,033  

MTB

  M&T Bank Corporation   MA     225.12       146,445       32,967.7       239.00       174.76       227.82       -1.19       23.90       11.73       17.86       17.53       173.83       115.83       1466.32       214,736,000  

MGYR

  Magyar Bancorp, Inc.   MA     18.15       6,478       117.6       20.00       16.00       17.11       6.08       12.66       5.03       1.78       1.78       19.19       19.11       164.93       1,068,398  

MNSB

  MainStreet Bancshares, Inc.   SE     23.86       7,117       163.6       25.19       17.86       24.40       -2.21       30.88       17.19       1.99       2.14       25.63       25.63       312.37       2,223,293  

MBBC

  Marathon Bancorp, Inc.   MW     15.31       2,951       45.2       15.75       9.90       14.30       7.06       54.65       25.90       0.43       0.43       16.11       16.11       84.39       249,023  

MCHB

  Mechanics Bancorp   WE     14.66       221,401       3,245.7       16.03       12.42       15.17       -3.36       32.59       0.21       1.14       0.96       12.06       7.53       96.61       21,388,955  

MBWM

  Mercantile Bank Corporation   MW     53.75       17,274       928.5       55.77       42.69       54.22       -0.87       23.39       11.75       5.57       5.78       42.66       37.34       402.04       6,945,035  

MBIN

  Merchants Bancorp   MW     49.09       45,935       2,255.0       51.00       28.75       49.56       -0.95       56.79       44.13       4.10       4.10       38.73       38.55       442.40       20,321,782  

MRBK

  Meridian Corporation   MA     19.25       11,890       228.9       21.67       11.16       19.75       -2.53       67.54       9.50       1.85       1.83       16.86       16.26       216.70       2,576,581  

MCBS

  MetroCity Bankshares, Inc.   SE     34.17       28,660       979.3       35.30       24.53       34.55       -1.10       27.12       28.75       2.77       2.96       19.34       16.56       163.58       4,688,347  

MCB

  Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp.   MA     93.11       12,395       1,154.1       97.84       64.25       96.18       -3.19       43.84       21.94       8.12       8.07       76.53       75.74       713.54       8,844,124  

MPB

  Mid Penn Bancorp, Inc.   MA     33.54       25,345       850.1       35.22       26.35       33.92       -1.12       25.62       8.12       2.20       2.95       35.08       27.56       274.80       6,964,809  

MSBI

  Midland States Bancorp, Inc.   MW     29.43       20,730       610.1       30.34       14.24       29.63       -0.67       80.66       39.02       1.18       2.19       21.54       20.76       315.87       6,547,963  

MVBF

  MVB Financial Corp.   SE     27.63       12,850       355.0       29.59       20.31       27.65       -0.07       34.19       6.97       2.18       -0.30       26.07       25.91       258.55       3,322,298  

NBHC

  National Bank Holdings Corporation   SW     42.82       44,791       1,917.9       44.12       35.06       42.90       -0.19       19.44       12.65       2.68       3.21       37.25       25.63       281.63       12,614,408  

NKSH

  National Bankshares, Inc.   SE     35.30       6,363       224.6       40.00       24.74       36.09       -2.19       36.24       5.28       2.75       3.05       29.43       27.52       287.43       1,828,993  

NBBK

  NB Bancorp, Inc.   NE     20.13       41,503       835.4       22.86       16.05       20.44       -1.52       24.18       1.56       1.37       1.74       18.83       18.00       174.12       7,226,437  

NBTB

  NBT Bancorp Inc.   MA     46.68       52,010       2,427.8       48.81       39.20       47.67       -2.08       16.79       12.43       3.51       3.98       36.81       27.05       311.56       16,204,406  

NEWT

  NewtekOne, Inc.   SE     13.91       28,859       401.4       14.91       9.59       13.70       1.53       32.98       22.56       2.27       -0.20       12.36       11.85       100.03       2,886,767  

NIC

  Nicolet Bankshares, Inc.   MW     146.85       21,252       3,120.8       163.11       114.12       147.22       -0.25       25.44       21.06       8.53       NA       105.07       59.79       732.85       15,574,490  

NBN

  Northeast Bank   NE     126.49       8,555       1,082.2       142.31       80.45       128.69       -1.71       54.11       21.71       11.67       11.66       66.35       66.33       588.41       5,034,096  

NECB

  Northeast Community Bancorp, Inc.   MA     25.74       12,393       319.0       26.14       19.27       25.64       0.39       14.55       13.84       3.22       3.21       25.79       25.79       163.41       2,025,127  

NTRS

  Northern Trust Corporation   MW     172.11       185,047       31,848.5       176.99       109.39       170.75       0.80       55.08       26.00       9.55       9.61       65.40       61.25       943.40       174,574,300  

NPB

  Northpointe Bancshares, Inc.   MW     17.85       34,582       617.3       19.48       12.91       18.33       -2.62       37.20       6.38       2.22       2.23       16.38       16.34       213.87       7,395,877  

NRIM

  Northrim BanCorp, Inc.   WE     25.21       22,245       560.8       30.82       19.60       25.52       -1.21       15.38       -5.26       2.88       2.45       15.10       12.71       150.82       3,354,908  

NWBI

  Northwest Bancshares, Inc.   MW     14.48       146,315       2,118.6       14.93       11.25       14.58       -0.69       19.47       20.67       0.93       1.19       13.02       9.72       115.55       16,907,049  

NWFL

  Norwood Financial Corp.   MA     30.77       10,833       333.3       32.36       23.70       31.91       -3.57       22.01       9.70       2.72       3.19       26.07       22.43       269.30       2,917,254  

OVLY

  Oak Valley Bancorp   WE     34.03       8,274       281.6       35.97       25.25       34.64       -1.76       33.98       13.21       2.88       2.86       24.50       24.11       242.95       2,010,299  

OCFC

  OceanFirst Financial Corp.   MA     18.03       57,600       1,743.5       20.61       16.09       18.40       -2.01       7.51       0.45       1.17       1.49       28.98       19.86       252.71       14,556,336  

OFG

  OFG Bancorp   MA     46.66       42,258       1,971.8       48.57       35.71       47.38       -1.52       14.50       13.86       4.84       4.92       32.35       30.14       285.10       12,047,903  

OVBC

  Ohio Valley Banc Corp.   MW     48.11       4,711       226.6       54.96       27.51       49.15       -2.12       65.27       20.34       3.28       3.91       36.36       34.80       356.08       1,677,502  

ONB

  Old National Bancorp   MW     24.80       386,373       9,582.1       26.17       19.39       24.69       0.45       21.21       11.16       1.94       2.42       21.40       13.93       188.94       73,002,651  

OSBC

  Old Second Bancorp, Inc.   MW     21.89       51,432       1,125.9       22.67       16.43       22.22       -1.49       31.16       12.26       1.68       1.96       17.29       14.35       133.17       6,849,221  

OPBK

  OP Bancorp   WE     14.36       14,894       213.9       15.27       11.52       13.99       2.64       22.32       1.70       1.82       1.82       15.62       NA       181.19       2,698,627  

OPHC

  OptimumBank Holdings, Inc.   SE     5.85       12,166       71.2       5.90       3.91       5.54       5.60       32.95       37.65       0.74       0.74       7.35       7.35       104.28       1,268,735  

OBT

  Orange County Bancorp, Inc.   MA     37.23       13,408       499.2       38.03       22.98       35.98       3.47       57.75       30.40       3.40       3.09       21.75       21.32       201.79       2,705,620  

OBK

  Origin Bancorp, Inc.   SW     49.36       30,904       1,525.4       50.35       32.13       49.56       -0.40       42.37       31.24       2.58       2.99       40.81       35.61       329.67       10,188,144  

ORRF

  Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.   MA     39.03       19,648       766.9       40.72       29.40       39.14       -0.28       31.02       10.19       4.37       4.69       30.76       25.38       283.85       5,576,972  

PRK

  Park National Corporation   MW     176.62       18,096       3,196.1       182.34       149.06       177.76       -0.64       10.96       16.06       10.91       11.95       93.93       77.21       717.50       12,983,967  

PKBK

  Parke Bancorp, Inc.   MA     31.86       11,731       373.7       32.44       18.90       31.95       -0.28       67.24       27.24       3.50       3.50       28.58       28.58       188.64       2,212,935  

PBHC

  Pathfinder Bancorp, Inc.   MA     16.87       6,256       105.5       16.88       12.06       14.85       13.60       13.83       19.56       -0.40       0.10       19.75       18.11       227.28       1,421,982  

CASH

  Pathward Financial, Inc.   MW     82.05       21,110       1,732.1       101.26       65.87       82.91       -1.04       12.54       15.56       8.42       8.53       39.92       25.45       336.92       7,112,399  

PNBK

  Patriot National Bancorp, Inc.   NE     1.07       117,670       125.9       2.00       0.86       0.94       14.44       11.46       -41.21       -0.13       -0.13       0.77       0.76       10.00       1,176,794  

PCB

  PCB Bancorp   WE     26.80       14,149       379.2       26.82       19.50       26.05       2.88       34.74       23.79       2.78       2.79       23.02       22.96       240.03       3,396,193  

PGC

  Peapack-Gladstone Financial Corporation   MA     44.75       17,505       783.3       46.57       24.42       46.11       -2.95       67.85       60.68       2.48       2.47       37.79       35.26       439.82       7,698,965  

PEBO

  Peoples Bancorp Inc.   MW     36.23       35,923       1,301.5       36.82       27.49       36.09       0.39       24.42       20.65       3.12       3.38       33.85       22.97       268.57       9,648,087  

PEBK

  Peoples Bancorp of North Carolina, Inc.   SE     42.45       5,310       225.4       45.78       26.81       44.06       -3.65       53.23       17.25       3.63       3.29       28.95       28.95       326.66       1,734,478  

PFIS

  Peoples Financial Services Corp.   MA     62.24       10,011       623.1       64.91       43.64       62.78       -0.86       32.03       27.78       5.85       6.49       52.50       42.29       541.74       5,423,330  

PNFP

  Pinnacle Financial Partners, Inc.   SE     96.12       150,401       14,456.5       120.46       81.08       93.74       2.54       -7.21       0.74       7.21       8.99       91.42       61.18       816.26       122,766,000  

PLBC

  Plumas Bancorp   WE     55.56       6,968       387.1       57.51       39.70       55.70       -0.25       31.25       24.32       4.72       5.17       38.05       33.07       315.73       2,200,075  

PDLB

  Ponce Financial Group, Inc.   MA     19.32       24,188       467.3       19.65       12.81       19.25       0.36       48.96       18.17       1.30       1.26       13.49       13.49       136.46       3,300,757  


Exhibit 1A

Weekly Bank and Thrift Market Line - Part One

Prices As of June 18, 2026

 

            Market Capitalization     Price Change Data     Current Per Share Financials        
            Price/
Share(1)
    Shares
Outstanding
    Market
Capitalization
    52 Week (1)     Last Wk     % Change From     LTM
EPS (3)
    LTM Core
EPS (3)
    BV/
Share
    TBV/
Share (4)
    Assets/
Share
    Assets  
        High     Low     Last Wk     52 Wks (2)     MRY (2)        
            ($)     (000)     ($Mil)     ($)     ($)     ($)     (%)     (%)     (%)     ($)     ($)     ($)     ($)     ($)        

Companies

                                                                                             

BPOP

  Popular, Inc.   MA     159.24       64,538       10,277.0       162.97       102.97       158.81       0.27       53.41       27.88       13.54       13.13       97.27       84.98       1179.64       76,131,018  

PFBC

  Preferred Bank   WE     99.04       11,842       1,172.8       103.05       79.65       100.98       -1.92       23.25       4.88       10.73       10.72       65.04       65.01       646.40       7,654,637  

FRST

  Primis Financial Corp.   SE     15.45       24,772       382.7       15.89       9.55       15.43       0.13       55.90       11.07       1.88       0.53       17.25       13.47       171.83       4,256,668  

BPRN

  Princeton Bancorp, Inc.   MA     38.35       6,811       261.2       38.40       29.21       36.93       3.85       30.62       10.55       2.86       2.98       40.26       37.76       330.89       2,253,767  

PB

  Prosperity Bancshares, Inc.   SW     71.19       100,855       7,179.8       77.20       61.07       71.54       -0.49       5.16       3.01       5.52       5.96       81.40       42.39       432.50       43,619,183  

PROV

  Provident Financial Holdings, Inc.   WE     16.84       6,254       105.3       17.42       14.95       16.97       -0.77       8.86       5.85       0.92       0.96       20.02       20.02       194.70       1,217,624  

PFS

  Provident Financial Services, Inc.   MA     22.72       130,314       2,960.7       23.98       15.92       23.25       -2.28       40.77       15.04       2.35       2.56       21.97       16.04       193.39       25,201,690  

QCRH

  QCR Holdings, Inc.   MW     94.96       16,510       1,567.8       97.25       64.06       96.38       -1.47       47.64       14.00       7.98       8.20       68.04       59.18       582.30       9,613,695  

RBB

  RBB Bancorp   WE     25.48       16,936       431.5       26.12       15.95       24.50       4.00       57.67       23.45       2.36       2.17       31.10       26.77       247.66       4,194,312  

RRBI

  Red River Bancshares, Inc.   SW     88.80       6,585       584.7       98.85       56.06       91.43       -2.88       57.14       24.32       6.68       6.64       56.76       56.53       508.24       3,346,600  

RF

  Regions Financial Corporation   SE     28.62       853,380       24,423.7       31.53       21.44       28.89       -0.93       30.33       5.61       2.40       2.43       20.41       13.54       188.36       160,741,000  

RNST

  Renasant Corporation   SE     41.69       92,272       3,846.8       43.50       33.04       42.26       -1.35       20.70       18.37       2.41       3.08       41.63       25.00       293.78       27,107,274  

RBCA.A

  Republic Bancorp, Inc.   MW     84.76       19,618       1,662.8       88.78       63.97       86.88       -2.43       23.61       22.86       6.48       6.35       57.78       55.64       369.73       7,253,279  

RMBI

  Richmond Mutual Bancorporation, Inc.   MW     14.75       9,691       142.9       16.04       12.77       14.72       0.20       11.74       5.06       1.25       1.35       13.80       13.80       156.76       1,519,216  

RVSB

  Riverview Bancorp, Inc.   WE     5.80       20,285       117.7       6.22       4.74       5.95       -2.52       8.41       15.54       -0.21       0.23       7.08       5.76       72.16       1,463,809  

STBA

  S&T Bancorp, Inc.   MA     46.84       35,977       1,685.2       48.70       34.01       47.14       -0.64       30.33       19.03       3.57       3.58       39.46       29.10       276.40       9,944,003  

SBFG

  SB Financial Group, Inc.   MW     23.01       6,275       144.4       23.93       17.10       22.85       0.70       32.47       3.32       2.55       2.57       22.86       18.25       255.71       1,604,598  

SBCF

  Seacoast Banking Corporation of Florida   SE     30.84       96,221       2,967.5       35.55       24.46       31.32       -1.53       24.10       -1.85       1.52       2.42       27.83       15.61       219.76       21,145,147  

SFBS

  ServisFirst Bancshares, Inc.   SE     80.46       54,663       4,398.2       90.64       67.20       81.56       -1.35       11.26       12.08       5.42       5.61       34.98       34.73       332.42       18,171,287  

SHBI

  Shore Bancshares, Inc.   MA     21.96       33,456       734.7       23.12       14.35       22.28       -1.44       50.51       24.21       1.88       2.06       18.02       15.30       185.50       6,206,063  

BSRR

  Sierra Bancorp   WE     39.51       12,906       509.9       41.22       26.49       40.25       -1.84       44.73       20.90       3.43       3.42       27.78       25.69       290.92       3,754,462  

SFNC

  Simmons First National Corporation   SE     21.90       145,064       3,176.9       22.62       17.00       22.19       -1.31       20.33       16.18       -2.56       2.01       23.70       14.03       170.22       24,692,783  

SMBK

  SmartFinancial, Inc.   SE     44.65       17,098       763.4       46.29       31.21       44.84       -0.42       41.88       20.71       3.12       3.27       32.87       27.32       345.51       5,907,685  

SFBC

  Sound Financial Bancorp, Inc.   WE     43.83       2,557       112.1       48.85       40.68       43.25       1.34       -7.43       0.46       2.93       2.93       43.00       42.69       434.96       1,112,051  

SPFI

  South Plains Financial, Inc.   SW     40.72       19,146       779.6       45.09       34.61       41.76       -2.49       16.44       4.95       3.57       3.66       30.90       29.65       242.68       4,646,374  

SFST

  Southern First Bancshares, Inc.   SE     58.03       9,455       548.7       62.38       35.15       61.51       -5.66       60.30       12.64       4.26       4.31       46.00       46.00       484.22       4,578,402  

SMBC

  Southern Missouri Bancorp, Inc.   MW     72.51       11,016       798.7       75.00       47.60       71.39       1.58       40.22       22.65       5.99       6.29       52.07       45.84       466.74       5,141,464  

SBSI

  Southside Bancshares, Inc.   SW     33.63       29,752       1,000.6       34.75       26.32       34.02       -1.15       19.89       10.66       2.36       3.24       28.73       21.94       295.85       8,802,182  

SSB

  SouthState Bank Corporation   SE     96.53       97,938       9,453.9       108.46       84.48       97.50       -0.99       12.19       2.57       9.27       10.35       92.21       56.90       694.11       67,979,223  

SRBK

  SR Bancorp, Inc.   MA     18.83       7,730       145.6       19.61       12.81       18.89       -0.32       44.51       19.63       0.59       0.57       22.63       19.46       147.92       1,143,450  

STT

  State Street Corporation   NE     168.31       276,767       46,582.7       174.66       96.27       164.85       2.10       69.50       30.46       9.86       11.78       87.33       54.85       1416.95       392,165,000  

SYBT

  Stock Yards Bancorp, Inc.   MW     73.18       31,069       2,273.6       83.83       61.51       74.81       -2.18       -1.16       12.67       4.86       4.94       37.37       30.41       304.71       9,466,856  

SSBI

  Summit State Bank   WE     13.58       6,777       92.0       14.00       9.40       13.45       0.97       40.73       16.77       0.89       0.89       15.16       14.76       146.97       995,922  

TCBI

  Texas Capital Bancshares, Inc.   SW     99.07       43,671       4,326.5       108.92       73.62       100.36       -1.29       30.84       9.42       7.44       7.55       75.71       75.67       766.79       33,486,484  

TCBS

  Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.   SW     17.78       2,700       48.0       20.00       15.10       17.19       3.43       11.19       -1.06       1.09       1.09       18.80       18.80       159.40       430,446  

TBBK

  The Bancorp, Inc.   MA     56.17       41,634       2,338.6       81.65       49.66       56.50       -0.58       10.79       -16.81       5.14       5.11       16.65       16.63       237.75       9,898,764  

BNY

  The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation   MA     143.63       686,379       98,584.6       148.13       87.41       142.09       1.08       56.80       23.72       8.07       8.12       57.48       29.01       818.09       561,517,000  

FNLC

  The First Bancorp, Inc.   NE     30.38       11,276       342.6       31.25       23.47       30.52       -0.46       28.40       14.90       3.24       3.24       25.44       22.71       283.86       3,200,763  

PNC

  The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.   MA     232.04       401,565       93,179.1       243.94       172.89       233.94       -0.81       32.39       11.17       17.21       17.21       143.65       108.39       1501.70       603,028,000  

TCBX

  Third Coast Bancshares, Inc.   SW     38.99       16,592       646.9       43.84       29.98       39.45       -1.17       29.79       2.58       3.89       4.13       35.28       31.96       396.70       6,582,073  

TSBK

  Timberland Bancorp, Inc.   WE     42.53       7,828       332.9       43.58       29.96       42.20       0.78       39.53       18.80       3.91       3.82       34.61       32.65       261.42       2,046,386  

TMP

  Tompkins Financial Corporation   MA     89.30       14,383       1,284.4       93.02       59.70       91.19       -2.07       48.56       23.14       11.67       5.89       65.78       60.73       604.59       8,695,761  

TOWN

  TowneBank   SE     34.71       91,298       3,169.0       37.86       31.91       35.15       -1.25       5.89       4.02       2.08       3.06       31.31       21.49       244.90       22,358,708  

TCBK

  TriCo Bancshares   WE     51.40       31,911       1,640.2       53.18       37.96       52.04       -1.23       32.54       8.51       3.95       3.98       41.49       31.82       311.75       9,948,211  

TFIN

  Triumph Financial, Inc.   SW     72.07       23,806       1,715.7       77.84       46.43       74.64       -3.44       32.24       15.07       1.19       1.27       38.05       21.21       288.86       6,876,715  

TFC

  Truist Financial Corporation   SE     48.33       1,245,879       60,213.3       56.20       38.94       50.68       -4.64       21.40       -1.79       4.03       4.36       47.60       32.89       440.63       548,975,000  

TRST

  TrustCo Bank Corp NY   MA     52.24       17,475       912.9       55.60       30.52       54.89       -4.83       70.00       26.40       3.41       3.41       38.32       38.29       372.41       6,507,879  

TRMK

  Trustmark Corporation   SE     44.67       58,606       2,617.9       46.34       33.39       45.41       -1.63       31.85       14.69       3.78       3.78       36.28       30.58       323.99       18,987,324  

USB

  U.S. Bancorp   MW     58.14       1,557,732       90,566.5       61.19       42.55       57.63       0.88       34.37       8.96       4.77       5.05       37.94       28.76       450.01       700,998,000  

UMBF

  UMB Financial Corporation   MW     133.06       75,979       10,109.7       137.56       98.16       132.51       0.42       33.74       15.66       11.27       12.91       99.15       68.86       956.51       72,674,161  

UNB

  Union Bankshares, Inc.   NE     23.70       4,614       109.4       29.49       20.65       23.29       1.76       -11.96       -0.13       2.51       2.44       17.46       16.98       352.22       1,625,145  

UBCP

  United Bancorp, Inc.   MW     15.99       5,757       92.1       17.34       12.47       15.80       1.20       16.38       11.43       1.35       1.26       11.30       11.18       149.13       858,499  

UBSI

  United Bankshares, Inc.   SE     44.42       137,475       6,106.6       46.09       34.10       44.98       -1.24       27.75       15.68       3.57       3.55       39.65       24.84       245.18       33,705,380  

UCB

  United Community Banks, Inc.   SE     32.85       119,687       3,931.7       36.77       27.23       34.27       -4.14       18.21       5.22       2.72       2.85       30.54       22.43       235.42       28,176,582  

UNTY

  Unity Bancorp, Inc.   MA     55.43       10,041       556.6       57.82       43.41       55.45       -0.04       26.24       7.17       5.94       5.46       35.66       35.46       301.50       3,027,327  

UVSP

  Univest Financial Corporation   MA     41.64       27,846       1,159.5       43.26       27.91       42.02       -0.90       44.48       27.18       3.33       3.31       34.06       27.71       292.38       8,141,582  

USCB

  USCB Financial Holdings, Inc.   SE     19.15       18,264       349.8       20.79       15.67       19.50       -1.79       20.36       3.96       1.43       1.75       12.23       12.23       155.81       2,845,735  

VLY

  Valley National Bancorp   MA     14.09       554,131       7,807.7       14.72       8.36       14.41       -2.22       64.41       20.63       1.11       1.12       13.48       9.98       116.34       64,466,585  

VABK

  Virginia National Bankshares Corporation   SE     44.71       5,423       242.4       48.58       36.56       44.64       0.16       20.16       12.20       3.69       3.84       34.39       32.51       303.95       1,648,164  

WAFD

  WaFd, Inc.   WE     36.48       73,888       2,695.5       38.59       26.31       36.57       -0.25       30.66       13.89       3.06       3.15       36.30       30.27       373.11       27,568,785  

WASH

  Washington Trust Bancorp, Inc.   NE     34.92       19,066       665.8       37.08       25.23       34.95       -0.09       29.77       18.17       2.73       2.76       28.72       25.14       338.79       6,459,196  

WSBF

  Waterstone Financial, Inc.   MW     19.21       17,210       330.6       19.76       13.08       19.34       -0.67       43.25       16.07       1.66       1.66       19.19       19.15       130.81       2,251,218  

WFC

  Wells Fargo & Company   WE     82.20       3,060,189       251,547.6       97.76       72.57       82.40       -0.24       9.98       -11.80       6.48       6.18       53.21       44.58       720.79       2,205,752,000  

WSBC

  WesBanco, Inc.   SE     36.29       96,181       3,490.4       38.10       29.18       36.03       0.72       20.44       9.18       3.10       3.82       40.01       22.16       285.74       27,482,455  

WTBA

  West Bancorporation, Inc.   MW     24.92       17,028       424.3       26.60       17.31       24.85       0.28       32.20       12.30       2.06       2.24       15.90       15.90       235.55       4,010,973  

WABC

  Westamerica Bancorporation   WE     57.73       23,488       1,356.0       59.25       44.93       57.47       0.45       25.34       20.70       4.49       4.50       37.35       32.20       249.68       5,864,450  

WAL

  Western Alliance Bancorporation   WE     79.91       107,785       8,613.1       97.23       65.82       82.32       -2.93       10.40       -4.95       8.59       7.46       67.01       61.10       917.13       98,853,000  

WNEB

  Western New England Bancorp, Inc.   NE     13.68       19,972       273.2       14.52       8.53       13.62       0.44       58.89       8.40       0.89       0.88       12.26       11.59       138.42       2,764,537  

WTFC

  Wintrust Financial Corporation   MW     154.11       67,448       10,394.4       162.96       117.21       155.85       -1.12       29.83       10.22       11.93       12.15       103.10       89.90       1069.83       72,157,433  

WSFS

  WSFS Financial Corporation   MA     74.14       52,044       3,858.5       76.37       49.92       74.34       -0.27       44.38       34.21       5.62       5.95       52.24       33.80       424.77       22,106,915  

ZION

  Zions Bancorporation, National Association   SW     66.17       147,092       9,733.1       67.99       46.19       66.44       -0.41       36.91       13.03       6.43       6.11       49.16       41.75       597.97       87,957,000  

MHCs

                                 

BSBK

  Bogota Financial Corp.   MA     8.99       12,505       112.4       9.50       6.95       9.06       -0.77       17.28       6.39       0.17       0.17       11.00       11.00       70.15       877,245  

CLBK

  Columbia Financial, Inc.   MA     20.03       104,143       2,086.0       21.20       13.66       20.73       -3.38       44.83       28.89       0.55       0.59       11.27       NA       105.72       11,010,507  

GCBC

  Greene County Bancorp, Inc.   MA     29.42       17,025       500.9       30.71       21.25       29.15       0.93       34.58       32.34       2.29       NA       15.72       15.72       186.85       3,181,155  

KFFB

  Kentucky First Federal Bancorp   MW     5.10       8,087       41.2       5.10       2.61       4.79       6.47       91.37       9.68       0.17       0.17       6.14       6.14       46.32       374,541  

PBFS

  Pioneer Bancorp, Inc.   MA     17.10       24,428       417.7       17.14       11.40       16.81       1.73       47.67       26.85       0.81       0.87       13.10       12.62       90.92       2,221,002  

RBKB

  Rhinebeck Bancorp, Inc.   MA     17.59       10,892       191.3       17.99       9.41       16.55       6.28       43.71       46.34       0.91       0.91       12.43       12.22       117.97       1,284,867  

TFSL

  TFS Financial Corporation   MW     16.42       278,807       4,578.0       17.00       12.54       16.80       -2.26       29.91       22.72       0.33       0.33       6.85       6.82       62.69       17,479,670  

WSBK

  Winchester Bancorp, Inc.   NE     13.20       9,295       122.7       13.39       8.76       12.93       2.09       49.32       26.32       0.46       0.31       12.82       12.82       113.72       1,057,104  

Under Acquisition

                               

AFBI

  Affinity Bancshares, Inc.   SE     22.53       6,095       137.3       22.53       18.32       22.51       0.09       22.58       10.06       1.37       1.43       21.24       18.30       151.71       924,677  

FBIZ

  First Business Financial Services, Inc.   MW     60.34       8,362       504.6       61.30       45.90       59.77       0.95       27.83       11.12       6.07       6.05       44.12       42.76       516.71       4,320,855  

FSEA

  First Seacoast Bancorp, Inc.   NE     16.77       4,358       73.1       17.00       10.13       16.82       -0.30       49.47       27.05       -0.22       -0.21       13.34       13.30       135.12       588,809  

FSUN

  FirstSun Capital Bancorp   SW     36.19       44,124       1,691.4       42.34       29.95       36.79       -1.63       8.58       -3.84       3.39       NA       42.08       38.57       194.12       8,565,123  

NFBK

  Northfield Bancorp, Inc.   MA     14.41       41,764       601.8       14.84       9.91       14.68       -1.84       24.01       26.07       0.12       0.97       16.63       16.63       137.32       5,735,202  

NSTS

  NSTS Bancorp, Inc.   MW     13.74       4,915       67.5       13.84       10.72       13.73       0.07       10.81       6.10       -0.02       -0.02       15.20       15.20       54.99       270,318  

STEL

  Stellar Bancorp, Inc.   SW     38.43       50,921       1,956.9       40.21       26.30       38.40       0.08       43.93       24.21       2.05       2.43       32.76       21.69       213.85       10,889,356  

WBS

  Webster Financial Corporation   NE     75.62       162,026       12,252.4       76.10       50.66       73.20       3.31       46.66       20.15       6.11       6.34       57.33       37.59       528.21       85,584,588  

 

(1)

Average of High/Low or Bid/Ask price per share. 

(2)

Or since offering price if converted of first listed in the past 52 weeks. Percent change figures are actual year-to-date and are not annualized. 

(3)

EPS (earnings per share) is based on actual trailing 12 month data and is not shown on a pro forma basis.  

(4)

Excludes intangibles (such as goodwill, value of core deposits, etc.).  

(5)

ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month common earnings and average common equity and total assets balances. 

(6)

Annualized based on last regular quarterly cash dividend announcement. 

(7)

Indicated dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month earnings. 

(8)

Excluded from averages due to actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics. 

(9)

For MHC institutions, market value reflects share price multiplied by public (non-MHC) shares. 

Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.

Copyright (c) 2026 by RP® Financial, LC. 


Exhibit 1B

Weekly Bank and Thrift Market Line - Part Two

Prices As of June 18, 2026

 

            Key Financial Ratios     Asset Quality Ratios     Pricing Ratios     Dividend Data (6)  
            Equity/
Assets(1)
    Tang Equity/
Assets(1)
    Reported Earnings     Core Earnings     NPAs/
Assets
    Rsvs/
NPLs
    Price/
Earnings
    Price/
Book
    Price/
Assets
    Price/
Tang Book
    Price/
Core Earnings
    Div/
Share
    Dividend
Yield
    Payout
Ratio (7)
 
        ROA(5)     ROE(5)     ROA(5)     ROE(5)  
            (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)     ($)     (%)     (%)  

Companies

                                                                                                   

SRCE

  1st Source Corporation   MW     14.49       13.70       1.78       12.44       1.86       13.53       0.80       230.14       11.80       144.85       20.41       155.03       11.29       1.72       2.24       24.69  

ACNB

  ACNB Corporation   MA     13.01       10.67       1.56       12.47       1.81       14.44       0.23       309.66       11.70       139.03       18.09       174.17       10.10       1.68       2.99       41.31  

ALRS

  Alerus Financial Corporation   MW     10.87       8.85       0.52       5.03       1.69       16.53       1.02       93.73       28.27       130.22       14.15       163.52       8.56       0.88       2.97       80.95  

AMAL

  Amalgamated Financial Corp.   MA     8.81       8.67       1.21       13.51       1.24       13.83       1.08       68.95       12.78       162.51       14.31       165.32       12.48       0.68       1.57       18.02  

AMTB

  Amerant Bancorp Inc.   SE     9.23       9.03       0.57       6.20       0.75       8.08       1.91       45.61       16.74       102.78       9.49       105.28       12.63       0.36       1.55       25.53  

ABCB

  Ameris Bancorp   SE     14.52       11.14       1.60       10.88       1.63       11.11       0.22       618.30       13.77       144.45       20.98       195.68       13.49       0.80       0.91       12.58  

ASRV

  AmeriServ Financial, Inc.   MA     8.20       7.34       0.38       4.80       0.38       4.81       0.55       167.70       11.79       54.67       4.48       61.65       11.75       0.12       3.13       36.36  

ATLO

  Ames National Corporation   MW     9.69       9.13       1.02       10.81       1.04       10.93       0.95       86.72       12.17       125.71       12.18       134.21       12.04       0.96       3.26       36.36  

AROW

  Arrow Financial Corporation   MA     9.73       9.23       1.16       12.15       1.20       12.60       0.10       895.71       12.56       145.69       14.18       154.48       12.11       1.20       3.12       38.19  

ASB

  Associated Banc-Corp   MW     10.96       8.71       1.11       10.12       1.13       10.29       0.32       348.84       10.14       100.56       10.64       131.34       9.97       0.96       3.32       32.99  

AUB

  Atlantic Union Bankshares Corporation   SE     13.54       8.50       0.92       7.05       1.35       10.31       0.27       297.56       16.59       113.86       14.98       196.51       11.20       1.48       3.83       61.44  

AUBN

  Auburn National Bancorporation, Inc.   SE     9.06       9.06       0.79       9.15       0.79       9.15       0.01       NM       11.19       95.42       8.65       95.42       11.19       1.08       4.25       47.58  

AVBH

  Avidbank Holdings, Inc.   WE     11.18       11.18       -0.66       -6.37       1.38       13.29       0.63       128.27       NM       121.39       13.57       121.39       9.13       NA       NA       NM  

AVBC

  Avidia Bancorp, Inc.   NE     13.66       13.29       0.51       4.52       0.88       7.69       0.49       167.02       NA       105.43       14.40       108.81       NA       0.20       1.02       NA  

AX

  Axos Financial, Inc.   WE     10.48       9.83       1.80       16.62       1.79       16.52       0.62       192.15       10.70       163.44       17.13       175.52       10.77       NA       NA       NM  

BANC

  Banc of California, Inc.   WE     10.23       9.41       0.73       7.11       0.80       7.74       0.59       130.08       15.34       101.45       9.05       113.06       13.88       0.48       2.42       33.59  

BANF

  BancFirst Corporation   SW     12.58       11.39       1.71       13.86       1.70       13.75       0.69       205.01       15.25       196.50       24.72       220.08       15.37       1.96       1.77       33.56  

BFC

  Bank First Corporation   MW     13.51       9.14       1.52       10.92       1.79       12.84       0.42       259.01       19.84       195.31       26.38       303.29       17.00       2.20       1.56       27.12  

BAC

  Bank of America Corporation   SE     8.60       6.71       0.92       10.56       0.92       10.58       0.18       207.68       13.95       145.35       11.54       195.63       13.91       1.12       1.98       27.79  

BOH

  Bank of Hawaii Corporation   WE     7.76       7.63       0.92       12.30       0.94       12.58       0.05       NM       15.73       203.13       13.08       207.44       15.34       2.80       3.62       56.57  

BMRC

  Bank of Marin Bancorp   WE     10.08       8.33       -0.83       -7.52       0.99       9.00       NA       264.03       NM       105.92       10.68       130.57       10.77       1.00       3.90       NM  

BOTJ

  Bank of the James Financial Group, Inc.   SE     7.66       6.95       1.06       14.66       1.10       15.23       0.14       427.66       10.14       137.22       10.51       152.36       9.77       0.40       1.66       16.53  

OZK

  Bank OZK   SE     14.78       13.40       1.74       11.70       1.74       11.70       1.06       166.18       8.02       92.61       13.04       104.48       8.02       1.88       3.82       29.64  

BSVN

  Bank7 Corp.   SW     13.36       12.82       2.40       18.48       2.41       18.53       0.50       210.11       9.80       167.25       22.34       175.30       9.77       1.08       2.36       23.18  

BKU

  BankUnited, Inc.   SE     8.53       8.33       0.77       8.94       0.77       8.87       0.69       86.68       13.24       115.64       9.86       118.70       13.35       1.32       2.82       35.10  

BWFG

  Bankwell Financial Group, Inc.   NE     9.24       9.14       1.21       13.48       1.21       13.48       0.56       155.39       11.28       143.63       13.28       145.45       11.28       0.80       1.46       16.06  

BANR

  Banner Corporation   WE     12.03       9.96       1.26       10.78       1.28       10.96       0.31       364.39       10.91       111.67       13.44       138.02       10.74       2.08       3.21       33.67  

BHB

  Bar Harbor Bankshares   NE     11.50       8.42       0.90       7.87       1.23       10.76       0.52       148.29       14.85       113.26       13.03       160.20       10.81       1.36       3.77       53.06  

BCML

  BayCom Corp   WE     12.99       11.64       1.01       7.85       1.03       8.02       0.59       130.80       13.04       100.06       13.00       113.40       12.76       1.20       3.82       47.52  

BAFN

  BayFirst Financial Corp.   SE     6.85       NA       -2.17       -28.57       -1.73       -22.77       1.41       130.12       NM       30.81       1.73       NA       NM       0.00       0.00       NM  

BCBP

  BCB Bancorp, Inc.   MA     9.40       9.26       0.02       0.22       0.03       0.29       1.98       54.47       NM       68.05       5.92       69.34       NM       0.32       2.88       NM  

BBT

  Beacon Financial Corporation   NE     11.27       9.07       0.66       5.94       1.08       9.77       0.58       192.04       17.06       99.30       11.19       126.37       11.13       1.29       4.39       55.76  

BRBS

  Blue Ridge Bankshares, Inc.   SE     11.47       11.39       0.48       3.57       NA       NA       0.87       98.37       27.92       108.61       12.46       109.56       NA       0.00       0.00       708.33  

BOKF

  BOK Financial Corporation   SW     11.11       9.30       1.18       10.34       1.14       10.01       0.10       531.66       13.19       132.57       14.73       161.74       13.64       2.52       1.93       24.90  

BWB

  Bridgewater Bancshares, Inc.   MW     9.90       9.59       1.02       10.82       0.95       10.09       0.22       488.92       11.15       118.95       10.43       123.96       12.01       NA       NA       NM  

BYFC

  Broadway Financial Corporation   WE     18.42       18.34       -1.58       -7.64       -0.13       -0.64       NA       82.96       NM       81.85       7.22       82.86       NM       0.00       0.00       NM  

BHRB

  Burke & Herbert Financial Services Corp.   SE     10.90       10.06       1.48       14.36       1.59       15.42       0.98       91.39       8.50       115.40       12.45       126.40       7.91       2.20       3.38       28.53  

BFST

  Business First Bancshares, Inc.   SW     11.13       9.47       1.11       10.14       1.14       10.41       1.37       63.15       10.20       102.11       10.62       124.11       9.76       0.60       2.10       20.92  

BVFL

  BV Financial, Inc.   MA     20.16       18.82       1.37       6.59       1.58       7.60       0.29       243.77       14.63       96.92       19.54       105.56       12.58       0.13       0.00       NM  

BY

  Byline Bancorp, Inc.   MW     12.92       11.04       1.44       11.13       1.53       11.88       0.63       182.87       11.45       124.76       16.12       149.13       10.72       0.48       1.37       14.33  

CFFI

  C&F Financial Corporation   SE     9.46       8.61       1.04       11.27       1.02       11.00       0.10       NM       9.01       95.88       9.05       106.32       9.25       1.92       2.52       21.61  

BCAL

  California BanCorp   WE     14.27       11.46       1.48       10.70       1.59       11.45       0.96       112.60       10.79       109.84       15.68       141.29       10.08       0.40       2.05       16.39  

CAC

  Camden National Corporation   NE     10.20       7.64       1.15       11.82       1.23       12.61       0.16       415.88       10.96       122.66       12.51       168.37       10.27       1.68       3.28       35.74  

CBNK

  Capital Bancorp, Inc.   MA     10.74       9.74       1.60       14.23       1.67       14.87       1.56       98.67       10.05       132.53       14.23       147.65       9.62       0.48       1.45       14.50  

CCBG

  Capital City Bank Group, Inc.   SE     12.57       10.79       1.39       11.04       1.34       10.71       0.29       278.19       13.45       144.99       18.23       172.43       13.86       1.08       2.32       30.03  

COF

  Capital One Financial Corporation   SE     16.44       10.60       0.50       3.00       0.80       4.77       0.28       NM       70.71       116.15       18.32       199.33       33.25       3.20       1.59       105.26  

CFFN

  Capitol Federal Financial, Inc.   MW     10.44       10.35       0.80       7.42       0.80       7.45       0.56       48.44       13.47       100.58       10.50       101.52       13.42       0.34       4.24       63.33  

CARE

  Carter Bankshares, Inc.   SE     10.52       10.48       2.24       26.03       1.19       13.85       0.57       219.03       6.36       135.88       14.30       136.44       12.14       0.40       1.29       2.05  

CLST

  Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.   SW     28.49       28.49       0.73       2.49       0.75       2.58       0.85       94.37       29.87       81.11       23.11       81.11       28.82       NA       NA       NM  

CATY

  Cathay General Bancorp   WE     12.42       11.02       1.40       11.37       1.35       10.98       0.51       234.58       12.18       132.50       16.46       151.69       12.62       1.52       2.57       29.69  

CBFV

  CB Financial Services, Inc.   MA     10.03       9.47       0.45       4.49       1.02       10.22       0.21       309.49       28.68       118.22       11.85       125.94       12.62       1.12       3.01       83.72  

CBC

  Central Bancompany, Inc.   MW     18.57       17.15       2.07       11.81       2.16       12.32       0.25       308.45       15.77       178.22       33.09       196.35       15.09       0.48       1.70       16.65  

CPF

  Central Pacific Financial Corp.   WE     7.92       7.92       1.10       13.83       1.10       13.83       0.19       412.65       11.99       157.65       12.49       157.65       11.99       1.16       3.27       37.79  

CPBI

  Central Plains Bancshares, Inc.   MW     16.38       NA       0.77       5.32       0.77       5.32       NA       NM       18.10       89.32       14.63       NA       18.10       NA       NA       NM  

CFBK

  CF Bankshares Inc.   MW     8.81       8.81       0.87       10.01       0.87       10.01       0.71       122.16       10.79       104.63       9.10       104.63       10.79       0.36       1.21       12.23  

CBNA

  Chain Bridge Bancorp, Inc.   SE     9.11       9.11       1.36       13.28       1.36       13.28       0.00       NM       12.23       151.86       13.84       151.86       12.23       NA       NA       NM  

CHMG

  Chemung Financial Corporation   MA     9.57       8.84       0.67       7.44       1.15       12.80       0.36       326.34       18.73       130.07       12.44       141.84       10.77       1.36       1.92       35.88  

COFS

  ChoiceOne Financial Services, Inc.   MW     10.70       7.34       1.28       12.43       1.40       13.55       0.50       180.20       8.61       101.44       10.85       153.46       7.90       1.16       3.64       31.08  

C

  Citigroup Inc.   MA     7.65       6.90       0.60       7.61       0.64       8.23       0.12       582.50       17.73       127.48       8.85       144.49       16.38       2.40       1.67       29.74  

CZNC

  Citizens & Northern Corporation   MA     10.60       8.46       0.60       5.53       0.89       8.15       1.30       82.67       19.94       115.98       12.30       148.83       13.82       1.12       5.19       102.75  

CZWI

  Citizens Community Bancorp, Inc.   MW     10.47       8.88       0.85       8.07       0.87       8.22       1.00       132.73       13.95       107.65       11.27       129.15       13.69       0.42       1.98       13.73  

CFG

  Citizens Financial Group, Inc.   NE     11.48       8.12       0.90       7.73       0.88       7.59       NA       130.79       15.86       118.77       12.66       181.70       16.19       1.84       2.76       42.55  

CZFS

  Citizens Financial Services, Inc.   MA     11.35       8.72       1.29       11.42       1.30       11.50       1.32       60.78       8.30       95.04       10.79       127.42       8.24       2.04       3.07       24.54  

CHCO

  City Holding Company   SE     11.75       9.65       1.98       16.67       2.01       16.92       0.17       178.03       14.00       225.81       26.54       281.61       13.79       3.48       2.75       38.33  

CIVB

  Civista Bancshares, Inc.   MW     12.85       9.91       1.21       10.45       1.33       11.48       0.68       137.88       9.87       101.05       12.98       135.42       8.99       0.72       2.71       25.74  

CCNE

  CNB Financial Corporation   MA     10.44       9.15       1.07       10.36       1.17       11.35       0.58       145.33       11.44       114.63       11.27       134.19       10.44       0.76       2.38       26.33  

CCB

  Coastal Financial Corporation   WE     8.89       8.82       1.06       10.36       1.12       10.94       0.57       531.84       22.46       216.78       19.28       218.70       21.27       NA       NA       NM  

COSO

  CoastalSouth Bancshares, Inc.   SE     11.20       11.01       1.16       10.75       1.16       10.80       0.62       129.60       12.04       120.71       13.51       123.03       11.98       0.20       0.76       4.55  

CBAN

  Colony Bankcorp, Inc.   SE     10.22       8.39       0.90       9.25       1.07       11.04       0.47       139.25       12.85       114.38       11.69       142.18       10.77       0.48       2.34       29.38  

COLB

  Columbia Banking System, Inc.   WE     11.61       8.63       1.08       9.69       1.46       13.05       0.23       312.24       12.17       115.41       13.40       160.54       9.01       1.48       4.84       58.57  

CBSH

  Commerce Bancshares, Inc.   MW     12.11       11.14       1.79       15.24       1.76       15.25       0.03       NM       13.46       185.72       22.38       204.25       13.69       1.10       2.01       26.41  

CBK

  Commercial Bancgroup, Inc.   SE     12.60       12.14       1.70       14.98       1.81       16.00       0.28       312.73       10.70       146.35       18.45       152.80       10.03       0.40       1.29       6.83  

CMTV

  Community Bancorp   NE     9.46       8.60       1.46       16.16       1.35       14.89       NA       NA       13.01       197.58       18.69       219.30       14.13       1.00       2.52       31.23  

CBU

  Community Financial System, Inc.   MA     11.41       6.43       1.28       11.34       1.38       12.20       0.31       191.48       15.13       161.82       18.46       303.07       14.06       1.88       3.07       45.63  

CTBI

  Community Trust Bancorp, Inc.   MW     12.92       12.07       1.58       12.34       1.59       12.39       0.21       583.23       11.97       142.43       18.41       154.01       11.93       2.12       3.11       37.13  

CWBC

  Community West Bancshares   WE     11.32       8.74       1.14       10.43       1.18       10.75       0.62       131.45       11.66       115.28       13.05       153.73       11.31       0.48       1.91       22.22  

CNOB

  ConnectOne Bancorp, Inc.   MA     11.20       9.43       0.74       6.52       0.96       8.45       0.29       368.11       18.76       110.21       11.57       135.61       13.49       0.78       2.42       42.49  

CFR

  Cullen/Frost Bankers, Inc.   SW     8.59       7.38       1.28       15.19       1.29       15.27       0.14       395.60       14.18       208.59       17.40       247.74       14.11       4.12       2.83       39.24  

CUBI

  Customers Bancorp, Inc.   MA     8.29       8.27       1.17       13.79       1.18       13.89       0.29       336.61       9.62       119.09       9.87       119.29       9.54       NA       NA       NM  

CVBF

  CVB Financial Corp.   WE     14.97       10.52       1.35       9.15       1.41       9.55       0.04       NM       13.60       121.74       18.22       182.25       13.03       0.80       3.89       52.29  

DCOM

  Dime Commercial Bancshares, Inc.   MA     9.98       9.02       0.85       8.43       NA       NA       0.64       105.82       14.66       124.47       11.54       140.62       NA       1.00       2.58       37.59  

EBMT

  Eagle Bancorp Montana, Inc.   WE     9.22       7.55       0.74       8.33       0.76       8.54       0.11       748.71       11.57       94.57       8.72       117.60       11.29       0.58       2.54       29.29  

EGBN

  Eagle Bancorp, Inc.   MA     11.51       11.51       -1.07       -10.59       -0.88       -8.68       1.31       114.29       NM       73.49       8.46       73.49       NM       0.04       0.15       NM  

EFSI

  Eagle Financial Services, Inc.   SE     10.35       10.35       0.98       10.29       0.96       10.07       0.80       117.78       11.86       118.70       12.29       118.70       12.11       1.24       3.01       35.23  

EWBC

  East West Bancorp, Inc.   WE     10.86       10.35       1.76       16.25       1.75       16.14       0.26       415.02       12.67       193.02       20.96       203.55       12.76       3.20       2.51       27.97  

EBC

  Eastern Bankshares, Inc.   NE     13.99       10.21       1.35       9.35       1.65       11.46       0.45       238.18       11.57       111.65       15.62       159.68       9.51       0.60       2.98       30.34  

ECBK

  ECB Bancorp, Inc.   NE     10.66       10.66       0.62       5.61       0.62       5.61       NA       846.50       17.66       101.28       10.80       101.28       17.66       NA       NA       NM  

EFSC

  Enterprise Financial Services Corp   MW     11.74       9.44       1.21       10.08       1.09       9.10       0.84       234.59       11.72       116.50       13.24       150.09       13.01       1.36       2.19       24.53  


Exhibit 1B

Weekly Bank and Thrift Market Line - Part Two

Prices As of June 18, 2026

 

            Key Financial Ratios     Asset Quality Ratios     Pricing Ratios     Dividend Data (6)  
            Equity/
Assets(1)
    Tang Equity/
Assets(1)
    Reported Earnings     Core Earnings     NPAs/
Assets
    Rsvs/
NPLs
    Price/
Earnings
    Price/
Book
    Price/
Assets
    Price/
Tang Book
    Price/
Core Earnings
    Div/
Share
    Dividend
Yield
    Payout
Ratio (7)
 
        ROA(5)     ROE(5)     ROA(5)     ROE(5)  
            (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)     ($)     (%)     (%)  

Companies

                                                                                                   

EQBK

  Equity Bancshares, Inc.   MW     10.66       8.99       0.40       3.39       1.34       11.43       0.72       122.51       36.98       118.41       12.63       143.11       10.85       0.72       1.55       57.14  

ESQ

  Esquire Financial Holdings, Inc.   MA     12.44       12.44       2.36       18.78       2.41       19.19       NA       NM       19.08       325.48       40.50       325.48       18.68       0.80       0.71       12.61  

FNB

  F.N.B. Corporation   MA     13.43       8.91       1.18       8.83       1.20       8.99       0.24       375.42       11.25       95.34       12.81       151.29       11.04       0.52       2.87       30.25  

FMAO

  Farmers & Merchants Bancorp, Inc.   MW     10.79       8.42       1.06       9.91       1.11       10.34       0.33       251.40       11.05       105.62       11.39       138.89       10.58       0.92       3.22       34.82  

FMNB

  Farmers National Banc Corp.   MW     10.69       6.68       1.07       11.98       1.25       13.96       0.85       91.77       9.75       109.14       11.66       182.57       8.40       0.68       4.85       46.90  

FBLA

  FB Bancorp, Inc.   SW     23.53       23.53       0.05       0.21       0.23       0.89       1.30       42.30       NM       82.81       19.49       82.81       82.99       NA       NA       NM  

FBK

  FB Financial Corporation   SE     11.99       9.91       0.92       7.53       1.39       11.44       0.62       201.89       20.21       140.02       16.78       173.37       13.03       0.84       1.58       30.08  

FDBC

  Fidelity D & D Bancorp, Inc.   MA     8.56       7.91       1.08       13.03       1.11       13.38       0.08       864.66       9.70       117.86       10.08       128.45       9.44       1.72       3.61       33.01  

FDSB

  Fifth District Bancorp, Inc.   SW     24.14       24.14       0.82       3.38       0.31       1.27       0.02       NM       18.38       65.41       15.79       65.41       47.71       NA       NA       NM  

FITB

  Fifth Third Bancorp   MW     11.48       8.01       0.96       9.29       1.21       11.64       0.37       274.88       17.70       149.65       16.20       230.51       14.57       1.60       3.04       53.69  

FISI

  Financial Institutions, Inc.   MA     10.03       9.17       1.27       12.77       1.25       12.57       0.60       119.05       9.73       119.71       11.72       132.73       9.89       1.28       3.46       32.81  

FNWD

  Finward Bancorp   MW     8.56       7.48       0.48       6.00       0.54       6.76       0.71       139.72       14.93       85.88       7.35       99.42       13.26       0.48       1.42       20.96  

FINW

  FinWise Bancorp   SW     21.86       21.53       1.75       8.37       1.84       8.80       NA       164.09       12.89       98.86       21.61       100.77       12.24       NA       NA       NM  

FBNC

  First Bancorp   SE     13.00       9.54       0.96       7.56       1.41       11.13       0.32       303.99       20.74       149.38       19.42       211.57       14.09       0.96       1.59       32.08  

FBP

  First BanCorp.   MA     10.31       10.11       1.87       18.72       1.87       18.67       0.57       279.29       11.20       198.16       20.42       202.47       11.23       0.80       3.21       33.78  

FRBA

  First Bank   MA     11.32       10.17       1.05       9.65       1.10       10.10       0.66       175.47       9.98       92.97       10.52       104.84       9.53       0.36       2.19       17.96  

BUSE

  First Busey Corporation   MW     13.38       11.02       1.16       8.92       1.41       10.85       0.24       420.70       12.55       109.83       13.54       140.32       10.18       1.04       3.68       45.33  

FCAP

  First Capital, Inc.   MW     10.76       10.31       1.41       13.43       1.39       13.23       0.31       257.71       12.05       152.69       16.41       160.20       12.18       1.24       1.96       23.71  

FCBM

  First Carolina Financial Services, Inc.   SE     10.34       8.47       0.39       3.87       0.46       4.58       0.65       94.54       11.56       43.89       4.54       54.67       9.78       NA       NA       NM  

FCNC.A

  First Citizens BancShares, Inc.   SE     9.34       9.14       0.98       10.09       1.02       10.56       0.65       110.50       11.91       119.39       10.34       122.58       11.37       8.40       0.41       4.74  

FCF

  First Commonwealth Financial Corporation   MA     12.66       9.73       1.29       10.25       1.35       10.70       0.54       201.05       12.93       127.89       16.19       172.06       12.38       0.56       2.89       36.09  

FCBC

  First Community Bankshares, Inc.   SE     14.30       10.25       1.49       9.58       1.67       10.73       0.48       189.81       16.38       157.07       22.47       229.48       14.64       1.24       2.88       84.53  

FCCO

  First Community Corporation   SE     9.23       8.00       0.97       12.00       1.08       13.31       0.02       NM       12.38       134.32       12.40       157.24       11.22       0.64       2.05       25.10  

FFBC

  First Financial Bancorp.   MW     12.91       7.97       1.40       10.39       1.57       11.63       0.44       182.73       11.17       112.80       14.56       193.12       9.99       1.00       3.18       35.34  

FFIN

  First Financial Bankshares, Inc.   SW     12.63       10.81       1.79       14.54       1.79       14.55       0.35       207.02       17.82       241.62       30.52       288.10       17.80       0.88       2.70       42.93  

THFF

  First Financial Corporation   MW     10.69       8.93       1.42       12.99       1.57       14.32       0.47       182.62       10.75       132.60       14.18       161.92       9.75       2.24       3.07       32.21  

FGBI

  First Guaranty Bancshares, Inc.   SW     5.66       5.61       -1.18       -19.50       -0.91       -15.05       2.00       76.75       NM       88.98       4.33       90.02       NM       0.04       0.38       NM  

FHB

  First Hawaiian, Inc.   WE     11.41       7.62       1.19       10.43       1.18       10.35       0.16       426.71       12.25       122.76       14.00       191.71       12.35       1.04       3.75       45.61  

FHN

  First Horizon Corporation   SE     11.25       9.52       1.26       11.37       1.26       11.73       0.73       118.70       12.41       140.02       14.20       173.01       12.42       0.68       2.75       32.00  

INBK

  First Internet Bancorp   MW     6.32       5.98       -0.58       -8.84       -0.06       -0.89       0.69       150.89       NM       62.26       3.93       65.97       NM       0.24       0.95       NM  

FIBK

  First Interstate BancSystem, Inc.   WE     12.71       8.63       1.15       9.06       1.03       8.15       0.61       126.49       11.87       105.70       13.43       162.86       13.21       1.88       5.27       61.24  

FRME

  First Merchants Corporation   MW     12.68       9.13       1.04       8.10       1.26       9.86       0.43       237.21       11.98       96.14       12.09       139.63       9.92       1.48       3.65       42.65  

FMBH

  First Mid Bancshares, Inc.   MW     11.59       8.91       1.22       10.27       1.38       11.66       0.52       201.00       11.55       113.35       13.14       151.86       10.18       1.00       2.18       25.19  

FXNC

  First National Corporation   SE     9.08       8.39       1.03       11.65       1.06       11.99       0.21       330.66       12.60       140.77       12.79       153.66       12.25       0.68       2.34       28.54  

FNRN

  First Northern Community Bancorp   WE     11.11       10.92       1.23       11.59       1.27       11.96       0.27       371.37       13.00       141.23       15.69       143.97       12.60       NA       NA       NM  

FNWB

  First Northwest Bancorp   WE     7.36       7.31       0.23       3.15       0.40       5.47       1.08       77.53       18.24       60.70       4.47       61.11       10.92       0.00       0.00       NM  

FUNC

  First United Corporation   MA     10.07       9.56       1.24       12.76       1.25       12.86       0.42       424.94       10.89       133.73       13.46       141.57       10.80       1.04       2.44       32.23  

FUSB

  First US Bancshares, Inc.   SE     8.98       8.40       0.54       5.94       NA       NA       0.19       646.78       15.87       88.37       7.94       95.13       NA       0.28       1.70       26.92  

MYFW

  First Western Financial, Inc.   SW     8.44       7.54       0.50       5.83       0.50       5.89       0.50       127.53       19.71       108.73       9.17       122.82       19.50       NA       NA       NM  

FSBC

  Five Star Bancorp   WE     9.11       9.11       1.47       15.58       1.48       15.76       0.06       NM       14.24       209.18       19.06       209.18       14.08       1.00       2.26       28.57  

FLG

  Flagstar Bank, National Association   MA     9.32       8.95       -0.06       -0.69       0.11       1.29       3.08       35.66       NM       80.16       7.05       84.09       88.14       0.04       0.27       NM  

FRBT

  Forbright, Inc.   MA     10.10       9.75       NA       NA       NA       NA       1.11       62.62       NA       88.46       8.93       91.93       NA       NA       NA       NA  

FRAF

  Franklin Financial Services Corporation   MA     7.78       7.42       1.06       14.54       1.04       14.35       0.37       244.42       11.51       154.46       12.02       162.67       11.65       1.36       2.26       24.91  

FSBW

  FS Bancorp, Inc.   WE     9.80       9.42       1.04       10.76       1.10       11.32       0.57       177.59       9.72       99.65       9.76       104.08       9.23       1.16       2.82       31.70  

FULT

  Fulton Financial Corporation   MA     10.87       9.15       1.23       11.51       1.30       12.17       0.45       258.73       10.90       123.64       12.78       151.54       10.29       0.76       3.35       35.71  

FVCB

  FVCBankcorp, Inc.   SE     11.15       10.87       1.04       9.32       1.04       9.33       0.47       175.24       12.99       114.95       12.81       118.25       12.98       0.28       1.71       19.53  

GBFH

  GBank Financial Holdings Inc.   WE     12.03       12.03       1.38       11.08       1.45       11.65       0.95       122.40       24.04       255.27       30.70       255.27       22.86       NA       NA       NM  

GABC

  German American Bancorp, Inc.   MW     14.01       9.63       1.61       12.15       1.71       12.92       0.35       265.76       12.46       143.89       20.16       220.11       11.72       1.24       2.77       33.24  

GBCI

  Glacier Bancorp, Inc.   WE     13.39       9.15       0.88       6.89       0.99       7.79       0.17       478.88       22.63       148.33       19.86       227.53       20.04       1.32       2.74       61.68  

GSBC

  Great Southern Bancorp, Inc.   MW     11.14       10.99       1.24       11.27       1.23       11.19       0.18       NM       11.76       127.39       14.19       129.34       11.85       1.72       2.34       33.60  

HWC

  Hancock Whitney Corporation   SE     12.43       9.93       1.18       9.45       1.44       11.52       0.35       274.67       14.42       128.97       16.04       166.20       11.78       2.00       2.87       39.01  

HAFC

  Hanmi Financial Corporation   WE     10.24       10.09       1.04       9.81       1.02       9.65       0.16       567.38       11.65       115.88       11.87       117.78       11.83       1.12       3.64       41.04  

HNVR

  Hanover Bancorp, Inc.   MA     8.50       7.74       0.35       3.89       0.42       4.72       0.78       107.89       22.17       84.83       7.04       94.10       17.86       0.40       1.72       38.10  

HWBK

  Hawthorn Bancshares, Inc.   MW     9.45       9.45       1.31       14.60       1.30       14.54       0.37       308.61       11.21       153.76       14.53       153.76       11.26       0.84       2.15       23.50  

HBT

  HBT Financial, Inc.   MW     11.03       9.31       1.32       11.33       1.64       13.99       0.18       552.88       13.90       147.49       16.27       178.10       11.32       0.92       3.08       40.37  

HFWA

  Heritage Financial Corporation   WE     13.13       9.63       1.00       7.78       1.17       9.10       0.14       562.85       13.69       103.23       13.55       146.45       11.73       0.96       3.49       47.06  

HTH

  Hilltop Holdings Inc.   SW     13.84       12.32       1.07       7.57       NA       NA       0.44       145.88       14.34       103.35       14.14       118.42       NA       0.80       2.14       28.79  

HIFS

  Hingham Institution for Savings   NE     10.61       10.61       1.12       10.78       0.81       7.80       0.87       76.03       12.48       129.35       13.73       129.35       17.25       2.52       0.89       14.12  

HBCP

  Home Bancorp, Inc.   SW     12.50       10.39       1.33       10.97       1.37       11.32       1.12       94.09       11.14       116.83       14.61       143.95       10.80       1.24       1.89       20.50  

HOMB

  Home BancShares, Inc.   SE     18.75       13.42       2.10       11.44       2.09       11.41       0.94       170.02       11.38       124.85       23.40       185.91       11.41       0.84       3.06       34.16  

HFBL

  Home Federal Bancorp, Inc. of Louisiana   SW     9.04       8.51       0.96       10.45       0.99       10.81       0.61       152.73       10.57       107.09       9.68       114.42       10.22       0.54       2.77       28.13  

HTB

  HomeTrust Bancshares, Inc.   SE     13.51       12.74       1.51       11.25       1.51       11.26       0.70       133.62       12.52       137.42       18.56       147.00       12.51       0.60       1.26       13.70  

HOPE

  Hope Bancorp, Inc.   WE     12.24       9.67       0.36       2.96       0.62       5.09       0.59       141.64       24.69       71.88       8.80       93.64       14.29       0.56       4.39       107.69  

HBNC

  Horizon Bancorp, Inc.   MW     10.65       8.39       -2.12       -20.39       1.51       14.57       0.59       160.81       NM       141.26       15.04       183.77       8.83       0.64       3.32       NM  

HYNE

  Hoyne Bancorp, Inc.   MW     33.75       33.74       0.06       0.24       0.41       1.64       0.28       459.54       NA       83.39       28.15       83.44       NA       NA       NA       NA  

HBAN

  Huntington Bancshares Incorporated   MW     11.42       8.03       0.99       9.28       1.15       10.86       0.29       403.50       12.97       115.25       12.10       178.61       11.16       0.62       3.68       47.69  

INDB

  Independent Bank Corp.   NE     14.29       9.86       1.02       6.98       1.23       8.39       0.40       197.77       16.08       111.14       15.88       169.34       13.46       2.56       3.16       60.52  

IBCP

  Independent Bank Corporation   MW     9.19       8.71       1.28       14.34       1.32       14.79       0.51       231.09       10.24       138.34       12.71       146.73       9.93       1.12       3.27       32.24  

IBOC

  International Bancshares Corporation   SW     19.62       18.25       2.53       13.36       2.53       13.37       1.06       100.26       10.98       139.11       27.21       152.19       11.02       1.46       1.98       21.34  

ISTR

  Investar Holding Corporation   SW     10.70       9.01       0.93       9.07       1.00       9.77       0.61       177.00       13.09       106.70       10.66       131.36       12.22       0.48       1.65       24.56  

ISBA

  Isabella Bank Corporation   MW     10.39       8.43       0.91       8.76       0.93       8.92       0.22       317.20       14.87       126.35       13.13       159.20       14.61       1.12       2.80       41.33  

JMSB

  John Marshall Bancorp, Inc.   SE     11.40       11.40       0.98       8.62       0.97       8.51       0.04       NM       13.40       112.15       12.78       112.15       13.58       0.36       1.69       11.32  

JPM

  JPMorgan Chase & Co.   MA     7.43       6.37       1.29       16.50       1.29       16.47       0.21       270.56       15.58       253.33       17.86       301.75       15.61       6.00       1.80       28.74  

KRNY

  Kearny Financial Corp.   MA     10.03       8.65       0.47       4.78       0.46       4.67       0.69       85.38       14.86       71.86       7.21       84.57       15.18       0.44       5.24       77.19  

KEY

  KeyCorp   MW     10.59       9.27       1.04       9.77       1.04       9.74       0.37       212.46       13.86       140.46       13.19       166.75       13.89       0.82       3.63       50.31  

LSBK

  Lake Shore Bancorp, Inc.   MA     19.72       19.72       1.13       6.45       1.11       6.37       0.22       302.78       15.96       96.10       18.95       96.10       16.14       0.36       2.19       33.03  

LKFN

  Lakeland Financial Corporation   MW     10.57       10.51       1.58       14.89       1.57       14.88       0.30       329.07       14.02       199.26       21.07       200.59       14.06       2.08       3.46       47.78  

LARK

  Landmark Bancorp, Inc.   MW     10.06       8.11       1.19       12.44       1.25       13.01       0.65       121.50       9.40       110.83       11.15       140.61       8.99       0.84       2.89       26.25  

LCNB

  LCNB Corp.   MW     12.33       8.35       1.02       8.53       1.06       8.91       0.14       424.91       10.68       88.79       10.94       136.96       10.22       0.88       5.25       54.66  

LC

  LendingClub Corporation   WE     12.76       11.65       1.59       12.14       1.62       12.31       0.25       812.56       12.89       145.63       18.58       161.49       12.72       NA       NA       NM  

LOB

  Live Oak Bancshares, Inc.   SE     8.38       NA       0.87       10.55       0.75       9.13       0.79       165.49       14.66       149.76       11.64       157.60       17.11       0.12       0.32       4.60  

MTB

  M&T Bank Corporation   MA     13.03       9.43       1.38       10.21       1.36       10.03       0.55       184.94       12.60       129.51       15.58       194.35       12.84       6.00       2.66       33.59  

MGYR

  Magyar Bancorp, Inc.   MA     11.62       11.58       1.08       9.44       1.08       9.44       0.03       NM       10.20       94.57       10.99       94.98       10.20       0.40       2.20       20.22  

MNSB

  MainStreet Bancshares, Inc.   SE     9.67       9.67       0.80       8.01       0.86       8.55       2.47       35.44       11.99       93.09       7.96       93.09       11.13       0.40       1.70       20.10  

MBBC

  Marathon Bancorp, Inc.   MW     19.09       19.09       0.45       2.84       0.45       2.84       0.48       899.47       35.70       95.02       18.14       95.02       35.70       NA       NA       NM  

MCHB

  Mechanics Bancorp   WE     13.05       8.57       1.28       9.56       1.07       8.05       0.23       353.31       12.86       121.54       15.86       194.67       15.21       2.80       19.11       114.88  

MBWM

  Mercantile Bank Corporation   MW     10.61       9.41       1.44       13.81       1.50       14.35       0.11       752.17       9.65       125.99       13.37       143.93       9.30       1.56       2.93       27.65  

MBIN

  Merchants Bancorp   MW     11.47       11.43       1.19       10.12       1.19       10.12       1.47       32.13       11.97       126.75       11.41       127.33       11.97       0.44       0.90       10.24  


Exhibit 1B

Weekly Bank and Thrift Market Line - Part Two

Prices As of June 18, 2026

 

            Key Financial Ratios     Asset Quality Ratios     Pricing Ratios     Dividend Data (6)  
            Equity/
Assets(1)
    Tang Equity/
Assets(1)
    Reported Earnings     Core Earnings     NPAs/
Assets
    Rsvs/
NPLs
    Price/
Earnings
    Price/
Book
    Price/
Assets
    Price/
Tang Book
    Price/
Core Earnings
    Div/
Share
    Dividend
Yield
    Payout
Ratio (7)
 
        ROA(5)     ROE(5)     ROA(5)     ROE(5)  
            (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)     ($)     (%)     (%)  

Companies

                                                                                                   

MRBK

  Meridian Corporation   MA     7.77       7.52       0.84       11.35       0.83       11.23       2.01       46.44       10.41       114.21       8.88       118.36       10.52       0.56       2.91       28.65  

MCBS

  MetroCity Bankshares, Inc.   SE     11.82       10.30       1.88       16.29       2.00       17.40       0.38       158.70       12.34       176.72       20.89       206.37       11.56       1.16       3.39       37.55  

MCB

  Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp.   MA     10.72       10.62       1.06       11.42       1.05       11.35       0.80       115.51       11.47       121.67       13.05       122.93       11.54       1.00       1.07       9.24  

MPB

  Mid Penn Bancorp, Inc.   MA     12.74       10.29       0.82       6.60       1.09       8.80       0.55       138.68       15.25       95.61       12.18       121.68       11.36       0.88       2.66       41.36  

MSBI

  Midland States Bancorp, Inc.   MW     8.54       8.31       0.52       6.11       0.84       9.97       0.83       125.33       24.94       136.61       9.52       141.79       13.45       1.28       4.40       108.47  

MVBF

  MVB Financial Corp.   SE     10.08       10.03       0.87       8.96       -0.12       -1.21       1.06       65.07       12.67       105.98       10.68       106.62       NM       0.68       2.50       31.19  

NBHC

  National Bank Holdings Corporation   SW     13.20       9.47       1.02       7.34       1.23       8.88       0.27       378.38       15.98       114.95       15.17       167.04       13.32       1.28       3.05       46.64  

NKSH

  National Bankshares, Inc.   SE     10.25       9.65       0.97       9.95       1.08       11.02       0.02       NM       12.84       119.96       12.29       128.26       11.58       1.50       4.25       55.64  

NBBK

  NB Bancorp, Inc.   NE     11.66       11.21       0.89       6.71       1.14       8.62       0.63       176.01       14.69       106.92       12.47       111.82       11.56       0.28       1.39       20.44  

NBTB

  NBT Bancorp Inc.   MA     11.81       8.96       1.16       10.06       1.31       11.39       0.36       239.37       13.30       126.82       14.98       172.58       11.73       1.48       3.19       42.17  

NEWT

  NewtekOne, Inc.   SE     14.02       13.58       2.69       17.94       -0.14       -0.94       5.93       29.54       6.13       112.55       14.14       117.34       NM       0.76       5.58       33.48  

NIC

  Nicolet Bankshares, Inc.   MW     14.49       8.80       1.35       9.86       NA       NA       0.39       242.48       17.22       139.77       20.25       245.62       NA       1.44       1.00       15.47  

NBN

  Northeast Bank   NE     11.28       11.27       2.21       18.91       2.21       18.90       0.78       200.02       10.84       190.64       21.50       190.70       10.84       0.04       0.03       0.34  

NECB

  Northeast Community Bancorp, Inc.   MA     17.59       17.59       2.18       12.65       2.17       12.61       0.00       NM       7.99       99.81       17.56       99.81       8.02       1.00       3.89       38.82  

NTRS

  Northern Trust Corporation   MW     7.44       7.03       1.19       14.71       1.19       14.77       0.03       308.55       18.02       263.16       18.34       280.99       17.91       3.20       1.86       33.51  

NPB

  Northpointe Bancshares, Inc.   MW     7.98       7.96       1.32       14.49       1.33       14.56       0.79       17.67       8.04       108.97       8.35       109.24       8.00       0.10       0.56       4.50  

NRIM

  Northrim BanCorp, Inc.   WE     10.01       8.56       2.00       20.80       1.70       17.71       0.45       174.56       8.75       167.00       16.72       198.42       10.27       0.64       2.56       22.20  

NWBI

  Northwest Bancshares, Inc.   MW     11.26       8.66       0.84       7.39       1.08       9.54       0.54       164.99       15.57       111.25       12.53       148.92       12.22       0.80       5.57       86.02  

NWFL

  Norwood Financial Corp.   MA     9.73       8.49       1.03       10.49       1.22       12.48       0.38       236.75       11.31       118.02       11.49       137.19       9.64       1.28       4.16       58.09  

OVLY

  Oak Valley Bancorp   WE     10.25       10.11       1.21       12.21       1.21       12.13       0.23       282.25       11.82       138.88       14.24       141.15       11.89       0.75       2.23       23.44  

OCFC

  OceanFirst Financial Corp.   MA     11.47       8.15       0.50       4.19       0.63       5.31       0.31       248.60       15.41       62.21       7.13       90.81       12.10       0.80       4.44       68.38  

OFG

  OFG Bancorp   MA     11.35       10.66       1.75       15.58       1.78       15.85       1.01       176.75       9.64       144.25       16.37       154.79       9.48       1.40       3.01       26.86  

OVBC

  Ohio Valley Banc Corp.   MW     10.21       9.82       0.99       9.40       1.18       11.20       1.11       69.25       14.67       132.32       13.51       138.23       12.31       1.00       2.08       28.66  

ONB

  Old National Bancorp   MW     11.66       8.02       1.08       9.32       1.34       11.58       0.71       112.19       12.78       115.89       13.17       178.06       10.24       0.58       2.34       29.38  

OSBC

  Old Second Bancorp, Inc.   MW     13.04       11.07       1.30       10.28       1.52       12.09       0.94       115.15       13.03       126.61       16.51       152.51       11.14       0.28       1.28       16.07  

OPBK

  OP Bancorp   WE     8.62       NA       1.05       12.36       1.05       12.35       0.68       155.25       7.89       91.91       7.93       NA       7.90       0.56       3.90       27.47  

OPHC

  OptimumBank Holdings, Inc.   SE     10.00       10.00       1.62       14.89       1.62       14.89       0.10       843.06       7.91       79.59       5.78       79.59       7.91       NA       NA       NM  

OBT

  Orange County Bancorp, Inc.   MA     10.78       10.59       1.68       16.93       1.53       15.45       0.96       106.76       10.95       171.14       18.45       174.63       12.04       0.72       1.93       19.71  

OBK

  Origin Bancorp, Inc.   SW     12.37       10.97       0.82       6.54       0.95       7.58       0.87       113.46       19.13       120.94       14.96       138.60       16.49       1.00       2.05       27.13  

ORRF

  Orrstown Financial Services, Inc.   MA     10.82       9.10       1.55       14.94       1.66       16.04       0.56       158.08       8.93       126.90       13.72       153.80       8.32       1.20       3.07       26.09  

PRK

  Park National Corporation   MW     13.11       11.03       1.70       12.98       1.87       14.30       0.81       134.81       16.19       188.03       24.62       228.75       14.77       4.40       2.54       51.24  

PKBK

  Parke Bancorp, Inc.   MA     15.16       15.16       1.93       13.10       1.93       13.10       0.55       371.26       9.10       111.49       16.89       111.49       9.10       0.80       2.51       21.14  

PBHC

  Pathfinder Bancorp, Inc.   MA     8.69       8.03       -0.17       -1.98       0.00       0.00       2.69       75.91       NM       85.41       7.42       93.14       162.75       0.40       2.37       NM  

CASH

  Pathward Financial, Inc.   MW     11.96       7.97       2.51       23.05       2.54       22.87       NA       107.47       9.74       205.52       24.60       322.44       9.62       0.20       0.25       2.38  

PNBK

  Patriot National Bancorp, Inc.   NE     7.67       7.61       -1.14       -14.28       -1.13       -14.09       1.94       34.01       NM       138.88       10.65       139.93       NM       0.00       0.00       NM  

PCB

  PCB Bancorp   WE     11.68       11.66       1.22       10.52       1.22       10.55       0.27       365.92       9.64       116.43       11.46       116.72       9.62       0.88       3.28       30.22  

PGC

  Peapack-Gladstone Financial Corporation   MA     9.08       8.55       0.60       6.85       0.59       6.82       0.77       112.99       18.04       118.42       10.33       126.92       18.11       0.20       0.45       8.06  

PEBO

  Peoples Bancorp Inc.   MW     12.60       8.92       1.17       9.43       1.27       10.23       0.38       213.52       11.61       107.04       13.49       157.70       10.71       1.68       4.70       52.88  

PEBK

  Peoples Bancorp of North Carolina, Inc.   SE     9.12       9.12       1.16       13.52       1.05       12.24       0.28       215.81       11.69       146.61       13.36       146.61       12.92       0.84       1.98       27.27  

PFIS

  Peoples Financial Services Corp.   MA     9.69       7.96       1.15       11.53       1.28       12.79       0.26       346.12       10.64       118.56       11.49       147.17       9.59       2.50       4.02       42.48  

PNFP

  Pinnacle Financial Partners, Inc.   SE     11.89       8.48       0.91       7.47       1.27       10.48       0.40       205.23       13.33       105.14       11.91       157.10       10.69       2.00       2.09       20.53  

PLBC

  Plumas Bancorp   WE     12.06       10.65       1.54       13.56       1.69       14.88       0.65       136.84       11.77       146.02       17.61       168.00       10.74       1.32       2.38       26.69  

PDLB

  Ponce Financial Group, Inc.   MA     16.70       16.70       0.99       5.89       0.96       5.70       0.72       111.04       14.86       143.19       15.19       143.19       15.38       NA       NA       NM  

BPOP

  Popular, Inc.   MA     8.29       7.32       1.19       12.46       1.15       12.09       0.66       179.81       11.76       163.71       13.53       187.39       12.13       3.00       1.89       22.16  

PFBC

  Preferred Bank   WE     10.06       10.06       1.82       17.41       1.82       17.40       2.25       44.39       9.23       152.27       15.32       152.35       9.24       3.20       3.23       36.35  

FRST

  Primis Financial Corp.   SE     10.04       8.02       1.18       11.64       0.33       3.28       1.92       56.82       8.22       89.59       8.99       114.69       29.00       0.40       2.63       21.28  

BPRN

  Princeton Bancorp, Inc.   MA     12.14       11.47       0.86       7.29       0.89       7.60       0.73       121.57       13.41       95.26       11.56       101.56       12.85       1.40       3.78       47.20  

PB

  Prosperity Bancshares, Inc.   SW     18.82       10.77       1.35       6.81       1.46       7.37       0.27       368.48       12.90       87.46       16.46       167.94       11.95       2.40       3.39       43.12  

PROV

  Provident Financial Holdings, Inc.   WE     10.40       10.40       0.50       4.71       0.52       4.90       0.08       606.75       18.30       84.13       8.75       84.13       17.58       0.56       3.33       60.87  

PFS

  Provident Financial Services, Inc.   MA     11.36       8.56       1.24       11.04       1.36       12.04       0.58       123.84       9.67       103.42       11.75       141.64       8.86       0.96       4.25       40.85  

QCRH

  QCR Holdings, Inc.   MW     11.68       10.31       1.43       12.34       1.47       12.68       0.44       206.88       11.90       139.56       16.29       160.45       11.57       0.40       0.42       4.01  

RBB

  RBB Bancorp   WE     12.66       11.09       0.99       7.89       0.91       7.23       1.16       97.98       10.80       81.93       10.37       95.19       11.74       0.64       2.51       27.12  

RRBI

  Red River Bancshares, Inc.   SW     11.16       11.11       1.36       12.62       1.36       12.54       0.13       596.36       13.29       156.45       17.45       157.10       13.38       1.00       1.13       11.98  

RF

  Regions Financial Corporation   SE     11.72       8.38       1.40       11.82       1.42       12.00       0.44       220.35       11.93       140.20       15.32       211.44       11.77       1.06       3.70       44.17  

RNST

  Renasant Corporation   SE     14.27       9.08       0.86       5.97       1.11       7.68       0.78       149.79       17.30       100.14       14.28       166.77       13.52       0.96       2.33       38.17  

RBCA.A

  Republic Bancorp, Inc.   MW     15.63       15.14       1.79       11.59       1.75       11.36       0.45       288.95       13.08       146.69       22.92       152.33       13.34       1.98       2.34       29.20  

RMBI

  Richmond Mutual Bancorporation, Inc.   MW     9.54       9.54       0.82       8.93       0.88       9.63       1.05       105.37       11.80       106.89       10.20       106.89       10.94       0.60       4.07       48.00  

RVSB

  Riverview Bancorp, Inc.   WE     9.95       8.25       -0.29       -2.65       0.31       2.87       0.53       196.39       NM       81.90       8.15       100.67       25.51       0.08       1.38       NM  

STBA

  S&T Bancorp, Inc.   MA     14.39       11.03       1.39       9.32       1.39       9.35       0.50       186.73       13.12       118.71       17.08       160.96       13.08       1.48       3.16       40.06  

SBFG

  SB Financial Group, Inc.   MW     8.95       7.28       1.05       11.71       1.06       11.83       0.30       432.17       9.02       100.67       9.01       126.05       8.94       0.64       2.78       24.31  

SBCF

  Seacoast Banking Corporation of Florida   SE     14.48       9.36       0.78       5.40       1.25       8.96       0.47       185.47       20.29       110.83       14.48       197.51       12.73       0.76       2.46       49.34  

SFBS

  ServisFirst Bancshares, Inc.   SE     10.53       10.46       1.67       16.63       1.73       17.18       0.99       98.47       14.85       230.03       24.20       231.68       14.34       1.52       1.91       27.21  

SHBI

  Shore Bancshares, Inc.   MA     9.71       8.37       1.03       10.86       1.13       11.90       1.10       90.03       11.68       121.88       11.84       143.56       10.66       0.56       2.55       26.60  

BSRR

  Sierra Bancorp   WE     9.69       9.02       1.24       12.73       1.24       12.69       0.28       204.13       11.52       142.23       13.78       153.80       11.55       1.04       2.63       29.74  

SFNC

  Simmons First National Corporation   SE     13.92       8.74       -1.44       -10.48       1.12       8.15       0.62       162.79       NM       92.41       12.87       156.06       10.91       0.86       3.96       NM  

SMBK

  SmartFinancial, Inc.   SE     9.52       8.04       0.94       9.85       0.98       10.31       0.25       358.57       14.31       135.83       12.92       163.42       13.67       0.36       0.81       10.58  

SFBC

  Sound Financial Bancorp, Inc.   WE     9.93       9.87       0.71       7.00       0.71       7.00       0.67       117.02       14.96       101.94       10.12       102.66       14.96       0.84       1.92       27.30  

SPFI

  South Plains Financial, Inc.   SW     10.87       10.48       1.37       12.78       1.40       13.11       0.10       NM       11.41       131.79       14.32       137.32       11.13       0.68       1.67       18.49  

SFST

  Southern First Bancshares, Inc.   SE     8.29       8.29       0.81       9.77       0.82       9.88       0.26       378.22       13.62       126.15       10.45       126.15       13.47       NA       NA       NM  

SMBC

  Southern Missouri Bancorp, Inc.   MW     11.15       9.95       1.33       12.12       1.40       12.72       0.62       185.62       12.11       139.27       15.53       158.17       11.53       1.00       1.38       16.69  

SBSI

  Southside Bancshares, Inc.   SW     9.71       7.59       0.85       8.52       1.16       11.74       0.11       480.83       14.25       117.04       11.37       153.26       10.38       1.44       4.34       61.02  

SSB

  SouthState Bank Corporation   SE     13.28       8.64       1.42       10.50       1.58       11.72       0.47       199.85       10.41       104.68       13.91       169.66       9.33       2.40       2.50       25.89  

SRBK

  SR Bancorp, Inc.   MA     16.13       14.19       0.42       2.38       0.40       2.28       0.00       NM       31.92       83.22       13.42       96.76       32.89       0.24       1.27       44.07  

STT

  State Street Corporation   NE     7.07       4.89       0.88       11.12       1.04       13.12       0.06       77.78       17.07       192.74       11.99       306.84       14.28       3.36       1.96       34.08  

SYBT

  Stock Yards Bancorp, Inc.   MW     11.65       9.69       1.55       13.86       1.58       14.10       0.11       889.78       15.06       195.84       22.82       240.66       14.81       1.28       1.77       26.34  

SSBI

  Summit State Bank   WE     10.31       10.07       0.59       5.94       0.59       5.95       3.41       49.14       15.26       89.57       9.23       91.98       15.23       0.00       0.00       NM  

TCBI

  Texas Capital Bancshares, Inc.   SW     10.77       10.77       1.12       9.84       1.14       9.98       0.50       163.10       13.32       130.86       13.04       130.92       13.12       0.80       0.81       2.69  

TCBS

  Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.   SW     12.60       12.60       0.70       6.27       0.69       6.24       2.60       176.35       16.31       94.59       11.92       94.59       16.39       0.24       1.35       21.10  

TBBK

  The Bancorp, Inc.   MA     7.04       7.03       2.56       29.90       2.54       29.71       1.35       86.57       10.93       337.35       23.75       337.72       11.00       NA       NA       NM  

BNY

  The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation   MA     8.06       4.74       1.34       13.51       1.35       13.73       0.01       359.09       17.80       249.88       17.74       495.18       17.68       2.12       1.45       26.27  

FNLC

  The First Bancorp, Inc.   NE     8.96       8.08       1.14       13.17       1.14       13.18       0.51       155.73       9.38       119.40       10.70       133.75       9.37       1.48       4.95       45.68  

PNC

  The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.   MA     10.56       8.41       1.26       12.28       1.26       12.26       0.40       207.89       13.48       161.54       15.62       214.08       13.49       6.80       2.92       39.51  

TCBX

  Third Coast Bancshares, Inc.   SW     9.88       9.12       1.30       12.93       1.37       13.69       0.57       176.08       10.02       110.51       9.91       121.98       9.44       NA       NA       NM  

TSBK

  Timberland Bancorp, Inc.   WE     13.25       12.59       1.55       11.81       1.51       11.53       0.47       198.28       10.88       122.90       16.28       130.27       11.14       1.16       2.73       28.64  

TMP

  Tompkins Financial Corporation   MA     10.89       10.14       2.00       20.00       1.01       10.09       0.59       113.34       7.65       135.75       14.78       147.06       15.15       2.68       3.05       22.37  

TOWN

  TowneBank   SE     12.96       9.28       0.86       6.90       1.26       10.20       0.23       608.43       16.69       110.87       14.34       161.52       11.35       1.12       3.23       86.06  

TCBK

  TriCo Bancshares   WE     13.31       10.53       1.30       9.82       1.32       9.90       0.75       189.04       13.01       123.88       16.49       161.51       12.90       1.44       2.83       36.46  

TFIN

  Triumph Financial, Inc.   SW     13.83       8.49       0.49       3.40       0.52       3.58       1.51       37.60       60.56       189.43       25.11       339.71       56.73       NA       NA       NM  


Exhibit 1B

Weekly Bank and Thrift Market Line - Part Two

Prices As of June 18, 2026

 

            Key Financial Ratios     Asset Quality Ratios     Pricing Ratios     Dividend Data (6)  
            Equity/
Assets(1)
    Tang Equity/
Assets(1)
    Reported Earnings     Core Earnings     NPAs/
Assets
    Rsvs/
NPLs
    Price/
Earnings
    Price/
Book
    Price/
Assets
    Price/
Tang Book
    Price/
Core Earnings
    Div/
Share
    Dividend
Yield
    Payout
Ratio (7)
 
        ROA(5)     ROE(5)     ROA(5)     ROE(5)  
            (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)     (%)     (%)     (%)     (x)     ($)     (%)     (%)  

Companies

                                                                                                   

TFC

  Truist Financial Corporation   SE     11.70       8.65       1.02       8.52       1.10       9.19       0.32       298.28       11.99       101.54       11.07       146.93       11.08       2.08       4.32       51.61  

TRST

  TrustCo Bank Corp NY   MA     10.31       10.30       0.99       9.17       0.99       9.17       0.35       246.89       15.32       136.31       14.05       136.43       15.32       1.52       2.91       44.57  

TRMK

  Trustmark Corporation   SE     11.21       9.62       1.21       10.79       1.22       10.80       0.55       165.87       11.82       123.11       13.81       146.07       11.80       1.00       2.24       25.93  

USB

  U.S. Bancorp   MW     9.45       7.57       1.15       12.24       1.21       13.02       0.22       513.84       12.19       153.25       13.03       202.17       11.51       2.08       3.59       54.09  

UMBF

  UMB Financial Corporation   MW     10.77       7.85       1.28       11.83       1.46       13.51       0.21       281.57       11.81       134.20       13.97       193.23       10.30       1.72       1.29       15.00  

UNB

  Union Bankshares, Inc.   NE     4.96       4.83       0.73       15.25       0.71       14.82       0.82       60.52       9.44       135.73       6.73       139.58       9.71       1.44       6.08       57.37  

UBCP

  United Bancorp, Inc.   MW     7.86       7.79       0.91       12.02       0.86       11.28       1.05       65.60       11.84       141.57       11.13       143.01       12.67       0.78       4.88       69.63  

UBSI

  United Bankshares, Inc.   SE     16.28       10.86       1.52       9.25       1.51       9.20       0.30       328.62       12.44       112.04       18.24       178.81       12.51       1.52       3.44       42.30  

UCB

  United Community Banks, Inc.   SE     12.97       9.87       1.21       9.42       1.27       9.87       0.33       228.43       12.08       107.58       13.95       146.43       11.52       1.00       3.07       36.76  

UNTY

  Unity Bancorp, Inc.   MA     11.83       11.77       2.21       18.19       2.03       16.70       1.04       110.68       9.33       155.43       18.38       156.32       10.16       0.64       1.15       10.44  

UVSP

  Univest Financial Corporation   MA     11.69       9.72       1.16       10.27       1.15       10.22       0.46       668.97       12.50       122.25       14.29       150.27       12.56       0.92       2.21       26.73  

USCB

  USCB Financial Holdings, Inc.   SE     7.84       7.84       1.00       12.51       1.22       15.28       0.13       717.09       13.39       156.61       12.29       156.61       10.97       0.50       2.61       31.47  

VLY

  Valley National Bancorp   MA     12.14       9.41       1.04       8.54       1.04       8.59       0.68       135.10       12.69       104.50       12.18       141.23       12.62       0.44       3.12       39.64  

VABK

  Virginia National Bankshares Corporation   SE     11.32       10.76       1.23       11.26       1.28       11.73       0.13       371.73       12.12       130.00       14.71       137.52       11.63       1.44       3.22       39.02  

WAFD

  WaFd, Inc.   WE     10.81       9.35       0.94       8.33       0.96       8.55       0.48       163.05       11.92       100.48       9.88       120.51       11.59       1.08       2.96       35.29  

WASH

  Washington Trust Bancorp, Inc.   NE     8.47       7.49       0.79       9.81       0.80       9.92       0.63       101.70       12.79       121.61       10.29       138.89       12.66       2.24       6.41       82.05  

WSBF

  Waterstone Financial, Inc.   MW     15.47       15.44       1.32       8.45       1.32       8.45       0.35       236.62       11.57       100.11       15.48       100.30       11.57       0.68       3.54       28.31  

WFC

  Wells Fargo & Company   WE     8.17       7.06       1.07       11.90       1.02       11.49       0.40       163.70       12.69       154.49       11.51       184.38       13.30       1.80       2.15       27.78  

WSBC

  WesBanco, Inc.   SE     14.81       9.14       1.17       8.07       1.42       9.82       0.53       144.84       11.71       90.70       12.80       163.77       9.50       1.52       4.19       48.71  

WTBA

  West Bancorporation, Inc.   MW     6.75       6.75       0.87       14.03       0.95       15.28       0.00       NM       12.10       156.73       10.58       156.73       11.12       1.00       4.01       48.54  

WABC

  Westamerica Bancorporation   WE     15.05       13.25       1.86       11.00       1.87       11.02       0.02       957.17       12.86       154.55       23.26       179.26       12.83       1.92       3.33       41.43  

WAL

  Western Alliance Bancorporation   WE     8.00       7.39       1.07       12.68       0.93       11.52       0.62       93.72       9.30       119.25       8.88       130.79       10.71       1.68       2.14       19.09  

WNEB

  Western New England Bancorp, Inc.   NE     8.97       8.53       0.65       7.29       0.64       7.17       0.17       436.89       15.37       111.61       10.02       118.01       15.61       0.28       2.05       31.46  

WTFC

  Wintrust Financial Corporation   MW     10.23       9.10       1.26       12.16       1.28       12.36       0.26       234.04       12.92       149.47       14.49       171.43       12.69       2.20       1.43       17.60  

WSFS

  WSFS Financial Corporation   MA     12.28       8.29       1.44       11.40       1.53       12.02       0.40       239.66       13.19       141.91       17.48       219.34       12.46       0.80       1.08       12.63  

ZION

  Zions Bancorporation, National Association   SW     8.29       7.15       1.07       14.05       1.02       13.37       0.33       239.07       10.29       134.61       11.07       158.48       10.82       1.80       2.72       27.99  

MHCs

                                   

BSBK

  Bogota Financial Corp.   MA     16.19       16.18       0.23       1.48       0.23       1.50       1.52       19.32       52.88       81.71       13.23       81.76       52.10       NA       NA       NM  

CLBK

  Columbia Financial, Inc.   MA     10.66       NA       0.51       4.92       0.55       5.26       0.43       166.19       36.42       177.72       18.95       199.92       34.07       NA       NA       NM  

GCBC

  Greene County Bancorp, Inc.   MA     8.41       8.41       1.29       15.72       NA       NA       0.10       708.69       12.85       187.20       15.75       187.20       NA       0.40       1.41       17.47  

KFFB

  Kentucky First Federal Bancorp   MW     13.26       13.26       0.38       2.88       0.38       2.88       0.62       95.73       30.00       83.05       11.01       83.05       30.00       0.00       0.00       NM  

PBFS

  Pioneer Bancorp, Inc.   MA     14.79       14.32       0.93       6.23       1.00       6.68       0.40       292.04       21.11       130.50       19.31       135.53       19.72       NA       NA       NM  

RBKB

  Rhinebeck Bancorp, Inc.   MA     10.79       10.63       0.77       7.51       0.78       7.53       0.27       227.65       19.33       141.50       15.27       143.92       19.26       NA       NA       NM  

TFSL

  TFS Financial Corporation   MW     11.00       10.95       0.54       4.84       0.54       4.84       0.22       201.77       49.76       239.56       26.35       240.78       49.76       1.13       6.88       342.42  

WSBK

  Winchester Bancorp, Inc.   NE     11.27       11.27       0.23       2.07       0.42       3.78       NA       272.17       28.70       102.98       11.61       102.98       42.06       NA       NA       NM  

Under Acquisition

                                 

AFBI

  Affinity Bancshares, Inc.   SE     14.00       12.30       0.95       6.98       0.99       7.26       NA       251.88       16.45       106.07       14.85       123.12       15.80       NA       NA       NM  

FBIZ

  First Business Financial Services, Inc.   MW     8.80       8.56       1.25       14.31       1.25       14.25       0.94       90.44       9.94       136.77       11.68       141.12       9.98       1.36       2.29       20.76  

FSEA

  First Seacoast Bancorp, Inc.   NE     10.63       10.61       -0.13       -1.20       -0.12       -1.16       0.07       831.80       NM       125.73       13.37       126.08       NM       NA       NA       NM  

FSUN

  FirstSun Capital Bancorp   SW     13.72       12.73       1.14       8.49       NA       NA       0.82       139.75       10.68       86.01       11.80       93.82       NA       NA       NA       NM  

NFBK

  Northfield Bancorp, Inc.   MA     12.11       12.11       0.08       0.67       0.68       5.43       0.37       176.68       120.08       86.63       10.49       86.63       14.84       0.52       3.61       433.33  

NSTS

  NSTS Bancorp, Inc.   MW     29.59       29.59       -0.04       -0.12       -0.04       -0.12       0.10       386.93       NM       90.40       26.74       90.40       NM       NA       NA       NM  

STEL

  Stellar Bancorp, Inc.   SW     15.32       10.69       0.98       6.41       1.16       7.60       0.53       176.73       18.75       117.31       17.97       177.17       15.81       0.60       1.57       28.78  

WBS

  Webster Financial Corporation   NE     11.19       7.74       1.24       10.79       1.28       11.18       0.61       140.36       12.38       131.91       14.37       201.16       11.94       1.60       2.13       26.19  

 

(1)

Average of High/Low or Bid/Ask price per share. 

(2)

Or since offering price if converted of first listed in the past 52 weeks. Percent change figures are actual year-to-date and are not annualized. 

(3)

EPS (earnings per share) is based on actual trailing 12 month data and is not shown on a pro forma basis.  

(4)

Exludes intangibles (such as goodwill, value of core deposits, etc.).  

(5)

ROA (return on assets) and ROE (return on equity) are indicated ratios based on trailing 12 month common earnings and average common equity and total assets balances. 

(6)

Annualized based on last regular quarterly cash dividend announcement. 

(7)

Indicated dividend as a percent of trailing 12 month earnings. 

(8)

Excluded from averages due to actual or rumored acquisition activities or unusual operating characteristics. 

(9)

For MHC institutions, market value reflects share price multiplied by public (non-MHC) shares. 

Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence and RP® Financial, LC. calculations. The information provided in this table has been obtained from sources we believe are reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of such information.

Copyright (c) 2026 by RP® Financial, LC. 


 

EXHIBIT 2

Pro Forma Analysis Sheet


EXHIBIT 2

PRO FORMA ANALYSIS SHEET

Columbia Financial, Inc.

Prices as of June 18, 2026

 

               Subject
at Midpoint
    Peer Group     New Jersey     All Public  

Valuation Midpoint Pricing
Multiples

        Symbol   Mean     Median     Mean     Median     Mean     Median  

Price-earnings multiple

   =    P/E      25.84x       13.34x       13.16x       14.45x       13.05x       13.32x       12.49x  

Price-core earnings multiple

   =    P/CE      19.85x       13.17x       12.82x       13.76x       12.36x       12.49x       11.80x  

Price-book ratio

   =    P/B      86.66     118.03     120.48     97.82     95.26     127.33     119.55

Price-tangible book ratio

   =    P/TB      92.38     148.82     144.35     112.01     104.84     152.90     146.73

Price-assets ratio

   =    P /A      15.05     13.21     13.02     11.38     11.56     14.13     13.37

Valuation Parameters

 

Pre-Conversion Earnings (Y) (1)(2)

   $ 70,849,000       (12 Mths 3/26   ESOP Stock (% of Offering + Merger Shares Applied to Offering) (E)      3.00  

Pre-Conversion Core Earnings (YC) (1)

   $ 102,489,000       (12 Mths 3/26   Cost of ESOP Borrowings (S)      0.00  

Pre-Conversion Book Value (B) (1)

   $ 1,581,313,000       ESOP Amortization (T)      25.00       Years  

Pre-Conv. Tang. Book Value (B) (1)

   $ 1,387,727,000       Stock Program (% of Offering + Merger Shares Applied to Offering (M)      2.45  

Pre-Conversion Assets (A) (1)

   $ 16,453,984,000       Stock Programs Vesting (N)      7.00       Years  

Reinvestment Rate (R)

     3.92     Fixed Expenses    $ 9,000,000    

Tax rate (TAX)

     27.00     Variable Expenses (Blended Commission %)      1.67  

After Tax Reinvest. Rate (R)

     2.86     Percentage Sold (PCT)      73.1036  

Est. Conversion Expenses (X) (2)

     2.31     MHC Assets    $ 0    

Insider Purchases

   $ 2,500,000       Options as (% of Offering + Merger Shares Applied to Offering) (O1)      6.20  

Price/Share

   $ 10.00       Estimated Option Value (O2)      32.20  

Foundation Cash Contribution (FC)

   $ —        Option Vesting Period (O3)      7.00       Years  

Foundation Stock Contribution (FS)

   $ —        % of Options taxable (O4)      25.00  

Foundation Tax Benefit (FT)

   $ —            

Calculation of Pro Forma Value After Conversion

 

1. V=   

P/E * (Y - FC * R)

   V=    $ 2,709,270,170  
   1 -P/E * PCT * ((1-X-E-M-FS)*R -(1-TAX)*(E/T)  -(1-TAX)*(M/N)-(1-TAX*O4)*(O1*O2/O3)))      
2. V=   

P/Core E * (YC)

   V=    $ 2,709,270,170  
      1 -P/Core E * PCT *  ((1-X-E-M-FS)*R -(1-TAX)*(E/T) -(1-TAX)*(M/N)-(1-TAX*O4)*(O1*O2/O3)))          
3. V=      P/B * (B-FC+FT)           V=    $ 2,709,270,170  
     1 - P/B * PCT * (1-X-E-M)      
4. V=      P/TB * (B-FC+FT)           V=    $ 2,709,270,170  
     1 - P/TB * PCT * (1-X-E-M)      
5. V=      P/A * (A-FC+FT)            V=    $ 2,709,270,170  
     1 - P/A * PCT * (1-X-E-M)      

Shares

 

Conclusion

   2nd Step
Offering Shares
     2nd Step
Exchange
Shares
     Full
Conversion
Shares
     Merger
Shares
Issued To
Target
     Merger
Shares
Applied to
Offering
     Total Market
Capitalization
Shares
     Exchange
Ratio
     Merger Shares
Pct. Of Total
 

Maximum

     192,625,000        70,870,908        263,495,908        42,973,477        0        306,469,385        2.5340        14.02

Midpoint

     167,500,000        61,626,877        229,126,877        41,800,140        0        270,927,017        2.2035        15.43

Minimum

     142,375,000        52,382,845        194,757,845        41,800,140        0        236,557,985        1.8729        17.67

Adusted Minimum(4)

     100,574,860        52,382,845        194,757,845        0        41,800,140        194,757,845        1.8729        21.46

Market Value

 

Conclusion

   2nd Step Offering
Value
     2nd Step
Exchange Shares
Value
     Full Conversion
Value
     Merger Shares
Value
     Merger Shares
Applied to
Offering
     Total Market
Capitalization
Value
 

Maximum

   $ 1,926,250,000      $ 708,709,080      $ 2,634,959,080      $ 429,734,770        0      $ 3,064,693,850  

Midpoint

   $ 1,675,000,000      $ 616,268,770      $ 2,291,268,770      $ 418,001,400        0      $ 2,709,270,170  

Minimum

   $ 1,423,750,000      $ 523,828,450      $ 1,947,578,450      $ 418,001,400        0      $ 2,365,579,850  

Adjusted Minimum(4)

   $ 1,005,748,600      $ 523,828,450      $ 1,947,578,450      $ 0        418,001,400      $ 1,947,578,450  

 

(1)

Historical Columbia Financial and Northfield Bancorp combined, including merger adjustments and $5.651 million after-tax impact of funding the merger.

(2)

Estimated offering expenses at midpoint of the offering.

(4)

If Columbia Financial does not receive orders for 142,375,000 shares ini the subscription and community offerings, up to 41,800,140 of the unsubscribed shares may be applied to the acquisition of Northfied Bancorp. At the adusted minimum, it is assumed that 41,800,140 of the unsubscribed sharese are applied to the merger of Northfield Bancorp and 100,574,860 shares are sold for cash.


EXHIBIT 3

Pro Forma Effect of Conversion Proceeds


Exhibit 3

PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS

Columbia Financial, Inc.

At the Minimum of the Range

 

1.Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio                         

Fully Converted Value

         $ 2,365,579,850  

Exchange Ratio

           1.87295  

2nd Step Offering Proceeds

         $ 1,423,750,000  

Less: Estimated Offering Expenses

           36,311,000  
        

 

 

 

2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds

         $ 1,387,439,000  
2.Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds                         

Net Conversion Proceeds

         $ 1,387,439,000  

Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation

           0  

Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1)

           (42,712,500

Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2)

           (34,881,875
        

 

 

 

Net Cash Proceeds

         $ 1,309,844,625  

Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return

           2.86
        

 

 

 

Earnings Increase

         $ 37,482,514  

Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings

           0  

Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3)

           (1,247,205

Less: RRP Vesting (3)

           (3,637,681

Less: Option Plan Vesting (4)

           (3,786,449
        

 

 

 

Net Earnings Increase

         $ 28,811,179  
3.Pro Forma Earnings         Before
Conversion(5)
    Net
Earnings
Increase
     After
Conversion
 

12 Months ended March 31, 2026 (reported)

    $ 70,849,000     $ 28,811,179      $ 99,660,179  

12 Months ended March 31, 2026 (core)

    $ 102,489,000     $ 28,811,179      $ 131,300,179  
4.Pro Forma Net Worth   Before
Conversion(5)
    Net Cash
Proceeds
    Tax Benefit
and Other
     After
Conversion
 

March 31, 2026

  $ 1,581,313,000     $ 1,309,844,625     $ 0      $ 2,891,157,625  

March 31, 2026 (Tangible)

  $ 1,387,727,000     $ 1,309,844,625     $ 0      $ 2,697,571,625  
5.Pro Forma Assets   Before
Conversion(5)
    Net Cash
Proceeds
    Tax Benefit
and Other
     After
Conversion
 

March 31, 2026

  $ 16,453,984,000     $ 1,309,844,625     $ 0      $ 17,763,828,625  

 

(1)

Includes ESOP purchases of 4.0% of the second step offering.

(2)

Includes RRP purchases of 2.5% of the second step offering.

(3)

ESOP amortized over 25 years, RRP amortized over 7 years, tax effected at: 27.00%

(4)

Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 7 year vesting, and assuming 25% of the options are taxable.

(5)

Adjusted to reflect consolidation and reinvestment of net MHC assets.


Exhibit 3

PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS

Columbia Financial, Inc.

At the Midpoint of the Range

 

1. Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio                            

Fully Converted Value

            $ 2,709,270,170  

Exchange Ratio

              2.20347  

2nd Step Offering Proceeds

            $ 1,675,000,000  

Less: Estimated Offering Expenses

              38,622,500  
           

 

 

 

2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds

            $ 1,636,377,500  
2. Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds                            

Net Conversion Proceeds

            $ 1,636,377,500  

Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation

              0  

Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1)

              (50,250,000

Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2)

              (41,037,500
           

 

 

 

Net Cash Proceeds

            $ 1,545,090,000  

Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return

              2.86
           

 

 

 

Earnings Increase

            $ 44,214,295  

Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings

              0  

Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3)

              (1,467,300

Less: RRP Vesting (3)

              (4,279,625

Less: Option Plan Vesting (4)

              (4,454,646
           

 

 

 

Net Earnings Increase

            $ 34,012,725  
3. Pro Forma Earnings           Before
Conversion(5)
     Net
Earnings
Increase
     After Conversion  

12 Months ended March 31, 2026 (reported)

      $ 70,849,000      $ 34,012,725      $ 104,861,725  

12 Months ended March 31, 2026 (core)

      $ 102,489,000      $ 34,012,725      $ 136,501,725  
4. Pro Forma Net Worth    Before
Conversion (5)
     Net Cash Proceeds      Tax Benefit of
Foundation
     After Conversion  

March 31, 2026

   $ 1,581,313,000      $ 1,545,090,000      $ 0      $ 3,126,403,000  

March 31, 2026 (Tangible)

   $ 1,387,727,000      $ 1,545,090,000      $ 0      $ 2,932,817,000  
5. Pro Forma Assets    Before
Conversion (5)
     Net Cash Proceeds      Tax Benefit of
Foundation
     After Conversion  

March 31, 2026

   $ 16,453,984,000      $ 1,545,090,000      $ 0      $ 17,999,074,000  

 

(1)

Includes ESOP purchases of 4.0% of the second step offering. 

(2)

Includes RRP purchases of 2.5% of the second step offering.

(3)

ESOP amortized over 25 years, RRP amortized over 7 years, tax effected at: 27.00%

(4)

Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 7 year vesting, and assuming 25% of the options are taxable.

(5)

Adjusted to reflect consolidation and reinvestment of net MHC assets.


Exhibit 3

PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS

Columbia Financial, Inc.

At the Maximum of the Range

 

1. Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio                            

Fully Converted Value

            $ 3,064,693,850  

Exchange Ratio

              2.53399  

2nd Step Offering Proceeds

            $ 1,926,250,000  

Less: Estimated Offering Expenses

              43,069,625  
           

 

 

 

2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds

            $ 1,883,180,375  
2. Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds                            

Net Conversion Proceeds

            $ 1,883,180,375  

Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation

              0  

Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1)

              (57,787,500

Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2)

              (47,193,125
           

 

 

 

Net Cash Proceeds

            $ 1,778,199,750  

Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return

              2.86
           

 

 

 

Earnings Increase

            $ 50,884,964  

Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings

              0  

Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3)

              (1,687,395

Less: RRP Vesting (3)

              (4,921,569

Less: Option Plan Vesting (4)

              (5,122,843
           

 

 

 

Net Earnings Increase

            $ 39,153,158  
3. Pro Forma Earnings           Before
Conversion(5)
     Net
Earnings
Increase
     After
Conversion
 

12 Months ended March 31, 2026 (reported)

      $ 70,712,000      $ 39,153,158      $ 109,865,158  

12 Months ended March 31, 2026 (core)

      $ 102,352,000      $ 39,153,158      $ 141,505,158  
4. Pro Forma Net Worth    Before
Conversion (5)
     Net Cash
Proceeds
     Tax Benefit of
Foundation
     After
Conversion
 

March 31, 2026

   $ 1,576,430,000      $ 1,778,199,750      $ 0      $ 3,354,629,750  

March 31, 2026 (Tangible)

   $ 1,382,844,000      $ 1,778,199,750      $ 0      $ 3,161,043,750  
5. Pro Forma Assets    Before
Conversion (5)
     Net Cash
Proceeds
     Tax Benefit of
Foundation
     After
Conversion
 

March 31, 2026

   $ 16,462,630,000      $ 1,778,199,750      $ 0      $ 18,240,829,750  

 

(1)

Includes ESOP purchases of 4.0% of the second step offering.

(2)

Includes RRP purchases of 2.5% of the second step offering.

(3)

ESOP amortized over 25 years, RRP amortized over 7 years, tax effected at: 27.00%

(4)

Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 7 year vesting, and assuming 25% of the options are taxable.

(5)

Adjusted to reflect consolidation and reinvestment of net MHC assets.


Exhibit 3

PRO FORMA EFFECT OF CONVERSION PROCEEDS

Columbia Financial, Inc.

At the Adjusted Minimum of the Range

 

1. Fully Converted Value and Exchange Ratio                            

Fully Converted Value

            $ 1,947,578,450  

Exchange Ratio

              1.87295  

2nd Step Offering Proceeds

            $ 1,005,748,600  

Less: Estimated Offering Expenses

              39,779,139  
           

 

 

 

2nd Step Net Conversion Proceeds

            $ 965,969,461  
2. Estimated Additional Income from Conversion Proceeds                            

Net Conversion Proceeds

            $ 965,969,461  

Less: Cash Contribution to Foundation

              0  

Less: ESOP Stock Purchases (1)

              (42,712,500

Less: RRP Stock Purchases (2)

              (34,881,875
           

 

 

 

Net Cash Proceeds

            $ 888,375,086  

Estimated after-tax net incremental rate of return

              2.86
           

 

 

 

Earnings Increase

            $ 25,421,741  

Less: Consolidated interest cost of ESOP borrowings

              0  

Less: Amortization of ESOP borrowings(3)

              (1,247,205

Less: RRP Vesting (3)

              (3,637,681

Less: Option Plan Vesting (4)

              (3,786,449
           

 

 

 

Net Earnings Increase

            $ 16,750,406  
3. Pro Forma Earnings           Before
Conversion(5)
     Net Earnings
Increase
     After Conversion  

12 Months ended March 31, 2026 (reported)

      $ 70,849,000      $ 16,750,406      $ 87,599,406  

12 Months ended March 31, 2026 (core)

      $ 102,489,000      $ 16,750,406      $ 119,239,406  
4. Pro Forma Net Worth    Before
Conversion(5)
     Net Cash
Proceeds
     Tax Benefit
and Other
     After Conversion  

March 31, 2026

   $ 1,581,313,000      $ 888,375,086      $ 0      $ 2,469,688,086  

March 31, 2026 (Tangible)

   $ 1,387,727,000      $ 888,375,086      $ 0      $ 2,276,102,086  
5. Pro Forma Assets    Before
Conversion(5)
     Net Cash
Proceeds
     Tax Benefit
and Other
     After Conversion  

March 31, 2026

   $ 16,453,984,000      $ 888,375,086      $ 0      $ 17,342,359,086  

 

(1)

Includes ESOP purchases of 4.0% of the second step offering.

(2)

Includes RRP purchases of 2.5% of the second step offering.

(3)

ESOP amortized over 25 years, RRP amortized over 7 years, tax effected at: 27.00%

(4)

Option valuation based on Black-Scholes model, 7 year vesting, and assuming 25% of the options are taxable.

(5)

Adjusted to reflect consolidation and reinvestment of net MHC assets.


EXHIBIT 4

Firm Qualifications Statement


LOGO

FIRM QUALIFICATION STATEMENT

RP® Financial (“RP®) provides financial and management consulting, merger advisory and valuation services to the financial services industry nationwide. We offer a broad array of services, high quality and prompt service, hands-on involvement by principals and senior staff, careful structuring of strategic initiatives and sophisticated valuation and other analyses consistent with industry practices and regulatory requirements. Our staff maintains extensive background in financial and management consulting, valuation and investment banking. Our clients include commercial banks, thrifts, credit unions, mortgage companies, insurance companies and other financial services companies.

STRATEGIC PLANNING SERVICES

RP®’s strategic planning services are designed to provide effective feasible plans with quantifiable results. We analyze strategic options to enhance shareholder value, achieve regulatory approval or realize other objectives. Such services involve conducting situation analyses; establishing mission/vision statements, developing strategic goals and objectives; and identifying strategies to enhance franchise and/or market value, capital management, earnings enhancement, operational matters and organizational issues. Strategic recommendations typically focus on: capital formation and management, asset/liability targets, profitability, return on equity and stock pricing. Our proprietary financial simulation models provide the basis for evaluating the impact of various strategies and assessing their feasibility and compatibility with regulations.

MERGER ADVISORY SERVICES

RP®’s merger advisory services include targeting potential buyers and sellers, assessing acquisition merit, conducting due diligence, negotiating and structuring merger transactions, preparing merger business plans and financial simulations, rendering fairness opinions, preparing mark-to-market analyses, valuing intangible assets and supporting the implementation of post-acquisition strategies. Our merger advisory services involve transactions of financially healthy companies and failed bank deals. RP® is also expert in de novo charters and shelf charters. Through financial simulations, comprehensive data bases, valuation proficiency and regulatory familiarity, RP®’s merger advisory services center on enhancing shareholder returns.

VALUATION SERVICES

RP®’s extensive valuation practice includes bank and thrift mergers, thrift mutual-to-stock conversions, goodwill impairment, insurance company demutualizations, ESOPs, subsidiary companies, merger accounting and other purposes. We are highly experienced in performing appraisals which conform to regulatory guidelines and appraisal standards. RP® is the nation’s leading valuation firm for thrift mutual-to-stock conversions, with appraised values ranging up to $4 billion.

OTHER CONSULTING SERVICES

RP® offers other consulting services including evaluating the impact of regulatory changes (TARP, etc.), branching and diversification strategies, feasibility studies and special research. We assist banks/thrifts in preparing CRA plans and evaluating wealth management activities on a de novo or merger basis. Our other consulting services are facilitated by proprietary valuation and financial simulation models.

KEY PERSONNEL (Years of Relevant Experience & Contact Information)

 

Ronald S. Riggins, Managing Director (45)    (703) 647-6543    rriggins@rpfinancial.com
William E. Pommerening, Managing Director (41)    (703) 647-6546    wpommerening@rpfinancial.com
Gregory E. Dunn, Director (42)    (703) 647-6548    gdunn@rpfinancial.com
James P. Hennessey, Director (38)    (703) 647-6544    jhennessey@rpfinancial.com
James J. Oren, Director (38)    (703) 647-6549    joren@rpfinancial.com

 

 

 

Washington Headquarters   
1311-A Dolley Madison Boulevard    Telephone: (703) 528-1700
Suite 2A    Fax No.: (703) 528-1788
McLean, VA 22101    Toll-Free No.: (866) 723-0594
www.rpfinancial.com    E-Mail: mail@rpfinancial.com